The Whirled League – Baseball The Way It Never Was

TWIWBL 58.4: Cum Posey Division

On April 30, 2024

#Chicago American Giants

Kevin Mitchell began a rehab assignment at AAA, and was almost immediately recalled after Duffy Lewis hit the 10-Day DL with blurred vision.

Dick Allen had 4 hits including a walkoff 2 run homerun to lead the American Giants to an 8-7 come from behind victory over Portland.

#Los Angeles Angels

Bobby Grich hit his first 2 homeruns of the season in an 11-5 loss to San Francisco.

#Miami Cuban Giants

The Cuban Giants did it again, using Julio Rodríguez‘ second homerun of the game for their second walkoff victory to start the season. Rodríguez and Alejandro Oms had 3 hits each, with Sandy Consuegra picking up the victory.

The news wasn’t so good for Rodríguez later in the week as a nasty collision at second base left him with a bruised rib and a trip to the DL. The Cuban Giants recalled P Ed Brandt to take his roster slot.

#Portland Sea Dogs

Bobby Murcer hit his first 2 homeruns of the year in a 6-4 loss. The game was Johan Santana‘s second blown save in a row, and wasted a solid start from Bert Blyleven. Trevor Hoffman and Santana blew a 4-1 lead in the 8th inning.

It’s not clear which news is worse: Johan Santana had his third consecutive horrible outing to start the year, blowing his 3rd save, falling to 0-3, and seeing his ERA nearly reach triple digits at 94.50. In the same game, Rogers Hornsby suffered a separated shoulder and will miss several weeks. The Sea Dogs recalled veteran IF Jeff Cirillo to take Hornsby’s spot.

#San Francisco Sea Lions

The Sea Lions hit 5 homeruns–2 by Sal Bando–in an 11-5 win over Los Angeles. Bando had 3 hits and 4 RBI’s, Turkey Stearnes drove in 3, and Reggie Jackson had 3 hits, with Bando, Rickey Henderson, and Jimmy Bloodworth all going yard in a 6 run 6th inning.

Lefty Grove tossed the first complete game shutout of the season, twirling a masterful 3-hitter against Cleveland. Grove struck out 6, and homeruns by Stearnes and Jimmie Foxx were more than enough to lead the Sea Lions to victory.

TWIWBL 58.3: Bill James Division

By mknn

On April 29, 2024

In TWIWBL

#Baltimore Black Sox

Gavvy Cravath hit 2 homeruns, but it wasn’t enough as the Black Sox fell to Detroit, 5-4, in 10 innings.

#Detroit Wolverines

Mike Henneman continued his perfect start with his 2nd save in as many chances as Detroit pulled out a 5-4 win over Baltimore.

The Wolverines ran out of arms early, having to move Juan Beníquez to AAA bring up Claude Passeau for a start. Ty Cobb had 4 hits and 5 RBI’s as Detroit came back to grab a 7-5 win over Memphis. Passeau headed back to AAA after, with Beníquez returning.

#Memphis Red Sox

SP Dean Chance headed to the DL with an injured toe, which will cause him to miss at least his first 2 starts on the season. Eddie Cicotte was recalled from AAA New Orleans.

The Red Sox scored 10 runs in the 5th inning of their season opener, keyed by triples from Ted Williams, Bill White, and Wade Boggs, which is as unlikely a trio to hit 3 triples in an inning as you can find. Reggie Smith and Claude Ritchey had 3 hits each as Memphis came from behind to win 12 to 5. David Bush got the win with 4 effective innings in relief of a wild Stubby Overmire.

#New York Black Yankees

Babe Ruth went deep twice and drove in 6 as the Black Yankees came from 4 runs down to top Los Angeles, 9-5.

TWIWBL 58.2: OPENING DAY!

By mknn

On April 24, 2024

In TWIWBL

Welcome to the opening day of games in Year 2 of the WBL!

We’ll start with last year’s victors from the Whirled Series, as the Detroit Wolverines visit the champs, the Baltimore Black Sox, with the Wolverines’ Hal Newhouser opening their season against the Black Sox’s Dennis Martínez.

New Wolverine Charlie Gehringer opened the scoring with the first homerun of the season, a 3 run shot in the top of the 3rd, and Bob Bailey added an RBI single in the following frame to give Detroit a 4-0 lead.

El Presidente lurched through his 5 innings, giving up 7 hits and 4 runs while Newhouser was far better, allowing only 1 score in his 6 innings. Newhouser did walk 6 Black Sox, so there is some concern there.

