We’re doing 3 teams for each league, with players color coded by their Tier Level (S Tier, A Tier, B Tier, C Tier), with selections for each position, 3 starters, 2 bullpen arms, and a closer.
Just a glance shows the differences in the leagues: you want offense, look at the AL, you want pitching, the NL. That’s a generality, and like all such, not fully accurate: the NL actually has more S Tier bats, but the AL is overall more top heavy offensively.
San Francisco, predictably, leads the way with 12 selections while the rivalry between the Black Yankees and Cleveland continues, with the Bill James Division heavyweights having 8 each.
#AL
Pos
First Team
Second Team
Third Team
C
Ed Bailey (DET/CLE)
Mickey Cochrane (SFS)
Curt Blefary (BAL)
1B
Jim Thome (MCG)
Lance Berkman (CLE)
Jack Clark (SFS)
2B
Eddie Collins (CAG)
Rogers Hornsby (NYY)
Miller Huggins (BAL)
SS
Arky Vaughan (CLE)
Cal Ripken, Jr. (BAL)
Dick Lundy (SFS)
3B
Evan Longoria (CLE)
Mike Schmidt (NYY)
Jimmie Foxx (SFS)
LF
Babe Ruth (NYY)
Kal Daniels (LAA)
Frank Robinson (BAL)
CF
Turkey Stearnes (SFS)
Tris Speaker (CLE)
Mike Trout (LAA)
RF
Mickey Mantle (NYY)
Joe Jackson (CAG)
Yasiel Puig (MCG)
DH
Ty Cobb (DET)
Lou Gehrig (NYY)
Reggie Jackson (SFS)
SP
Lefty Grove (SFS) José Méndez (MCG) Jim Whitney (BBB/MCG)
Bump Hadley (SFS) Andy Pettitte (NYY) Eddie Plank (SFS)
Ed Walsh (CAG) Brett Anderson (LAA) Ron Guidry (NYY)
RP
Ken Howell (SFS) Andrew Miller (MEM)
Ross Reynolds (LAA) Al Smith (CLE)
Firpo Marberry (CLE) Ron Reed (CLE)
CL
Rod Beck (SFS)
Goose Gossage (NYY)
Jonathan Papelbon (MEM/MCG)
I do wonder if this points to how fragile Cleveland is. The Spiders are one of only 2 teams to make the playoffs in both WBL seasons, but if you were to pick names likely to fade off this list, Arky Vaughan, Evan Longoria, Al Smith, and Firpo Marberry would jump out.
It also shows just how top heavy Los Angeles is: 2 S-Tier players (plus Brett Anderson and Ross Reynolds) with nothing to show for it. At the other end, there’s Detroit–the other team to make the playoffs each year–with only a single player (the incomparable Ty Cobb) listed, further reinforcing the Wolverines as having done it with a true team effort (although this was also quite close: Terry Adams, Al Kaline, and Hank Greenberg were all in contention for 3rd Team honors).
And the less said about Memphis, the better.
#NL
Pos
First Team
Second Team
Third Team
C
Josh Gibson (HOM)
Gary Carter (OTT)
Mike Piazza (BRK)
1B
Paul Konerko (CAG/BBB)
Will Clark (NYG)
Jeff Bagwell (HOU)
2B
Roberto Alomar (OTT)
Joe Morgan (IND)
Ryne Sandberg (HOD)
SS
Ernie Banks (HOD)
Carlos Correa (HOU)
Alex Rodríguez (OTT)
3B
Ron Cey (BRK)
Albert Pujols (KCM)
Scott Rolen (PHI)
LF
Jim Wynn (HOU)
Ryan Braun (BBB)
Rick Reichardt (HOM)
CF
Oscar Charleston (IND)
Willie Mays (NYG)
Charles Rogan (PHI)
RF
Aaron Judge (PHI)
Larry Walker (OTT)
Tony Gwynn (HOU)
DH
Willie Stargell (HOM)
Benny Kauff (NYG)
Rick Monday (OTT)
SP
Luis Padrón (IND) Toad Ramsey (HOU) A. Rube Foster (KCM)
Smokey Joe Williams (BRK) Smokey Joe Wood (KCM) Fernando Valenzuela (BRK)
Roger Clemens (HOU) Hardie Henderson (PHI) Orel Hershiser (BRK)
RP
Lee Smith (HOD/KCM) Eddie Guardado (KCM)
Robb Nen (NYG/HOM) Terry Forster (BRK)
Andrew Chafin (HOU) Fred Cambria (PHI)
CL
Eric Gagné (BRK)
Josh Lindblom (HOM)
Bob Howry (PHI)
Brooklyn and Kansas City’s pitching is so strong. And imagine just how bad Ottawa’s pitching had to be, given their offensive representation.
Indianapolis has 3 S Tier players, giving them perhaps the most dominant nucleus in the league to build around. Kansas City has 4 S Tier players, but 2 of them are relievers, so most GM’s would prefer the ABC’s group.
And there are some league-wide deficiencies, especially at 1B and LF. Jim Wynn is a nice player, but the best in the league?
Both of Birmingham’s entrants were brought over in trade … but they also lost Jim Whtiney in those deals.
#Team by Team
Portland had nobody–nobody–who was deemed top 3 in the AL at their position. Ouch.
Baltimore. 4: Curt Blefary, Miller Huggins, Cal Ripken, Jr, Frank Robinson. Birmingham, 2: Ryan Braun, Paul Konerko. Brooklyn. 7: Ron Cey, Terry Forster, Eric Gagne, Orel Hershiser, Mike Piazza, Fernando Valenzuela, Smokey Joe Williams Chicago. 3: Eddie Collins, Joe Jackson, Ed Walsh. Cleveland. 8: Ed Bailey, Lance Berkman, Evan Longoria, Firpo Marberry, Ron Reed, Al Smith, Tris Speaker, Arky Vaughan. Detroit. 1: Ty Cobb. Homestead. 5: Josh Gibson, Josh Lindblom, Robb Nen, Rick Reichardt , Willie Stargell. Houston. 7: Jeff Bagwell, Andrew Chafin, Roger Clemens, Carlos Correa, Tony Gwynn, Toad Ramsey, Jim Wynn. Indianapolis. 3: Oscar Charleston, Joe Morgan, Luis Padrón. Kansas City. 5: A. Rube Foster, Eddie Guardado, Albert Pujols, Lee Smith, Smokey Joe Wood. Los Angeles. 4: Brett Anderson, Kal Daniels, Ross Reynolds, Mike Trout. Memphis. 1: Andrew Miller. Miami. 5: José Méndez, Jonathan Papelbon, Yasiel Puig, Jim Thome, Jim Whitney. New YorkBlack Yankees. 8: Lou Gehrig, Goose Gossage, Ron Guidry, Rogers Hornsby, Mickey Mantle, Andy Pettitte, Babe Ruth, Mike Schmidt. New York Gothams. 3: Will Clark, Benny Kauff , Willie Mays. Ottawa. 5: Roberto Alomar , Gary Carter, Rick Monday, Alex Rodríguez, Larry Walker. Philadelphia. 7: Fred Cambria, Hardie Henderson, Bob Howry, Aaron Judge, Charles Rogan, Scott Rolen. Portland. 0. San Francisco. 12: Rod Beck, Jack Clark, Mickey Cochrane, Jimmie Foxx, Lefty Grove, Bump Hadley, Ken Howell, Reggie Jackson, Dick Lundy, Eddie Plank, Turkey Stearnes. Wandering House of David. 2: Ernie Banks, Ryne Sandberg.
