Month: April 2024

Year II Season Preview: Homestead Grays

On April 6, 2024

Expectations

Progress. Finishing over .500 with some clarity on long-term talent would be a success for next year.

Best Case

The roster stabilizes, and a handful of talent establishes itself as the core of future years. Napolean Lajoie and Honus Wagner settle in at 2B and SS respectively, and the OF talent clarifies. And, anyone reliable steps forward on the mound. Anyone.

Worst Case

Nothing settles, nobody figures it out, and the pitching continues to be miserable.

Key Questions

Who pitches?
For a team without top end talent, there are a surprising number of logjams (Davey Johnson and Lajoie and even the ageless Jeff Kent at 2B; Rick Reichardt and Willie Stargell at LF; Roberto Clemente, Andy Van Slyke, and Owen “Don’t Call Me Chief” Wilson in RF).

Trade Bait

Will the team hit it stride in time for Stargell to contribute? If not, he could be an attractive piece for a competitive team.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C		Gibson			Crandall
1B	Epstein
2B					Lajoie
3B						Sabo
SS				Wagner		Sánchez
LF/ RF		Reichardt	Van Slyke Wilson	Clemente Stargell
CF				McCutchen
SP			Liriano	Friend	Pierce Brown Zambrano	~~Kluber~~
End				Lindblom Ownbey	Jackson
RP						Drabek Giusti Hudson Lincecum

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

So. Much. Talent. So little production. Even with that, though, the presence of anything approaching average pitching makes the Grays a .500 team.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	OF Willie Stargell	3B Steve Hertz
Batting Eye	1B Mike Epstein	OF Ralph Kiner
Contact	OF Roberto Clemente	OF Goose Goslin
Running Speed	OF Andy Van Slyke	OF Sterling Marte
Base Stealing	IF Honus Wagner	IF Bobby Wheelock
IF Defense	U Nap Lajoie	IF Rennie Stennett
OF Defense	OF Roberto Clemente	OF Max Carey
Stuff	P Tim Lincecum	P Harry Kelley
Control	SP Bob Friend	P Syl Johnson
Velocity	RP Josh Lindblom	RP Mychal Givens

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (13)	19	P	Clayton Kershaw
2 (21)	21	P	Tim Lincecum
3 (39)	18	3B	Judy Johnson
4 (46)	19	OF	Ralph Kiner
5 (61)	24	P	Bartolo Colón
6 (64)	20	P	Pink Hawley
7 (79)	23	OF	Paul Waner
8 (109)	22	P	Trevor Cahill
9 (117)	23	P	Daniel Hudson
10 (130)	20	3B	Freddie Lindstrom

Others: P Catfish Hunter; P Nip Winters, P Ping Gardner; P Carlos Pulido; P Chris Zachary; P Dave Giusti.

Hope for the Grays persists, largely in how dense and deep their system is. 16 prospects in the top 200 bodes well for their future.

	Most	Least
Age	P Al Worthington, 38	3B Judy Johnson, 18
Height	P John Candelaria, 6’7″	P Earl Hamilton, 5’8″ SS Bobby Wheelock, 5’8″ OF Paul Waner, 5’8″ 1B Eric McNair, 5’8″
OPS	OF Harvey Hendrick, 1.088 (—)	IF Ken Harrelson, .432 (WBL)
HR	OF Starling Marte, 42 (—) IF JJ Hardy, 42 (—)	C Peaches Graham, 0 (WBL/AAA)
SB	CF Andrew McCutchen, 33 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	OF Andy Van Slyke, 5.7 (WBL/AAA/AA)	IF Ken Harrelson, -4.3 (WBL)
W	Frank Arellanes, 15 (—) Moose Haas, 15 (—)	Daniel Hudson, 3 (WBL/AAA/AA) Earl Hamilton, 3 (WBL/AAA) Doug Drabek 3 (—) John Candelaria, 3 (WBL/AAA)
SV	Mychal Givens, 24 (WBL/AAA/AA)
ERA	Charles Nagy, 2.17 (—)	John Candelaria, 6.84 (WBL/AAA)
WAR	Charles Nagy, 5.3 (—)	John Candelaria, -1.1 (WBL/AAA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: New York Gothams

By mknn

On April 6, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

A deep playoff run, much like last year.