Larry Gardner got one back with an RBI single for Baltimore in the bottom of the 5th, and then the Black Sox came all the way back against Chad Bradford in the bottom of the 8th, with singles from Curt Blefary and Ken Singleton driving in the runs to tie the game at 4.

So, opening day brought us extra innings!

Detroit would use a single from Hank Greenberg, a double from Al Kaline, and a sacrifice fly from Oscar Gamble to take a 5-4 lead in the 10th, and Mike Henneman–far from dependable last season–would shut down Baltimore on 5 pitches for his first save of the year and Detroit’s first win, 5-4.

The win went to Buddy Napier while Buddy Groom took the loss.

This was a great opening day for Detroit: the newcomers (Gehringer, Billy Hoeft) delivered and Henneman made the end look easy.

DET 5 (Napier 1-0; Henneman 1 Sv; Hoeft 1 H; Bradford 1 BSv) – BAL 4 (Groom 0-1) [10 Innings]
HRs: DET – Gehringer (1).

#Other Games

Jim Thome delivered a walkoff game winner against Portland’s closer, Johan Santana, as Miami came from behind to beat the Sea Dogs, 5-4.

POR 4 (Santana 0-1, 1 B Sv; Brown 1 B Sv) – MCG 5 (Terry 1-0)
HRs: POR – Hooper (1), Bell (1); MCG – Thome (1).

Homestead rode homeruns from Chris Sabo and Rick Reichardt and three hits from Josh Gibson (along with 3 errors by Philadelphia) in a 13-4 drubbing of the Stars. Francisco Liriano got the win with 5 decent innings and, perhaps more encouragingly, both Grays’ rookie arms–Doug Drabek and Tim Lincecum–were strong in relief.

HOM 13 (Liriano 1-0) – PHI 4 (Carlton 0-1)
HRs: HOM – Sabo (1), Reichardt (1).

Duke Snider went deep twice and John Briggs and Roy White added 3 hits apiece as Brooklyn gave Don Drysedale plenty of support in an 8-3 win over the New York Gothams. The only concern for the Royal Giants was reliever Dave Von Ohlen‘s departure in the 9th through injury.

NYG 3 (Mathewson 0-1) – BRK 8 (Drysedale 1-0; Von Ohlen 1 H)
HRs: NYG – Kauff (1); BRK – Snider 2 (2), Cey (1).

The House of David torched Roy Oswalt for 9 runs (5 earned) in the first 2 innings, and then held on for a 12 to 6 victory over Houston. Pete Browning had 3 hits, Ryne Sandberg drove in 3, and every starter had a hit in support of a mediocre start from Jack Taylor. Tony Gwynn had 3 hits for Houston.

HOU 6 (Oswalt 0-1) – HOD 12 (Taylor 1-0; Sabathia 1 Sv; Bauta 1 H)
HRs: HOU – Wynn (1); HOD – Sandberg (1).

TWIWBL 58.1: Draft Pick Updates

By mknn

On April 12, 2024

In TWIWBL

With opening day just around the corner, we thought it would be interesting to see how the draft worked out …

#Love ‘Em (Draft Picks Making Opening Day Rosters)

1st Round

Charles “Bullet Joe” Rogan, the overall #1 pick in the draft, makes Philadelphia’s opening day roster, expected to be their 4th OF and provide bullpen support. The Stars’ other first-rounder, Dave Stieb, made their opening day rotation.

Two outfielders were taken with the 7th and 8th picks, and both should be in their team’s opening day lineups, as San Francisco took CF Turkey Stearnes at 7 and Los Angeles RF Ichiro Suzuki at 8.

2nd Round

Miami took Julio Rodríguez with the 2nd pick in round 2 thinking the 19 year old would be a project for the future; instead he breaks camp as their starting CF.

Homestead’s Tim Lincecum makes the opening day roster in their bullpen, and Houston’s César Cedeño will start the season as their reserve OF (although this is expected to only last until George Brett‘s return from injury, but you never know).

Portland drafted 26 year old Walter Ball expecting him to be ready for the WBL, and he delivered, starting the season in their rotation.

Some mention should be made of Kansas City’s Matt Morris, who was expected to make their rotation before tearing his labrum.

3rd Round

Dobie Moore exploded on the scene for Memphis and should see essentially full time usage alternating between SS and 2B.

Philadelphia breaks camp with Bill Gatewood in the bullpen.