This is everyone who qualified for the ERA crown, plus a heaping handful of others who made at least 10 starts during the season. If a player had less than 162 innings, they are (a) probably knocked down a tier and (b) their name is prefaced by a * and italicized.
We’ve leaned on valuing IP in these rankings, perhaps a bit too much. But these are your starters, and they need to show up, game after game. It also means the Tiers are a little different: there are D-Tier pitchers here that you would welcome at the back end of your rotation, and it’s really only some of them, and the F Tier, that are truly an issue.
Our usual practices prevail: bold for top 3 and italics for bottom 3. Pitchers with below 162 IP aren’t included in the top/bottom markers.
#S Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
NL
KCM
A. Rube Foster
24
11-8
3.30
204
1.02
.189 BA .219 BABIP 0.7 HR/9 3.63 FIP
NL
IND
Luis Padrón
22
23-3
3.22
235
1.04
220 K .192 BA .225 BABIP
NL
HOU
Toad Ramsey
23
16-10
3.23
223
0.97
282 K .182 BA 11.4 K/9 3.8 K/BB 3.40 FIP
Just look at all that bold.
It’s been these 3 all year, and there’s a hair’s breadth between them. The analytics like Toad Ramsey, but Luis Padrón‘s record is stunning and while his ERA crown came by the absolute thinnest of margins, it did come.
Knuckleballers are always a bit unpredictable season-to-season, and it may very well be that A. Rube Foster has the best career of these three. But great things are expected of each of them.
#A Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
AL
SFS
Lefty Grove
27
16-6
4.40
209
1.15
230 K 2.2 BB/9 9.9 K/9 4.4 K/BB
AL
MCG
José Méndez
23
13-6
4.53
233
1.11
201 K 2.2 BB/9
NL
BRK
Fernando Valenzuela
24
14-5
3.69
163
1.08
1 Sv; 4 H
—
BBB/ MCG
Jim Whitney
24
10-7
3.83
202
1.10
1 Sv; 2 H
NL
BRK
Smokey Joe Williams
24
12-13
3.93
202
1.23
0.8 HR/9 3.55 FIP
NL
KCM
Smokey Joe Wood
22
15-12
4.11
191
1.13
Lefty Grove and Smokey Joe Williams each have an argument to move up a tier, but are held back, Grove’s instance by his ERA, in Williams’ by his record. Still, they are the class of this group.
If José Méndez hadn’t led the league in innings, he would probably drop down a level, but we’re nitpicking: these are staff aces on most teams. Note that Miami, Brooklyn, and Kansas City already have 2 pitchers each on this list.
#B Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
AL
LAA
Brett Anderson
22
11-6
4.34
189
1.12
NL
HOU
* Ice Box Chamberlain
19
4-4
3.56
109
1.13
1 Sv; 1 H
NL
HOU
Roger Clemens
25
17-10
3.71
211
1.13
AL
SFS
Bump Hadley
23
18-6
4.10
189
1.18
0.9 HR/9 4.2 BB/9
NL
PHI
Hardie Henderson
21
18-12
3.78
209
1.23
4.2 BB/9 1.7 KK/B
NL
BRK
Orel Hershiser
27
19-5
3.69
185
1.21
NL
HOD
* Kyle Peterson
22
8-3
3.80
107
1.16
AL
NYY
Andy Pettitte
33
18-9
4.43
201
1.21
AL
SFS
Eddie Plank
27
20-7
4.42
210
1.31
AL
CAG
Ed Walsh
25
10-11
3.94
205
1.15
1 Sv 201 K .225 BABIP
Hardie Henderson, Roger Clemens, and perhaps Eddie Plank (but that would be giving an awful lot of weight on 20 victories) could all be nudged up, but I’m comfortable with this. These are all front of rotation hurlers, with the only real surprise being Brett Anderson, who quietly excelled in a difficult year for Los Angeles. Ed Walsh, last year’s Rookie of the Year, avoided the sophomore slump entirely.
If you’re looking for skepticism, both Ice Box Chamberlain (due to age) and Kyle Peterson (due to coming out of nowhere) are decent bets to regress.
#C Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
AL
POR
Walter Ball
26
8-7
4.26
142
1.20
NL
PHI
Steve Carlton
25
12-13
5.05
187
1.24
NL
IND
Johnny Cueto
29
12-14
4.62
212
1.14
NL
HOM
* Doug Drabek
25
6-8
4.76
147
1.17
1 H
NL
BRK
Don Drysdale
22
11-8
5.66
186
1.28
AL
LAA
Dwight Gooden
22
11-11
4.36
194
1.29
AL
NYY
Ron Guidry
28
11-7
4.51
208
1.24
251 K 10.9 K/9
NL
OTT
Roy Halladay
29
15-9
5.17
195
1.26
2.2 BB/9
AL
POR
Walter Johnson
20
13-12
4.28
214
1.28
NL
BRK
* Sandy Koufax
21
6-3
4.93
119
1.16
2 H
AL
MEM
Stubby Overmire
25
13-10
4.72
212
1.26
6.1 K/9
NL
NYG
Gaylord Perry
22
12-15
4.34
189
1.12
NL
KCM
José Rijo
26
8-12
5.09
179
1.26
NL
PHI
Charles Rogan
27
12-9
4.51
188
1.24
AL
CLE
Bill Steen
26
13-10
4.71
193
1.33
1.9 K/BB
NL
NYG
Don Sutton
25
17-8
5.23
174
1.25
NL
PHI
JM Ward
20
6-10
5.01
196
1.16
Gaylord Perry and JM Ward were perhaps the unluckiest pitchers in the league this year: a bit of good fortune, and either could be several tiers above. If anyone is ranked too highly, it’s probably Bill Steen. There are a lot of names here that could easily take a step forward–Steve Carlton, Don Drysdale, and Walter Johnson especially.
Sandy Koufax blossomed in the bullpen after losing his rotation spot, but Brooklyn is likely to try him again as a starter next season.
Joe Rogan is just a remarkable talent. Everyone else here has great value solely from being on the mound: add Rogan’s bat and … yoikes.