The Gothams could also benefit from additional depth throughout the organization and, perhaps, by not trading away all their damn picks this year.

Best Case

Either Gaylord Perry or Juan Marichal (or both) step forward, joining Christy Mathewson among the league’s elite; the bullpen continues to dominate; and the offensive pieces that clicked last season–Pete Runnels, Pinky Higgins, Jimmy Sheckard, Johnny Callison–continue to do so (or are covered through increased performance/playing time for George Van Haltren or Carl Furillo in the OF).

Worst Case

The bullpen falters, and only Matty remains viable as a starter while everyone not named Willie Mays and Buster Posey struggles offensively.

Key Questions

Like so many other teams, the rotation is key.
The infield feels fragile, so how that plays out will bear watching.
How will the Gothams get PA’s for Benny Kauff?

Trade Bait

The Gothams do have a lot of OFers lying around, but it’s not clear who is actually surplus to requirements. With Kauff’s emergense, perhaps one of the Sheckard / Callison / Van Haltren group, or maybe last year’s 4th OF, Carl Furillo?

Instead, in an attempt to solve their MI issue, the Gothams obtained Davey Concepción, who promptly disappointed and was jettisoned to the minors.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C		Posey	Westrum
1B		Adcock		Clark
2B			Runnels			Doyle
3B			Higgins		Suárez
SS					Crawford
LF/ RF		Callison	Van Haltren Sheckard	Furillo
CF	Mays					Kauff
SP	Mathewson	Perry		Marichal Waddell
End	Norris ~~Wilson~~	Nen ~~Smith~~				Percival
RP			Howe Sutton			Hubbell

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

There’s a chance, right? A few improvements, and the Gothams could be in the mix.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	CF Willie Mays	OF Wally Berger IF Jim Ray Hart
Batting Eye	C Wes Westrum	C Dick Dietz
Contact	IF Pete Runnels	1B Bill Terry
Running Speed	OF Jimmy Sheckard	OF Charlie Hamburg IF Pat Listach IF Freddie Patek IF Tim Shinnick OF Kyle Tucker
Base Stealing	OF George Van Haltren	IF Hap Myers IF Tim Shinnick
IF Defense	IF Eugenio Suárez	IF Neifi Pérez
OF Defense	CF Willie Mays	OF Jo-Jo Moore
Stuff	SP Christy Mathewson	P William VanLandingham
Control	P Juan Marichal	P Al Spalding
Velocity	RP Robb Nen RP Troy Percival	P Rick Helling

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (53)	24	P	Masahiro Tanaka
2 (56)	19	OF	Kyle Tucker
3 (60)	22	P	William VanLandingham
4 (86)	25	P	Al Spalding
5 (104)	22	SS	Joe Sullivan
6 (112)	23	P	Jordan Montgomery
7 (155)	21	IF	Tom Burns

Others: None.

A very weak system in need of some serious replenishment, although Tucker and a couple of the arms should come good eventually.

	Most	Least
Age	1B Joe Adcock, 39	1B Bill White, 19 OF Kyle Tucker, 19
Height	P Mat Latos, 6’6″ P Jordan Montgomery, 6’6″ P Carson Smith, 6’6″	IF Freddie Patek, 5’5″
OPS	OF Carl Warwick, 1.025 (—)	IF Adam Everett, .381 (—)
HR	IF Chick Fulmer, 48 (—)	C Steve O’Neill, 1 (AAA/AA)
SB	OF Jimmy Sheckard, 37 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	IF Jim Ray Hart, 5.6 (—) CF Willie Mays, 5.6 (WBL)	IF Frank Malzone, -5.6 (—)
W	Christy Mathewson, 17 (WBL)	Lefty Hoerst, 2 (—/AA)
SV	Brian Wilson, 29 (WBL)
ERA	Joe Bush, 2.86 (—)	Matt Cain, 7.68 (AAA)
WAR	Christy Mathewson, 4.4 (WBL) Wei-Yin Chen, 4.4 (—)	Lefty Hoerst, 6.20 (—/AA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Ottawa Mounties

By mknn

On April 6, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

To not suck.