5th Round

The New York Black Yankees didn’t expect Noah Syndergaard to make the opening day roster, but he did.

Detroit is even more surprised at the performance and poise from 18 year old Billy Hoeft, who will start the season in their bullpen.

6th Round

Jess Barbour was a throw-in in the Albert Belle/Andy Pettitte trade, but his defensive flexibility and speed kept him around for Birmingham.

8th Round

Ottawa’s staff was essentially open going into Spring Training, so while Dupee Shaw making the team was a surprise, it wasn’t a shock.

The Black Yankees’ bench received a complete overhaul, with Elliot Maddox earning a spot out of the gate.

9th Round

Jack Billingham starts the season in Indianapolis’ bullpen.

12th Round

Indianapolis took Edward “The Only” Nolan with their final pick of the draft. Nolan starts the year on their staff as the WBL’s version if Mister Irrelevant.

#Leave ‘Em (Draft Picks No Longer With Original Organization)

Other than the inexplicable treatment of Chino Smith, this all looks fine. Topsy Hartsel should find a home somewhere, the rest may or may not.

1st Round: Vladimir Guerrero, OF (traded from MCG to POR)

2nd Round: Jon Matlack, P (traded from POR to MCG)

3rd Round: Topsy Hartsel, OF (BAL)

4th Round: Leo Cardenas, IF (IND); Bob Smith, P (BBB); Denard Span (traded from POR to OTT)

7th Round: Cass Michaels, IF (CAG)

8th Round: Ray Blades, OF (KCM); Chino Smith, IF (MEM, now with BAL); Lee Stange, P (POR, now with HOM)

9th Round: Justin Steel, P (HOD)

10th Round: Doug Bair, P (KCM); Greg Pryor, IF (BRK)

11th Round: Nick Allen, IF (SFS); Vern Kennedy, P (CAG); Eddie Solomon, P (BBB)

12th Round: Jeff Ballard, P (BBB); Craig Gentry, OF (CAG); Dave Lemanczyk, P (SFS); José Lopéz, 1B (MCG); Hal Mauck, P (HOD); Connor Seabold, P (MEM)

Year II Season Preview: Wandering House of David

By mknn

On April 7, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

A repeat of last year’s playoff contention, at a minimum.

Best Case

Starters are found to support repeat performances from Jack Taylor and Bob Rush; Pete Browning is healthy for a full season; Elrod Hendricks doesn’t backslide too much; and the OF talent figures itself out.

Worst Case

The pitching remains an open question; none of the marginal performers–Richie Hebner, Ron Santo, Ernie Banks–take a step forward and the pleasant surprises from last season–Jim Edmonds, Anthony Rizzo, Dan Ford–all regress and Hendricks falls off a cliff entirely.

Key Questions

How does the team integrate its considerable young talent into the roster as the season progresses?

As many as 8 spots on the pitching staff are available, as are the backup C and IF jobs.

Trade Bait

There is a lot of duplicate talent here, most of it in the minors. Sorting through all that is the major task of the organization over the next year or two.

The two trades made seem fine, netting some draft picks, an arm for the future (Claude Osteen), and a hopefully revitalized Sammy Sosa.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C	Hendricks					Chance
1B			Rizzo			Harris
2B		Sandberg			~~Grant~~	Cabrera
3B			Hebner Santo
SS			Banks
LF/ RF	Browning	Stone		Sosa
CF		Edmonds	Gore
SP	Taylor	Rush	Sullivan	Miley		Reuschel
End				Bauta Smith
RP			~~Sutter~~	Sabathia Wood	Jenkins	Gumbert

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

Above average, but needs some folks to step up dramatically on offense to reach the next level, and for the pitching to not regress at all. It’s possible–Sosa, Fergie Jenkins, Santo, and Banks all look like decent possibilities for upside.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	SS Ernie Banks	U Cody Bellinger
Batting Eye	OF George Gore	1B Mark McGwire
Contact	OF George Stone	1B Mark Grace
Running Speed	OF Sammy Sosa	OF Skeeter Barnes OF Tracy Jones
Base Stealing	U Frank Chance	OF Danny Green
IF Defense	U Bunny Downs	IF Deacon White
OF Defense	OF Pete Browning	OF Cy Williams
Stuff	P Kerry Wood	RP Ken McBride
Control	RP Ad Gumbert	SP Jim Clinton
Velocity	P CC Sabathia RP Lee Smith P Kerry Wood	RP Pedro Strop

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (2)	21	2B	Frank Grant
2 (9)	20	IF	Cap Anson
3 (14)	21	3B	Dave Malarcher
4 (47)	23	P	Karl Spooner
5 (57)	20	U	Cody Bellinger
6 (75)	21	P	Kyle Peterson
7 (118)	18	P	Larry Dierker
8 (152)	21	P	Bill Lee
9 (169)	20	P	Jocko Flynn
10 (190)	21	P	Frank Dwyer

Others: None.