#D Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
AL
MEM
Len Barker
25
11-12
4.99
180
1.44
AL
SFS
* Tommy Bridges
37
6-7
5.38
146
1.21
AL
POR
Bert Blyleven
21
10-11
5.03
204
1.32
NL
KCM
Frank Castillo
23
12-7
5.21
193
1.32
AL
SFS
* Watty Clark
26
6-4
4.02
134
1.30
2 H
NL
PHI
* Ray Collins
24
4-7
4.62
121
1.27
1 H
AL
CLE
* Bob Feller
20
13-3
4.30
153
1.34
NL
BBB
* Lefty Gomez
27
9-9
4.90
154
1.30
2 H
AL
NYY/ CAG
Waite Hoyt
24
11-4
4.89
169
1.44
4.1 BB/9
NL
BRK
Frank Knauss
23
12-6
4.55
180
1.34
NL
HOM
Francisco Liriano
23
10-12
5.03
181
1.38
NL
BBB
Greg Maddux
23
10-14
5.35
195
1.28
59 HRA .225 BABIP 6.50 FIP
AL
BAL
Dennis Martínez
24
12-8
5.12
202
1.42
NL
NYG
Christy Mathewson
22
7-16
5.61
210
1.40
207 K
AL
POR
* Joseíto Muñoz
20
4-4
4.56
101
1.37
1 Sv; 2 H
AL
BAL
* Jim Palmer
25
8-8
4.88
138
1.37
1 H
NL
BBB
Alejandro Peña
26
8-11
5.59
180
1.31
NL
HOM
Billy Pierce
30
10-11
5.77
173
1.36
NL
HOD
* Rick Reuschel
30
8-8
4.61
135
1.31
1 Sv; 1 H
NL
HOD
Bob Rush
24
11-9
5.28
186
1.32
2 H
NL
HOD
CC Sabathia
28
5-15
5.89
202
1.35
1 Sv; 1 H 64 HRA 3.2 HR/9 6.90 FIP
AL
CAG
Ben Sheets
27
6-12
5.88
165
1.32
1 H
NL
OTT
* Bill Smith
26
10-3
3.77
124
1.35
1 H
NL
HOU
Stephen Strasburg
25
9-10
5.87
169
1.37
NL
HOD
Jack Taylor
26
12-10
5.90
192
1.42
.291 BA 6.4 K/9
AL
CLE
Cy Young
25
15-9
5.38
199
1.39
.307 BABIP
There are some absolute conundrums here. Greg Maddux‘s issues are obvious in the final column: his BABIP is top-3 in the league, showing just how good his stuff is. But he has to keep the ball in the ballpark. At least once in a while.
Christy Mathewson and Cy Young seem like they could do more than be massive inning eaters, but they need to be harder to hit to make the jump forward. But pitching is weird: Jack Taylor and Gerrit Cole (see below) were among the best on the mound last season, and struggled mightily this.
Bob Feller would warrant a bump as well with a few more solid starts.
#F Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
Other
AL
CAG
Mark Buehrle
31
8-12
5.11
185
1.38
6.3 K/9
AL
MEM
* David Bush
26
9-9
6.58
149
1.32
AL
LAA
Gerrit Cole
26
7-15
6.36
166
1.43
2.9 HR/9 6.52 FIP
AL
MCG
Cole Hamels
25
11-12
6.18
178
1.42
63 HRA .293 BA 3.2 HR/9 3.7 K/BB
NL
NYG
* Carl Hubbell
26
6-10
5.75
160
1.29
1 H
NL
HOM
* Cliff Lee
30
8-4
5.30
114
1.32
3 H
NL
HOU
Roy Oswalt
28
7-11
6.53
181
1.49
.295 BA .305 BABIP
NL
OTT
Charles Radbourn
27
12-13
5.89
202
1.35
AL
DET
Charlie Root
31
11-10
6.15
199
1.42
59 HRA
AL
LAA
Tom Seaver
23
7-8
5.81
164
1.44
—
BBB/ CAG
* Sam Streeter
25
3-11
5.63
123
1.34
AL
POR
Dizzy Trout
29
5-12
5.93
162
1.50
4.1 BB/9 1.8 K/BB
AL
DET
Justin Verlander
25
5-12
6.48
169
1.52
.310 BABIP
NL
IND
* Doc White
27
5-12
6.55
143
1.34
1 Sv; 3 H
Most of these issues are clear: too many homeruns, too many walks, way too many runners on the basepaths. Maybe Old Hoss Radbourn could argue to be one tier up. Maybe.
Other than that, it must be said there is a ton of talent here: Roy Oswalt, Tom Seaver, and Justin Verlander jump out as most likely to bounce back next year.
It must be said there are probably 2 dozen more names that could be listed in the F Tier. Check out the individual team maps as they are published for those, but suffice to say that, when a pitcher goes down in flames in the WBL, they burn awfully bright.
Fitting for this league, there is a ton of talent here, which makes some of the Tier sorting challenging.
We have a new defensive metric for outfielders: ARM, which is an estimate of the number of runs saved (or allowed) from their throwing arms.
#S Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
NL
IND
Oscar Charleston
21
337/381/619
38 HR 130 RBI 101 R 46 SB
AL
CLE
Tris Speaker
23
312/397/631
35 HR 124 R 46 SB
AL
SFS
Turkey Stearnes
22
357/400/751
51 HR 125 RBI 108 R
-4.7 ARM
AL
LAA
Mike Trout
22
306/392/617
40 HR 107 RBI 106 R 45 SB
.994 fPct
The top of this list is easy: welcome to the WBL, Turkey Stearnes!
After that, it’s unclear. In one sense, maybe it’s just Stearnes? But Tris Speaker–as disliked as he is–had a great season. So, maybe it’s just the two of them? But it feels like Mike Trout and Oscar Charleston are certainly in a different class than the bulk of the A Tier.
I think this is a reflection of how great of a year Sternes had: consider him in an S+ tier by himself.
#A Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
NL
BRK
John Briggs
21
276/377/557
32 HR
NL
NYG
Willie Mays
24
261/337/600
49 HR 112 RBI 107 R 24 SB
14.5 ZR -4.7 ARM
AL
MCG
Julio Rodríguez
20
315/347/661
42 HR
2.30 RF -10.1 ZR
NL
PHI
Charles Rogan
27
308/362/620
21 SB
3.45 RF
Joe Rogan played more CF than anything else (other than pitcher), so he’s listed here.
Willie Mays is Willie Mays, and is expected to spend most of his career here and above. The rest can be considered surprises: John Briggs was seen by many as a AAA player who would fail in his rookie season; Julio Rodríguez was an afterthought invite to Spring Training who seized the opportunity; and while it was expected that Rogan would be solid as a 2-way player, nobody foresaw this.