Beyond that, sorting through some of the young talent and making commitments around how is part of the long-term project and who is not would go a long way towards clarifying Ottawa’s future. Staying healthy would go a ways towards this, especially on the mound.

Best Case

Bob Moose, Bob Brown, and Roy Halladay all return strong from injuries, joining Old Hoss Radbourn in a decent pitching staff and the core talent sorts itself out, especially in the OF.

Worst Case

The pitching continues to be among the worst in the league and none of the massive potential of Randy Johnson, Ken Griffey Jr or Álex Rodríguez comes to the surface.

Key Questions

Can the staff both deliver and stay healthy?
Who is the bullpen?
How the young talent sorts itself out.

Trade Bait

Not really. Radbourn has some value, but he also was the only quasi reliable arm for the Mounties last season.

Well, that was interesting: Griffey, Jr. was moved on, netting Adrián Beltré plus.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C			Carter			Ausmus
1B				Staub		Watson
2B			Alomar
3B				Beltré
SS					Rodríguez	Dorgan
LF/ RF		Walker	Raines			Thompson
CF			Beltrán			Monday
SP		Halladay	Radbourn	Moose	Peters Griffith Johnson Podgajny	Hammaker
End		~~Henke~~	Dempster			Ryan
RP						Gregg Shaw ~~Collins~~

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

Over half the roster is either unknown or was pretty horrible last year. Hence the goal being merely not to suck.

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	C Gary Carter	OF Jim Lemon
Batting Eye	IF Roberto Alomar	1B Nick Johnson
Contact	IF Álex Rodríguez	OF Terry Puhl
Running Speed	U Tim Raines	OF George Burns
Base Stealing	U Tim Raines	OF George Burns
IF Defense	3B Adrián Beltré	IF Dick Bertell
OF Defense	OF Sam Thompson	OF Jason Heyward
Stuff	P Charles Radbourn	P Reggie Richter
Control	SP Roy Halladay	P Curt Davis
Velocity	RP Ryan Dempster RP Tom Henke	RP Greg Holland

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (4)	23	P	Al Orth
2 (30)	21	P	Dan Haren
3 (50)	23	P	Max Scherzer
4 (70)	22	1B	Bob Watson
5 (80)	20	1B	John Mayberry
6 (102)	20	2B	Jimmy Dykes
7 (106)	19	P	Mark Eichhorn
8 (181)	20	C	Milt May
9 (183)	22	P	Dupee Shaw

Others: None.

It’s not a bad system, but it lacks–beyond the top arms–top end potential. Watson and Shaw both start the season with the Mounties.

	Most	Least
Age	P Ken Forsch, 38	IF Elbie Fletcher, 19 P Mark Eichhorn, 19 OF Warren Cromartie, 19 P Dave Bennett
Height	P Randy Johnson, 6’10”	OF Wee Willie Keeler, 5’4″
OPS	1B Dale Long, 1.236 (—)	IF Mike Sharperson, .526 (—)
HR	1B Dale Long, 66 (—)	IF Larry Kopf, 0 (—) IF Mike Dorgan, 0 (—)
SB	U Tim Raines, 92 (WBL)	Many with 0
WAR	1B Vic Saier, 5.0 (—)	IF Mike Sharperson, -2.3 (—)
W	Danny Cox, 16 (—)	Jesse Crain, 1 (AAA/AA)
SV	Ryan Dempster, 16 (WBL/AAA) Pedro Ramos, 16 (—)
ERA	Mark Grant, 2.31 (—)	Randy Johnson, 6.60 (WBL/AAA)
WAR	Charles Radbourn, 4.4 (WBL)	Monk Dubiel, -1.6 (WBL/AAA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.

Year II Season Preview: Philadelphia Stars

By mknn

On April 6, 2024

In Team News

Expectations

For all the noise around Miami and Ottawa, it was Philadelphia who ended up with the worst record in the league. Anything approaching .500 would be a significant step forward.

Best Case

Overall number 1 pick Bullet Joe Rogan pairs with Steve Carlton to anchor the rotation and the offense improves overall, with both Bobby Abreu and Aaron Judge taking significant steps forward (and the Stars figuring out how to get both of them in the lineup at the same time).