It’s a top heavy system, which is what you want. Could use some more pitching, but overall the system is a strength.

	Most	Least
Age	P Early Wynn, 41	P Joe Nuxhall, 16
Height	P CC Sabathia, 6’7″	IF Bunny Downs, 5’5″
OPS	U Joe Harris .988 (WBL/AAA)	IF Ron Oester, .586 (AAA/AA)
HR	C Elrod Hendricks, 41 (WBL)	IF Frank Grant, 0 (WBL/AAA/AA)
SB	OF Pete Browning, 38 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	OF Pete Browning, 4.2 (WBL)	IF Johnny Giavotella, -1.3 (—)
W	Rick Reuschel, 15 (WBL/AAA) Bob Rush, 15 (WBL) Jack Taylor, 15 (WBL) Early Wynn, 15 (—)	Ross Detwiler, 4 (—) Bob Anderson, 4 (—)
SV	Bruce Sutter, 25 (WBL)
ERA	Bill Stoneman, 2.35 (—)	Bob Shaw, 6.87 (AAA/AA)
WAR	Early Wynn, 5.2 (—)	Eddie Rommel, -0.3 (WBL/AAA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Kansas City Monarchs

By mknn

On April 7, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

This team was so lost last season, that anything could feel like progress. But a .500 finish would be a start.

Best Case

Bob Gibson explodes onto the scene and additional quality arms are found somewhere while the offense continues to build around the core of Stan Musial, Albert Pujols, Willie McGee, and Boog Powell.

Worst Case

This turns into the worst pitching staff in the league and the offense just can’t compensate enough, especially if Pujols doesn’t make a step forward.

Key Questions

Who is going to fill out the rotation and the bullpen?
3B looks unsettled.
How does the competition between Ducky Medwick and Steve Evans pan out?

Trade Bait

Not enough talent to really be active.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C		Simmons				Ruel
1B		Powell				Murphy
2B				Canó	Frisch
3B			Pujols
SS				Smith
LF/ RF	Musial		Brock Evans Medwick			~~Rettenmund~~
CF				McGee
SP		Hamlin	Castillo	Rijo Wood		Gibson ~~Morris~~
End	Kimbrel	Pfeffer		DiPino
RP						A.R. Foster Guardado Hermanson Shawkey

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

It’s all pretty much apparent there: the offense, especially Albert Pujols, needs to shift left and the need for something positive to happen on the mound for the Monarchs to take a step forward. Gibson and A. Rube Foster becoming at least solid would be a huge boon.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	U Dale Murphy	1B Andre Thornton
Batting Eye	C Muddy Ruel	OF Fielder Jones
Contact	OF Stan Musial	IF Dave Cash
Running Speed	OF Lou Brock CF Willie McGee	OF Cool Papa Bell OF Jarrod Dyson U Rex Hudler CF Omar Moreno
Base Stealing	OF Lou Brock	OF Jarrod Dyson
IF Defense	IF Albert Pujols	IF Sam Mongin
OF Defense	OF Stan Musial	OF Fielder Jones
Stuff	P Smokey Joe Wood	P Larry French
Control	SP Luke Hamlin	P Jimmy Key
Velocity	RP Craig Kimbrel	P Giovanny Gallegos P Darren O’Day P Trevor Rosenthal

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (1)	21	OF	Wade Johnston
2 (6)	23	P	A. Rube Foster
3 (7)	20	OF	Cool Papa Bell
4 (11)	25	P	Jock Menefee
5 (35)	18	IF	Carlos Baerga
6 (41)	21	P	Matt Morris
7 (83)	22	IF	Sam Mongin
8 (97)	22	IF	Dink Mothel
9 (100)	25	OF	Merv Rettenmund
10 (116)	18	C	Johnny Bassler

Others: OFs Heliodoro Hidalgo, Earl Averill; IFs Dave Cash, Kolten Wong; Ps Bill Singer, Larry French.

Clearly one of the deeper systems in the league, but one that has some complications: Bell and Johnston are blocked, Morris is injured, and only Foster will start the season with the Monarchs. But the scouts are drooling over all these guys, and 9 in the top 100 is pretty incredible–and that doesn’t even include top draft pick Hilton Smith.