#B Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
NL
OTT
Carlos Beltrán
25
258/332/533
35 HR 42 SB
10 A
AL
NYY
Eric Davis
25
263/344/538
34 HR 61 SB
AL
POR
Ken Griffey, Jr
20
292/326/568
33 HR
-7.8 ZR
Sure. Eric Davis continues to struggle with injuries, Carlos Beltrán needs to put the ball in play a little more, and Ken Griffey, Jr. is only 20. This also reinforces the trade between Portland and Ottawa–Beltrán deserves his starting spot in the WBL, and Griffey, Jr. needed a fresh start.
Any of these three could move up, while Davis seems the most likely to crash out as his injuries continue to mount.
#C Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
DET
Chili Davis
25
243/318/481
14 A -15.5 ZR .930 dEff 0.5 ARM
NL
HOD
George Gore
26
254/389/440
NL
HOU
Pete Hill
20
274/347/453
2.38 RF
AL
MEM
Reggie Smith
24
270/333/545
34 HR
-5.0 ARM
Here we get to set of CF that are always being questioned–they are good enough, but there’s always a lingering question about whether they’re actually the solution. This impacted George Gore the most, who was essentially a half-time player this year, and is least an issue for Pete Hill, given his age.
Chili Davis is solid, but his defense is far from solid, and Reggie Smith–like some others in the Memphis clubhouse–is under threat from a wave of emerging talent.
#D Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
BAL
Paul Blair
25
262/296/448
11.8 ZR 1.086 dEff
NL
BBB
Curtis Granderson
27
206/293/495
41 HR 21 SB
2.97 RF -5.2 ARM
NL
HOM
Andrew McCutchen
24
238/325/446
52 SB
.963 fPct
—
IND/ CAG
Jake Stenzel
26
244/293/465
22 SB
2.36 RF .917 dEff
Curtis Granderson and Andrew McCutchen had their names penciled in almost every day … which leads to a question of why they escaped the criticism seen by the tier above? For Granderson, it is answered by his defense, power, and the fact that his deficiency–putting the ball safely in play–was a team-wide issue for Birmingham.
Jake Stenzel stopped hitting for power when he arrived in Chicago, cementing his place in this group, while Paul Blair is only here due to his exceptional defense.
#F Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
NL
PHI
Willie Davis
22
233/282/391
21 SB
16.3 ZR 1.095 dEff
NL
HOD
Jim Edmonds
26
218/280/467
.996 fPct 2.95 RF
NL
KCM
Willie McGee
26
246/279/418
40 SB
11 A .969 fPct
NL
KCM
Dale Murphy
23
193/274/456
.971 fPct .936 dEff
AL
CAG
Cristóbal Torriente
18
186/237/247
24 SB
.993 fPct 1.069 dEff 0.4 ARM
Willie Davis and Jim Edmonds do enough with their gloves to stick around somewhere, and Davis is certainly young enough to improve more offensively. The rest are a challenge: Willie McGee is in danger of losing his job, Dale Murphy has obvious power, but is clearly not best suited for CF, and then there’s Cristóbal Torriente, whose defensive impact is unmistakable, but is clearly overwhelmed at the plate at this point.
#Rookies
This is in incredible rookie class, with Stearnes (S Tier), and Rodríguez, Rogan, and Briggs (all A Tier). And, oh yeah, Dale Murphy way down in the F Tier Tier.
#Fielding Notes
We have our standard defensive stats here, with the leaders in bold and the worst performers in italics. Assists (A), more romantically referred to as Outfield Kills are runners eliminated on the bases. Range Factor (RF) measures the number of plays made per game–the higher the better. Zone Rating (ZR) attempts to credit players for plays other fielders missed and ding them for plays other fielders made–the higher the better, and it has the benefit of being comparative across the position. Defensive Efficiency (dEff) measures the rate at which an individual fielder contributes to outs being made on balls put into play, with any score over 1.000 being a net positive impact. Finally, Fielding Percentage (fPct) reflects the percentage of times a chance was handled without a mistake–if someone made no errors, their fPct would be 1.000.
Of these, Range Factor is the most susceptible to the impact of the pitching staff and the ballpark, although none of these defensive ratings are perfect.
The Stars opted to start Hardie Henderson over Steve Carlton for game 1; for the Colt 45’s there was no question they would turn to Toad Ramsey and his mighty knuckleball.
Sherry Magee continues to be effective as the Stars’ leadoff hitter: here he coaxed a walk from Ramsey, stole 2nd and 3rd, and scored on Jim Fregosi‘s grounder for an early 1-0 lead. It may have been wasted effort, as Aaron Judge hit one into the Crawford Boxes, giving Philadelphia a 2-0 advantage.
It was short-lived: Jim Wynn doubled and scored on a triple from Tony Gwynn. Henderson got 2 outs, but left a sinker up to Paul Goldschmidt, who sent it deep into the seats for a 3-2 edge to Houston after 1 inning.
Ramsey seemed to settle down, but Houston continued its onslaught against Henderson, with George Brett going deep in the 2nd and Goldschmidt, after an error by Scott Rolen put Jeff Bagwell on base, hit his 2nd of the day, making it 6-2.
A single from Pete Hill leading off the 4th chased Henderson, but Robin Roberts escaped the inning without additional damage.
The Stars put runners on 2nd and 3rd (a walk to Chase Utley and a Magee double) with 1 out in the 5th. Ramsey walked in a run, but Philadelphia would be sad not to take greater advantage of the situation. Roberts continued to be effective, and we ended 5 with Houston ahead, 6-3.
Houston got some insurance in the bottom of the 8th as Hill laced a 2 run double, scoring 2 and increasing the score to 8-3.
Philadelphia had their chances, leaving 10 runners on base in the contest, but in the end–in what can only be seen as a good sign for the Colt 45’s–Andrew Chafin, Roberto Osuna, Tug McGraw, and Sparky Lyle combined for 4 scoreless innings in relief of Ramsey.
Goldschmidt was the clear star for Houston, driving in 4, but Carlos Correa and Hill chipped in 2 hits apiece. Magee and Rogan had 2 hits for the Stars.
Philadelphia would turn to Steve Carlton, trying to even out the series against Houston’s Roger Clemens.
Once again Aaron Judge went deep in the opening frame, this time with a solo shot. The Stars scored a second on an RBI single from Rico Carty, meaning, for the 2nd consecutive game, Philadelphia leads 2-0 before Houston comes to bat.
The script diverged there, however briefly: the Colt 45’s cut the deficit in half on a solo shot from Jeff Bagwell in the 2nd. In the 3rd, a leadoff walk to Craig Biggio was followed by a double in the right field corner by Jim Wynn. Tony Gwynn launched a ball to left, forcing a nice diving catch from Sherry Magee, but it was more than enough for Biggio to trot home. But the Colt 45’s weren’t done: Carlos Correa hit an RBI single and then Bagwell launched his 2nd of the game, giving Houston a 5-2 lead.