Worst Case

Rogan struggles, as do Hardie Henderson and Ray Collins, leaving the staff as poor as last season and the aging bats–Rico Carty, Ted Kluszewski, Buck Freeman–lose more productivity than is gained elsewhere.

Key Questions

What does the bullpen look like?
How does the OF resolve, and most importantly how much of Aaron Judge‘s debut performance was a mirage?
Can the flashes of talent on the IF shown last year from Juan Samuel and Roger Peckinpaugh deliver over a full season?

Trade Bait

All of the older talent, including the puzzling FA signee John Titus, could be moved on, with Buck Freeman perhaps being especially attractive.

Roster Evaluation

POS	Elite	Strong	Solid	Meh	Weak	Unknown
C				Lollar	Scioscia
1B			Kluszewski			Killebrew
2B					Utley
3B				Ramírez Rolen	Ward
SS						Fletcher Rollins
LF/ RF			Judge	Carty Hendrick	Magee
CF		Davis
SP			Carlton	Collins	~~Alexander~~ Jackson Ward	Henderson Stieb
End			Howry			Kennedy
RP				Belcher		Gatewood ~~Katoll~~ ~~Meyer~~ ~~Peterson~~ Rogan

New Addition | ~~Injured~~

Pretty miserable. Judge is demoted due to playing time. I mean, the good news would be that there is, um, lots of room for improvement?

Talent Ratings

	WBL	Minors
Raw Power	1B Ted Kleszewski U Harmon Killebrew	U Dolph Camilli
Batting Eye	U Harmon Killebrew	U Dolph Camilli
Contact	1B Ted Kluszewski	1B Cecil Cooper
Running Speed	P/OF Charles Rogan	IF Roger Peckinpaugh IF Juan Samuel
Base Stealing	OF Sherry Magee	OF Garry Maddox
IF Defense	3B Scott Rolen	IF Pinky May
OF Defense	P/OF Charles Rogan	SS Wally Gerber
Stuff	P/OF Charles Rogan	P Hardie Henderson
Control	RP Bob Howry	P Robin Roberts P Bill Stearns
Velocity	RP Bob Howry	RP Luke Weaver

Best In The Minors

Rank	Age	POS	Name
1 (38)	23	P	Bill Gatewood
2 (74)	18	P	Chris Archer
3 (76)	23	U	Harmon Killebrew
4 (81)	22	C	Bill Dickey
5 (114)	22	OF	Richie Ashburn
6 (122)	21	1B	Prince Fielder
7 (127)	26	P	Jack Easton
8 (128)	19	P	Bruce Hurst
9 (150)	23	SS	Roger Peckinpaugh
10 (167)	23	P	LaTroy Hawkins

Others: P Jack Kralick.

It’s not totally dire, as there is some good mid level talent, and the trio of Killebrew, Dickey, and Ashburn should all come good. Gatewood and Killebrew start the season in the WBL.

	Most	Least
Age	U Rico Carty, 37	P Chris Archer, 18
Height	P Bill Gatewood, 6’7″ OF Aaron Judge, 6’7″ P Steve Hamilton, 6’7″	P/OF Charles Rogan, 5’7″ C John Clapp, 5’7″
OPS	IF Michael Cuddyer, 1.048 (—)	IF Johnny Mitchell, .505 (AAA/AA)
HR	IF Michael Cuddyer, 46 (—)	IF Johnny Mitchell, .1 (AAA/AA) IF Pinky May, 1 (—)
SB	IF Juan Samuel, 36 (WBL/AAA)	Many with 0
WAR	OF Aaron Judge, 4.0 (WBL/AAA)	C Tom Egan, -1.4 (AA)
W	Hardie Henderson, 10 (WBL/AAA) Larry Jackson, 10 (WBL/AAA) Robin Roberts, 10 (WBL/AAA)	Scott Mathieson, 1 (—) Kevin Hagen, 1 (—) Jerry Casale, 1 (—)
SV	Bob Howry, 25 (WBL)
ERA	Adalberto Mejía, 3.70 (—)	Kevin Hagen, 8.57 (—)
WAR	Ray Collins, 2.9 (WBL)	Bronson Arroyo, -1.5 (WBL/AAA/AA)

Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.