	Most	Least
Age	IF Jim Davenport, 37	C Johnny Bassler, 18 IF Carlos Baerga, 18
Height	P Adam Russell, 6’8″	OF Heliodoro Hidalgo, 5’6″
OPS	OF Stan Musial, .972 (WBL)	C Salvador Pérez, .572 (WBL)
HR	OF Merv Rettenmund, 28 (WBL/AAA)	C Muddy Ruel, 0 (—)
SB	OF Lou Brock, 49 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	OF Merv Rettenmund, 5.4 (WBL/AAA)	IF Ivy Olson, -1.4 (—)
W	Sheriff Blake, 16 (—)	AJ Schugel, 1 (—) Félix Hernández, 1 (WBL/AAA/AA)
SV	Adam Russell, 25 (WBL/AAA)
ERA	Sheriff Blake, 2.27 (—)	Dustin Hermanson, 15.35 (—)
WAR	Sheriff Blake, 5.2 (—)	AJ Schugel, -3.9 (—)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Houston Colt 45’s

By mknn

On April 7, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

Playoff contention. Houston was close this year, but at the end of the day, the offense was just too weak across the board, especially in their ability to hit for power.

Best Case

The raw offensive talent takes a massive step forward: George Brett, Tony Gwynn, Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Andrés Galarraga, and Pete Hill each have a shot at being superstars; at least a few of them need to do so. The pitching feels like a safer bet: there is enough talent here to weather some underperformance and some injuries and still be among the league’s best, especially if someone–newcomer Tug McGraw or incumbent Billy Wagner–steps up at closer.

Worst Case

The offence just trundles along being incredibly mediocre and the pitching regresses as well.

Key Questions

Can the bullpen perform? Some indications (McGraw, Chad Qualls, and Andrew Chafin‘s performance last year in small samples) are positive; others not so much (the size of those samples, Kent Tekulve‘s challenges).
Who emerges at C?

Trade Bait

There’s a lot of excess here, especially at 1B, but there’s also not a lot of clarity over what to do with it. This is one of the rare franchises with a lot of pitching depth, so that’s pretty valuable right there.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C				Posada		Castro
1B				Bagwell Galaragga
2B					Biggio Johnson	Adams
3B				~~Brett~~
SS					Correa
LF/ RF			Stengel	Hill	Gwynn
CF			Wynn			Cedeño
SP		Oswalt Strasburg	Ely Saberhagen Ramsey	Clemens
End			Wagner			McGraw
RP				~~Chafin~~ Lidge	Ellis Tekulve	~~Blue~~ ~~Clyde~~ Franco

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

This is a really unusual model, where the pitching is outperforming the offense. But it’s also a team without a lot of options: other than behind the plate, everyone–even the horribly underperforming HR Johnson–is projected to improve somewhat dramatically over the next few seasons.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	OF Pete Hill	OF Gorman Thomas
Batting Eye	C Jorge Posada	IF Lance Blankenship
Contact	OF Tony Gwynn	U Jim O’Rourke
Running Speed	IF HR Johnson	OF Wily Taveras
Base Stealing	OF César Cedeño	OF Walt Devoy OF Wily Taveras
IF Defense	U Russ Adams	SS Roy McMillan
OF Defense	OF Jim Wynn	CF Wily Taveras
Stuff	P Bones Ely P Toad Ramsey	P Bill Harper
Control	SP Bret Saberhagen	RP Roberto Osuna
Velocity	SP Stephen Strasburg	P Wade Davis P Chris Saenz

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (10)	19	P	Ice Box Chamberlain
2 (27)	21	3B	Edgar Martínez
3 (48)	20	P	Vida Blue
4 (55)	23	C	Will Smith
5 (65)	21	P	Collin McHugh
6 (72)	20	P	Larry Jansen
7 (82)	18	CF	César Cedeño
8 (89)	20	P	Harry Staley
9 (91)	21	P	Scott Bankhead
10 (161)	25	CF	Kirby Puckett

Others: 1B Charlie Grimm; P Bill Harper; P Kyle Kendrick.

And this doesn’t even include Pete Hill or Leon Day, both still teenagers as well. It’s a deep system, with some star potential scattered throughout.