Carlton lasted 5, Clemens 6, with neither pitching particularly well, turning the game over to the shakiest parts of each bullpen.
Houston seemed to blink first, as John Franco gave up singles to Ted Kluszewski and Bill Dickey to start the 7th. But a pop to short center and a good throw by Jorge Posada to nail Dickey’s attempt to steal second seemed to offer an avenue out. But Franco allowed singles to Magee and Chase Utley, narrowing the lead to 5-4 and fetching Jim Kern from Houston’s bullpen. Kern induced a flyout from Charles Rogan, maintaining the single run advantage for the Colt 45’s.
And this is what Houston had envisioned: Tug McGraw shut it down before yielding to Sparky Lyle to close it out, giving the Colt 45’s a 2-0 edge in the series.
Bagwell’s 2 homeruns were key, of course, but so were Posada’s erasing 2 runners attempting to steal.
It was another game of missed opportunities for Philadelphia, who outhit Houston 11-5 in the contest. 3 of those came from Judge, who is 4-for-8 across the 2 games. The Stars’ bullpen did well, with Brad Kilby, Fred Cambria, and Ted Kennedy combining for 3 frames without giving up a hit.
We head to Philadelphia with something of a must-win game for the Stars, who will turn to the magnificent Charles Rogan, while Houston will counter with Ice Box Chamberlain.
Rogan balked in a run in the top of the first, but escaped a flurry of baserunners without further damage.
Aaron Judge did not hit a homerun in the opening frame, but he did drive in a run with a single, and later scored on a 3-run opposite drive by Jim Fregosi, putting the Stars up 4-1 after 1.
Then both hurlers settled down, and the score was unchanged through 5 innings. Jeff Bagwell took Rogan deep in the 6th, and when that was followed by a walk to Paul Goldschmidt, JM Ward was summoned from the Philadelphia bullpen. Ward retired Pete Hill, and the Stars still led, 4-2.
Judge was not to be denied, hitting one out of the park after Rogan was hit by a pitch. Fregosi followed with his 2nd of the day, chasing Chamberlain who gave up only 4 hits, but 8 runs.
Judge would add another, and Bill Dickey would go deep as well in what turned out to be a bit of walkover, 10-2 in favor of the Stars. Judge drove in 4 and Fregosi 5 on the day as Philadelphia corrected their errors of the first 2 games scoring 10 runs on 6 hits and leaving only a single runner on base.
Game 4 presents challenges for each team’s pitching staffs.
For Houston, Stephen Strasburg‘s solid performances down the stretch earned him the start, while Philadelphia will counter with their ace, Hardie Henderson, fully rested after a very short appearance in game 1.
Henderson started well, but walked 3 batters to start the top of the 2nd. George Brett doubled home 2 runs and another scored on a groundout from Jim O’Rourke. Pete Hill tripled home another run and scored on a sacrifice fly from Paul Goldschmidt, making it 5-0.
Chase Utley took Strasburg deep with Willie Davis on 2nd in the 3rd, closing the gap to 5-2.
A leadoff single from Craig Biggio chased Henderson, bringing in Robin Roberts. Bill Dickey whipped Roberts first strike to first, catching Biggio leaning the wrong way–something that may matter, as Jim Wynn followed with a homerun. Houston now led, 6-2–we’ll see if that extra run comes back to haunt them.
Scott Rolen went deep in the bottom of the 4th. 6-3. Doubles from Dickey and Sherry Magee plated another run in the 5th. 6-4.
But Tony Gwynn singled in 2 runs in the 6th to restore the cushion, making it 8-4, Houston.
A 1 out walk to Rolen in the 6th chased Strasburg after a decent enough effort, but Andrew Chafin was able to escape unscathed. The 7th did not go as well for Chafin, who gave up opening singles to Davis and Utley. In came Jim Kern, who induced a double play from Magee and a sharp grounder to short from Charles Rogan, preserving the lead.
But in the 8th, Jim Fregosi came through with a 2-run shot, cutting the lead in half, 8-6.
Philadelphia’s bullpen sort of imploded in the 9th: Bagwell doubled and scored on a single by Hill, who scored on a double by Goldschmidt. Wynn then drew a bases loaded walk, and Gwynn singled in 2 more runs. The 5 run explosion made it 13-6, Houston.
Philadelphia had some baserunners, but it came to naught, and Houston took a commanding 3-1 lead in the series.
Brett and Gwynn had 3 hits each with Gwynn, now hitting .353 in the series, driving in 4 runs on the day.
The bottom of the Stars’ order came to play, with Dickey, Davis, and Utley each having 2 hits.
Perhaps surprisingly, the first team with a chance to clinch their spot in the Division Series is the Houston Colt 45’s. The stellar Toad Ramsey gets the ball for Houston, while the Stars will turn to Ray Collins.
Jeff Bagwell singled in a run in the top of the first, and then Paul Goldschmidt launched a ball deep into the OF. An odd bounce and a poor throw later, and Goldschmidt had an inside-the-park homerun and Houston had a 3-0 edge.
Ramsey started a bit rough giving up singles to Sherry Magee, Aaron Judge, and Scott Rolen to score 1 and a 2-out double to Charles Rogan, resetting the game in a tie. Houston nudged ahead again when George Brett, who had tripled, scored on an RBI groundout from Jorge Posada.
And then both pitchers remembered how to pitch: the score remained 4-3, Houston, through 6 innings, which marked the end of Collins’ day.
Bagwell greeted Brad Kilby with a solo shot in the top of the 8th, extending the lead to 5-3. Houston brought in Jim Kern for the 8th, and he struck out 2, preserving the 2 run advantage, and then they padded it, scoring 3 in the top of the 9th (2 on Carlos Correa‘s first homerun of the series).
The Colt 45’s brought in Sparky Lyle with a 5 run edge, leading 8-3. Rico Carty and Rogan whiffed, bringing Philadelphia to their last batter, catcher Bill Dickey … a hard groundball, fielded by Correa, rifled to first. And Houston is through to the Division Series!
Bagwell, Gwynn, Brett, and Posada each had 2 hits for the Colt 45’s.
Bagwell, who hit .300 with 4 homeruns, was named Series MVP, but Goldschmidt and Gwynn deserved consideration as well. And, perhaps most importantly for Houston, Tug McGraw, Sparky Lyle, Jim Kern, and Andrew Chafin combined for over 10 innings of scoreless work out of the bullpen.
Aaron Judge (.421 with 4 homeruns and 6 RBIs) also deserved at least cursory MVP consideration.
Sailing under the radar for most of the season, Brooklyn still managed 99 victories, led by a ridiculously strong pitching staff.
The Royal Giants are one of the a very few teams with a legitimate top 4, and it’s unclear if Don Drysedale‘s 2nd half resurgence earns him a start in the opening game, given that Orel Hershiser (19-5, 3.69), Smokey Joe Williams (12-13, 3.93), and Fernando Valenzuela (14-5, 3.69) each had better seasons than Drysedale’s 11-8, 5.66 record.
The bullpen sports 2 of the dominant relievers of the league, with closer Eric Gagne and setup man Trevor Hildenberger, and Burleigh Grimes and Sandy Koufax provide excellent middle inning help when needed.
The offense is a notch below the pitching: Ron Cey and Mike Piazza are stars, and Dan Brouthers, John Briggs, Jackie Robinson, Beals Becker, and Duke Snider are all quite good. Vern Stephens and Dickie Thon seem to be sufficient at SS, and the versatility of Ray Dandridge helps around the IF, despite his lackluster offense.
George Hendrick has been lights out since being brought over in a trade, and makes the playoff roster ahead of swing starter Jim Bunning.
#Philadelphia Stars
Quite a turnaround for Philly, who were horrible last year, mediocre much of this year, and then turned it on the final few months to finish in 2nd place in the Effa Manley Division.
It’s an odd team in many ways. Clearly, Charles Rogan and his unique combination of a 308/362/620 slash line and legitimate #2 starter mound performances count for a lot, as does Aaron Judge breaking out with an OPS over 1.000, 63 homers, 133 RBI’s, and 108 runs scored. Scott Rolen is excellent at 3B, and Rico Carty held off the demons of age for another productive season.
And then the question marks start … Bill Dickey seems to be the answer behind the plate, but is untested, Sherry Magee could be useful, and the newly acquired Jim Fregosi might finally provide some stability at SS. Seems, could be, might …
The rotation is … odd. Hardie Henderson (18-12, 3.78) is probably the #1, but Steve Carlton‘s stuff is electric, despite a 12-13 record and a 5.05 ERA. Then, Rogan. Behind those, JM Ward has been far, far, far better than his 6-10 record would indicate and lefty Ray Collins is dependable.
Bob Howry, Ted Kennedy, Fred Cambria, and Pedro Feliciano form a solid, no-name bullpen (with trade acquisition Mark Melancon‘s selection to the postseason roster in doubt).
In the end, Melancon made it, as did the disappointing Harry Hooper, but that was more a function of a lack of relevant alternatives than anything else.
#Houston Colt 45’s
Most saw this Houston team as being a year or 2 away, but they kept winning through the Summer, and ended up topping the Marvin Miller Division by a comfortable margin.
The pitching staff is not structured as it was to start the season, as both Stephen Strasburg and Roy Oswalt have struggled mightily all season. Still, it’s a strong opening trio, led by the dominant Toad Ramsey (16-10, 3.23) and Roger Clemens (17-10, 3.71) and the now-healthy Ice Box Chamberlain (4-4, 3.56).
The bullpen has been poor all season, with Sparky Lyle (brought over to be the closer) struggling and Tug McGraw having his issues as well. Jim Kern has been a surprising bright spot, and Andrew Chafin and Roberto Osuna have been solid enough.
The offense is an intriguing mix. Carlos Correa, Jeff Bagwell, and Tony Gwynn are a solid core and Paul Goldschmidt has forced his way into the conversation in about 1/3 of a season’s work. Gentleman Jim O’Rourke has bounced back from a poor first season, and the rest of the pieces–mostly Jim Wynn and teenage phenom Pete Hill–are solid enough.
The worst news for Houston is that C Will Smith, who has absolutely destroyed WBL pitching since his recall, is not eligible for the postseason, putting the onus behind the plate on Jorge Posada, who has struggled. Given the presence of Gorman Thomas–who has also been on fire in limited action–we may see O’Rourke catching more than anticipated.
Thomas’ performance forced Casey Stengel off the playoff roster, as, especially with Dock Ellis injured for a few days, both Strasbourg and Oswalt made it.
#Indianapolis ABC’s
It came down to a playoff, but baseball fans are happy to see the ABC’s make the playoffs, as it extends the season for the best pitcher in baseball, Luis Padrón, and the emerging superstar Oscar Charleston.
The postseason likely brings an end to Indianapolis’ 6 man rotation, as the team will try to maximize the starts for Padrón (23-3, 3.22) and Johnny Cueto (12-14, 4.62). Eppa Rixey, Guy White, and Joe Lake are the most likely candidates behind those 2.
The back end of the bullpen was supposed to be a strength, but both Rob Dibble and Rob Murphy have struggle of late, leaving Jack Billingham and the surprising Mike LaCoss as the strongest performers at the moment.
Offensively, this is Charleston’s team, with the young CF slashing 337/381/619 with 38 homers, 130 RBIs, and 101 runs scored. Joey Votto and George Foster have been excellent and while Johnny Bench fell short of last year’s heights, 46 homers and 116 RBIs from behind the plate is nothing to sneeze at.
Chris Sabo has mostly displaced Ed Charles at 3B, but the biggest issue is the absence of Joe Morgan, who will miss the postseason through injury. Morgan was among the best in the game, and without him, the middle infield becomes pretty mediocre, relying on Tommy Helms and Barry Larkin.
#Predictions
Brooklyn is just that much better than Indianapolis across the board, so I think the Royal Giants take that one, 4-2.
The Houston/Philadelphia series is even harder to predict, and I think it is either very close, going the full 7 games, or Houston’s offense clicks on all cylinders and the Colt 45’s win in 5. Let’s say the former, with Houston edging it in a final contest.
With the division locked up, look for Dickie Thon to see time this final week as he makes his way back from injury and Dick Redding to get some ABs as well as a start or 2.
George Hendrick hit 2 out, but Brooklyn fell to Ottawa, 10-7. Hendrick has been tearing the cover off the ball since he came over from Philadelphia, and is making a very strong case for a role in the postseason for the Royal Giants.
The Royal Giants hit four consecutive homeruns, but it wasn’t enough as they fell to Birmingham, 11-9. Ray Dandridge, John Briggs, Jackie Robinson, and Beals Becker all went deep in the 7th, part of an 8 run explosion that gave Brooklyn a 9-5 lead. The usually dependable Trevor Hildenberger imploded, however, leading to the surprising defeat.
#Homestead Grays
The Grays recalled Paul Waner, Sterling Marte, Moose Haas, and Ray Brown for the final few games of the season.
Josh Gibson hit 2 out and nudged his BA back up to .396 as he chases .400 over the last few games of the season, but Homestead fell to Birmingham, 6-5. 2 more hits from Gibson nudged his average back to exactly .400 with 2 games to play as the Grays fell to Ottawa, 10-3.
#Ottawa Mounties
Chris Bosio and Mike Sharperson were sent to AAA to clear room for Dave Gregg and Mike Dorgan‘s return from their rehab assignments.