	Most	Least
Age	OF Gene Woodling, 40	OF César Cedeño, 18
Height	P Ryan Thompson, 6’6″	P George Winter, 5’8″ OF Kirby Puckett, 5’8″ U Jim O’Rourke, 5’8″
OPS	1B Harry Stovey, 1.042 (WBL/AAA/AA)	SS Roy McMillan, .352 (—)
HR	1B Harry Stovey, 31 (WBL/AAA/AA) OF Gorman Thomas, 31 (AAA)	IF Cristian Guzmán, 2 (AAA/AA)
SB	OF Jim Wynn, 45 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	1B Harry Stovey, 4.8 (WBL/AAA/AA)	SS Roy McMillan, -5.9 (—)
W	Guy Bush, 15 (—)	Ian Kennedy, 1 (—)
SV	John Franco, 34 (A)
ERA	Guy Bush, 3.27 (—)	George Winter, 9.13 (—)
WAR	George Kahler, 4.5 (—)	George Winter, -1.0 (—)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Indianapolis ABC’s

By mknn

On April 7, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

Playing .500 ball would be a nice step; doing so while nurturing some talent for the future would begin to raise hopes in Indianapolis.

Best Case

Some starting pitching comes out of nowhere to support the continued development of Doc White and Willie Mitchell, Johnny Bench and Oscar Charleston anchor the offense, and some of the MI talent finally emerges fully onto the scene. The 6 man rotation turns out to be a thing of beauty, allowing the ABC’s to maximize their talent on the mound.

Worst Case

Only Bench remains as a real offensive force and the pitching stays totally muddled, with the 6 man rotation confusing fans, pundits, and players alike.

Key Questions

Who starts, and does the team retain its experimentation with a 6-man rotation?
How do the uncertainties at SS/3B resolve?

Trade Bait

Not enough talent to really be active.

Davey Concepción was sent to the Gothams in exchange for Sad Sam Jones, adding another arm to the pile and clearing one person from the MI crowd.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C	Bench					Ritter
1B			Votto
2B			Morgan
3B				Charles
SS			Menke		Larkin
LF/ RF			Bescher Charleston			Dunn Foster Padrón
CF		Stenzel	Henderson
SP			Cueto	White Mitchell ~~Faber~~	Foster Jones	Padrón
End		~~Dibble~~	Carroll		James
RP				Tidrow		Bellingham Blackwell Nolan

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

That is a lot of new arms on the staff, and a lot of unknowns. But performance last year was so bad, you would think anything would be an improvement.

Some interesting things here, though: the continued use of the 6 man rotation, the emergence of Luis Padrón as a 2-way threat, the promise of some of the young talent, especially Oscar Charleston.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	C Johnny Bench	OF Wally Post
Batting Eye	IF Joe Morgan 1B Joey Votto	IF Edwin Encarnación
Contact	IF Joe Morgan	CF Edd Roush
Running Speed	OF Bob Bescher	IF Pokey Reese
Base Stealing	OF Bob Bescher	1B Doc Hoblitzell
IF Defense	IF Barry Larkin	3B Robin Ventura
OF Defense	OF Oscar Charleston	OF Curt Walker
Stuff	P The Only Nolan	P George Pipgras
Control	SP Johnny Cueto	SP Eppa Rixey
Velocity	RP Ewell Blackwell	RP Tyler Clippard

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (24)	19	P	Edward Nolan
2 (28)	19	P	Jim Maloney
3 (42)	22	3B	Oliver Marcell
4 (59)	24	3B	Robin Ventura
5 (101)	22	OF	George Foster
6 (105)	20	2B	Dario Lodigiani
7 (123)	19	P	Tom Glavine
8 (144)	23	1B	Sean Casey
9 (153)	25	P	Bob Ewing
10 (182)	25	P	Chris Hammond

Others: None.

Nolan and Foster start the year with the WBL club. There’s decent help on the mound working through the system, but little else, especially if Ventura ends up being a bust.

	Most	Least
Age	OF Harold Baines, 39	3B Bob Aspromonte, 18
Height	P Ewell Blackwell, 6’6″ OF Adam Dunn, 6’6″	SS Donie Bush, 5’6″
OPS	C Johnny Bench, .951 (WBL)	SS Walt Weiss, .441 (—)
HR	OF Adam Dunn, 35 (WBL/AAA/AA)	SS Walt Weiss, 0 (—)
SB	OF Bob Bescher, 37 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	C Johnny Bench, 6.0 (WBL)	SS Walt Weiss, -3.9 (—)
W	Eppa Rixey, 16 (WBL/AAA)	Joe Moeller, 3 (—) Teddy Higuera, 3 (—)
SV	Rob Dibble, 30 (WBL)
ERA	Jack Powell, 2.83 (—)	Joe Moeller, 7.11 (—)
WAR	Virgil Trucks, 7.0 (WBL/AAA)	Brad Radke, -1.1 (—)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Birmingham Black Barons

By mknn

On April 7, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

Pretty hard question: nobody expected a playoff run last season, now the fans will demand a repeat, but if the Black Barons can’t address some core offensive issues, that may be unlikely.