Bill Crouch will miss the last few games of the season, with Mike Minor being recalled.
Josh Donaldson hit 2 out as the Mounties rolled over the Grays, 10-3.
#Philadelphia Stars
Harmon Killebrew hit 2 homeruns, but the Stars faltered, falling 15-8 to Indianapolis.
Sherry Magee and Charles Rogan each drove in 5 (Rogan on 4 hits) and Odúbel Herrera scored 4 times as the Stars put an old fashioned whupping on the Gothams, 16-1. Rogan and Herrera doubled twice and Bill Dickey, Aaron Judge, and Killebrew each went deep in support of an excellent start from Ray Collins, who pitched 7 shutout innings allowing only 3 hits.
Both Scott Rolen and Judge hit 2 homeruns on the final day of the season, leading the Stars to an 8-4 win over the New York Gothams.
Some notes as we move through the final week of the season.
#Monday
Miami moved in front of Detroit by a half game in the AL Wild Card race behind a great start from Phenomenal Smith, whose return may be a difference maker for the Cuban Giants. Smith gave up 1 run in 7 innings, moving to 4-0. Hal Newhouser was good for Detroit, but an early homer from Gary Sheffield and a late one from Joe Adcock sealed the game for Miami.
Miami Cuban Giants
77-79
—
Detroit Wolverines
77-80
0.5
AL Wild Card
Cleveland was supposed to have an easy time of it, hosting the lowly Memphis Red Sox. But the Spiders’ bullpen collapsed, and they dropped a 9-8 decision to the visitors, who were powered by homers from Lefty O’Doul, Hack Wilson, and David Ortiz.
New York Black Yankees
89-67
—
Cleveland Spiders
87-69
2
Bill James Division
In a series that means more for Indianapolis than Philadelphia, the ABC’s opened with a decisive win, 15-8 over the Stars. Johnny Bench hit 2 out, and the game wasn’t as close as the score (Philadelphia tallied 5 in the 9th to make it more respectable).
Houston Colt 45s
81-75
—
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-79
3.5
Kansas City Monarchs
77-80
4.5
Marvin Miller Division
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-79
—
Kansas City Monarchs
77-80
1
Wandering House of David
76-81
2
NL Wild Card
#Tuesday
Detroit pulled back into a dead heat with Miami, pounding out 6 homeruns (2 from JD Martinez) in an 11-5 win. Ernie Lombardi, Tony Lazzeri, Oscar Gamble, and Ty Cobb also went deep for the Wolverines in an easy win for the visitors.
Detroit Wolverines
78-80
—
Miami Cuban Giants
77-80
0.5
AL Wild Card
Memphis did it again, beating Cleveland 4-2, and dropping the Spiders 2.5 games behind the Black Yankees. Homers from Reggie Smith and Wade Boggs backed a strong showing from Stubby Overmire, who moved to 13-9 on the year. The Spiders, however, remained only 2 games behind the Black Yankees as New York fell to San Francisco, 9-0, as Bump Hadley improved to 18-6 with a masterful 1-hitter.
New York Black Yankees
89-68
—
Cleveland Spiders
87-70
2
Bill James Division
Philadelphia stormed back from a 7-1 deficit, beating the ABC’s 8-7 on a pinch-hit walkoff shot from Aaron Judge–his 60th of the year–in a game that saw 2 grandslams, one from Indianapolis’ Ed Swartwood, the other from the Stars’ Charles Rogan. This was good news for Houston, who dropped a 9-8 decision to the New York Gothams, who were powered by 2 homeruns from Willie Mays. Houston remains 3.5 games ahead in the Marvin Miller Division.
Riding an excellent start from Rick Reuschel, the House of David pulled into a tie with Kansas City by defeating the Monarchs 3-1. Reuschel was supported by Ryne Sandberg‘s 40th homer of the year, and the win leaves both teams 1 game behind Indianapolis in the Wild Card race.
Houston Colt 45s
81-75
—
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-79
3.5
Kansas City Monarchs
77-80
4.5
Marvin Miller Division
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-80
—
Kansas City Monarchs
77-81
1
Wandering House of David
77-81
1
NL Wild Card
#Wednesday
What you see depends on where you stand: Miami fans will be miserable at their bullpen’s performance, as the Cuban Giants’ relievers surrendered 11 runs over the final 4 innings n an 11-8 loss to Detroit. Wolverines fans, of course, will be applauding the clutch performance of their team, led by Juan Beníquez‘ 4 hits and 3 RBI’s from Charlie Gehringer and Bob Bailey. The win moves Detroit 1.5 games up in the Wild Card chase.
Detroit Wolverines
79-80
—
Miami Cuban Giants
77-81
1.5
AL Wild Card
The Spiders are struggling, but they refuse to give up: a Larry Doby homerun and walkoff RBI single from John Ellis gave Cleveland a 9-8 win over Memphis, keeping them at least within touch of the Black Yankees for the Bill James Division crown. Willie McCovey hit his 15th homerun in 35 games, and Paul O’Neill (the first of his WBL career) and Ron Blomberg also went deep.
The Black Yankees fell to San Francisco, as Eddie Plank earned his 20th win of the season with 6 strong innings for the Sea Lions. San Francisco’s bullpen–Ken Howell, Joe Nathan, and closer Rod Beck–fanned 7 of the 9 batters they retired, with Beck earning his 40th save of the season.
New York Black Yankees
89-69
—
Cleveland Spiders
88-70
1
Bill James Division
Houston bounced back in a big way, using a phenomenal start from Ice Box Chamberlain and 7 homeruns to beat the Gothams, 9-2. Chamberlain allowed 1 hit in just under 8 innings, fanning 12 and 2 of the important cogs in the Colt 45’s late season surge–OF Gorman Thomas and C Will Smith–carried the team, twice launching back-to-back homeruns. Jim Wynn led off the game with a dinger, and Paul Goldschmidt and Jim O’Rourke also went deep.
The victory sealed the pennant for Houston, setting off raucous celebrations in the home dugout. It also meant all of the attention in the NL is now focused on the final Wild Card Spot, currently owned by Indianapolis, but with Kansas City and the House of David hot on their heels (and Homestead still hanging around with at least a mathematical chance).
After fighting back from a 6-1 deficit, Indianapolis suffered a gut-wrenching loss, falling to Philadelphia, 12-8. The Stars were led by homeruns from Sherm Lollar, Harmon Killebrew, Jung Ho Kang, and Sherry Magee.
Ryne Sandberg had 4 hits including a go-ahead solo homer in the bottom of the 8th as the House of David topped Kansas City, 6-5. Jack Taylor continued a late-season rebound with a solid start, but both bullpens struggled in this one. The victory moves the House of David into a dead heat with Indianapolis in the Wild Card chase, with Kansas City 1 game back.