Best Case

The pitching continues to dominate, Juan Rincón holds down the closer spot, and either Sam Streeter or Warren Spahn step up to seize the 5th starting spot. On the other side, Hank Aaron and Eddie Mathews move into the elite of the league and someone–anyone–steps up to support them.

Worst Case

The pitching falls apart, with Andy Pettitte and Alejandro Peña becoming solid, but no longer world-beaters and the bullpen collapses while the offense continues to be far too slapdash to be dependable.

Key Questions

How will some key pieces for last season–Pettitte, Rincón, Adrián González, Cupid Childs, Jim Pagliaroni–perform over the course of a full year.
With Andy Pettitte traded, how does the rotation respond and does Albert Belle perform at a level that makes it worthwhile.
Who will fill out the roster.

Trade Bait

The Black Barons would happily welcome an offensive star, but would have to mortgage their farm system to get one. Or, mortgage their best starter … which in a bit of a shock, is exactly what they ended up doing. It’s an interesting gambit: a true top of rotation star gone in exchange for a “win-now” bat (but Belle is aging) and a few arms for the future in Lefty Gomez and Frank Viola. We’ll see.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C				Pagliaroni Tenace
1B			González	McCormick		Beckley
2B						Childs
3B		Mathews
SS			Long	Tulowitzki
LF/ RF		Aaron Belle	Nieman			Barbour Pafko
CF				Granderson
SP		Peña	Maddux Willis		Streeter	Malarkey
End			Bedrosian Rincón
RP				Benton Chen ~~Young~~		Gomez ~~Malloy~~ Whitney

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

Doesn’t look like a strong playoff contender to me. Now, if 3 to 4 players shift left one column … there’s just so much uncertainty. Six new faces, plus Belle, and while most of them are in reserve roles, it feels like a lot to ask for the Black Barons to repeat last year’s success.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	3B Eddie Mathews	1B Nate Colbert
Batting Eye	3B Eddie Mathews	OF John Titus
Contact	OF Hank Aaron	3B Pie Traynor
Running Speed	SS Herman Long	OF Rajai Davis
Base Stealing	SS Herman Long	OF Rajai Davis
IF Defense	SS Herman Long	3B Pie Traynor
OF Defense	OF Andy Pafko	OF Billy Southworth
Stuff	SP Sam Streeter	RP Bill James
Control	SP Jim Whitney	RP Johnny Ryan
Velocity	RP Juan Rincón	RP Kerry Ligtenberg

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (32)	24	P	Jim Whitney
2 (36)	20	C	Joe Torre
3 (43)	20	U	Jess Barbour
4 (54)	20	2B	Trea Turner
5 (58)	25	OF	Curt Flood
6 (62)	21	P	Cozy Dolan
7 (63)	26	P	Rube Melton
8 (151)	22	P	Alex Malloy
9 (156)	19	2B	Marcus Giles
10 (173)	21	P	Jonathan Pettibone

Others: OF Melky Cabrera; P Steve Avery.

Whitney, Dolan, Malloy, and Barbour start the season in the WBL (Malloy on the DL, but still). This is very much a make or break year for Flood.

	Most	Least
Age	OF Sam Rice, 37	SP Steve Avery, 18
Height	P Dustin Nippert, 6’8″	OF Al Schweitzer, 5’6″
OPS	OF Max Kepler, 1.233 (—)	IF Gerry Jestadt, .604 (—)
HR	OF Max Kepler, 61 (—)	IF George McBride, 1 (AAA) OF Rajai Davis, 1 (AAA/AA) OF Brock Davis 1 (AA)
SB	OF Billy Southworth, 26 (WBL/AAA)	Many with 0
WAR	1B Nate Colbert, 4.4 (WBL/AAA/AA)	IF Gerry Jestadt, -2.0 (—)
W	Bill Phyle, 17 (—)	Harry Matuzak, 1 (—)
SV	Juan Rincón, 26 (WBL)
ERA	Aaron Sanchez, 1.98 (—)	Johnny Ryan, 6.90 (AA)
WAR	Aaron Sanchez, 7.3 (—)	Fred Fussell, -0.8 (WBL/AAA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Brooklyn Royal Giants

By mknn

On April 6, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

Improvement, meaning again being in the playoff hunt at the end, but perhaps it being far less of a longshot/surprise.

Best Case

The juggling of the pitching staff works perfectly, with Smokey Joe Williams and ~~Watty Clark~~ Orel Hershiser joining Don Drysedale and Frank Knauss to provide a dependable, top of the league rotation helped by a continually improving Sandy Koufax. This implies that Eric Gagne‘s conversion to closer goes well.

The offense finds its soul, helped by the acquisition of Pedro Guerrero.

Worst Case

Knauss, ~~Clark~~, and Koufax regress and Williams doesn’t step up, leaving only Drysedale as a dependable starter and the offense continues to just meander along without any real oomph. The acquisition of Guerrero fails to deliver.

Key Questions

In addition to the pitching staff changes mentioned above, the rest of the roster is very much in flux.
Can John Briggs continue to set the world on fire?
Will Mike Piazza finally take hold of the starting C role?

Trade Bait

Unsure? There is a bit of a logjam in the OF right now, maybe that could be solved.

Instead, the Royal Giants doubled down on the logjam, adding Guerrero to the mix. It’s unlikely Clark’s value is ever higher than it is right now, so it’s not a bad moment to make the move.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C				Piazza		Bertell
1B			Robinson
2B			Isbell
3B			Cey
SS			~~Smith~~	Dandridge		Wills
LF/ RF		Becker Guerrero
CF			Briggs Snider White	Griggs
SP	Drysedale	Knauss		Hershiser Koufax		Williams
End		Gagne ~~Hildenberger~~	Dreifort Von Ohlen
RP						Forster Grimes Mateo Valenzuela

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

Very middle of the road imo. There is a lot of uncertainty on the mound, with a bunch of new faces and others whose ability to replicate their success from last season remains firmly in doubt.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	OF Duke Snider	1B Jim Gentile
Batting Eye	OF John Briggs	C Jim French
Contact	OF Pedro Guerrero	1B Dan Brouthers
Running Speed	SS Maury Wills	SS Sonny Jackson
Base Stealing	2B Frank Isbell	2B Davey Lopes
IF Defense	IF Jackie Robinson	1B Eric Karros
OF Defense	OF Roy White	OF Chicken Wolf
Stuff	SP Sandy Koufax	RP Lefty Thomas
Control	CL Eric Gagne	RP Trevor Hildenberger
Velocity	CL Eric Gagne	SP Walker Buehler

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (3)	20	2B	Ed Delahanty
2 (5)	23	P	Smokey Joe Williams
3 (15)	21	P	Doc Newton
4 (51)	22	P	Walker Buehler
5 (84)	21	OF	John Briggs
6 (108)	22	P	Dazzy Vance
7 (125)	24	OF	Terry Moore
8 (147)	24	P	Fernando Valenzuela
9 (162)	24	P	Dustin McGowan
10 (165)	20	OF	Al Simmons

Others: RP Jesús Colome, P Chris Short.

Williams, Briggs, and Valenzuela all break camp with the WBL team. Given the scarcity of offense in the system, both Delahanty and Simmons may see time this season.

	Most	Least
Age	2B Julio Franco, 39	P Odalis Pérez, 19 P Hilly Flitcroft
Height	P Don Drysedale, 6’6″ P Tommy Hanson, 6’6″	P Bobby Shantz, 5’6″
OPS	1B Justin Smoak, 1.101 (—)	SS César Izturis, .527 (AAA/AA)
HR	1B Justin Smoak, 64 (—)	SS César Izturis, 0 (AAA/AA) OF Art Griggs, 0 (WBL/AAA)
SB	OF Beals Becker, 49 (WBL)
WAR	1B Jim Gentile, 5.0 (—)	SS Germany Smith, -1.0 (WBL/AAA)
W	Josh Outman, 14 (—) Jordan Zimmerman, 14 (AAA)	Tom Phoebus, 2 (—) Dick Redding, 2 (WBL/AAA)
SV	Red Evans, 23 (—)
ERA	Darren Dreifort, 2.03 (WBL/AAA)	Tom Sullivan, 8.09 (—)
WAR	Bobby Shantz, 5.9 (—)	Tom Sullivan, -2.0 (—)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.