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-81
—
Wandering House of David
78-81
—
Kansas City Monarchs
77-82
1
Homestead Grays
76-83
2
NL Wild Card
#Thursday
Miami just refuses to lose: Cleveland had taken the lead, 5-4 in the 6th inning, but the Cuban Giants scored 8 runs in their final 2 frames in a 12-6 victory. Miami pounded out 17 hits, led by 3 each from Jim Thome and Martín Dihigo. The game was never sure: Cuban Giants pitchers gave up 8 walks, so the Spiders had constant traffic on the basepaths. But they did just enough, with homeruns from Julio Rodríguez, Dihigo, Alejandro Oms, and Thome.
With the result, the Spiders drop to 1.5 games behind the Black Yankees and the Cuban Giants move to 1 game behind Detroit in the Wild Card race.
Detroit Wolverines
79-80
—
Miami Cuban Giants
78-81
1
AL Wild Card
Speaking of the Black Yankees … their bullpen continues to be their Achilles’ heel, with 4 relievers giving up 9 runs in 2.1 innings. Ouch. The big blows were homeruns from Jimmie Foxx and Bobby Bonds as San Francisco defeated New York, 13-10.
New York Black Yankees
89-70
—
Cleveland Spiders
88-71
1
Bill James Division
#Friday
The Black Yankees continue not to grab the Bill James Division by the throat, falling to lowly Baltimore 5-4 in the opening game of the final series of the season. Homers from Eddie Murray, Manny Machado, and a final go-ahead blast from Earl Averill gave the Black Sox the edge in another game that saw less than stellar performances from New York’s bullpen.
Two homers from Gary Sheffield carried Miami to a 5-4 win over Cleveland, preserving New York’s 1 game advantage, and keeping the pressure on Detroit. The Cuban Giants got another strong outing from Jim Whitney, and were able to fade a 9th inning comeback from the Spiders for the victory.
So what will Detroit do with their opportunity?
Play a game for the ages where they held leads of 3-1, 4-2, 9-5, and 10-6. And it was never enough as, after closer Mike Henneman was forced from the game with a back injury, Troy Percival came in and gave up a grand slam to Manny Ramírez and a walkoff shot to Gabby Hartnett. Both Ramírez and Hartnett had 2 homers in the game, while Al Kaline had 2 for Detroit. Kaline had 3 hits and 7 RBIs while Hartnett had 4 hits for Memphis. A true thriller of a game that leaves everything pretty much undecided.
New York Black Yankees
89-71
—
Cleveland Spiders
88-72
1
Bill James Division
Detroit Wolverines
79-81
—
Miami Cuban Giants
79-81
—
AL Wild Card
The House of David fell to Houston 8-2, as all eyes turned to the 4 game series between Indianapolis and Kansas City.
Kansas City’s Smokey Joe Wood and the ABC’s’ Luis Padrón squared off in the series opener and while each pitched well, neither were involved in the decision. Instead, after a 2 run shot from Ducky Medwick tied the game, Kansas City won it on a sacrifice fly from Dale Murphy in the bottom of the 9th. So Padrón fails in his attempt to win his 24th game of the year and, more importantly, Kansas City forces a 3 way dead heat for the final Wild Card spot.
Indianapolis ABC’s
78-82
—
Wandering House of David
78-82
—
Kansas City Monarchs
77-82
—
Homestead Grays
76-84
2
NL Wild Card
#Saturday
Memphis keeps embracing their role as spoiler while relying on a handful of late season call ups. In this case, Bucky Walters gave a good starting performance, Lefty O’Doul had 3 hits, and Wayne Causey drove in 2 with an 8th inning single for a 5-3 victory over Detroit.
It sure looks like Miami has found a key part of their rotation: Phenomenal Smith improved to 5-0, combining with Ricky Nolasco on a 3 hit shutout of Cleveland. Smith struck out 10 before yielding to Nolasco, for the last 2 outs. Martín Dihigo drove in 2 runs, continuing his second half surge.
Miami moves a full game ahead of Detroit for the Wild Card slot, and Cleveland falls 1.5 games behind the Black Yankees for the Bill James Division title, with New York’s magic number reduce to 1.
And then it was none. New York topped Baltimore 11-7 behind homers from Mickey Mantle, Babe Ruth, and Roger Maris, giving the Black Yankees their first Bill James Division title.
Miami Cuban Giants
80-81
—
Detroit Wolverines
79-82
1
AL Wild Card
Oh boy … Indianapolis has nobody to blame but themselves.
Behind a great start from Johnny Cueto and 3 RBI’s from Oscar Charleston, the ABC’s took a 6-2 lead into the bottom of the 9th, with their closer, Rob Dibble, on the mound. Dibble got one out, and then 16 of his next 20 pitches missed the strike zone, resulting in 4 consecutive walks, scoring a run. Rob Murphy relieved Dibble, and an RBI groundout and 2 wild pitches later, the game was tied at 6.
Cool Papa Bell walked in the bottom of the 10th, stole second, and scored on a hit from Ozzie Smith, moving Kansas City a game ahead in the Wild Card race.
#Sunday
The final day of the season leaves both final Wild Card spots up for grabs: in the AL, Miami has a 1 game lead over Detroit and in the NL, Kansas City has the edge over both Indianapolis and the House of David.
Miami was unable to clinch it: Larry Doby became the 2nd player in WBL history (and the first in the AL) to hit 4 homeruns in a game, driving in 7 as Cleveland topped the Cuban Giants, 13-7. That leaves Miami’s fate in the hands of Detroit later in the day.
Detroit used a mix of the old reliable–2 homeruns from Al Kaline and 1 from Ty Cobb–and the newly acquired (a strong start from Connie Johnson and key innings from Steve Howe and Troy Percival) to beat Memphis, 8-4.
And so, we finish in a dead heat.
Miami Cuban Giants
80-82
—
Detroit Wolverines
80-82
—
AL Wild Card
Eppa Rixey combined with 4 relievers (including an important 1.2 innings from Doc Mitchell), leading the ABC’s to a 7-3 win over Kansas City, meaning Indianapolis and the Monarchs finish with identical 79-83 records. The only question is if the House of David will join them in a 3-way tie for the final playoff spot.
Nope.
The House of David tried valiantly, and even outhit Houston, 10-8, but they fell to the Colt 45’s, 10-9 in a game that saw Tony Gwynn rap out 3 hits, reaching 200 on the season. Richie Hebner, Ryne Sandberg, and Anthony Rizzo each had 2 hits, but they didn’t get enough support as the House of David season ends, falling just short of the postseason.
#Monday
So, two playoff games, winner makes the postseason.
#AL
First up, we have Miami visiting Detroit.
The Cuban Giants will turn to Hugh McQuillan who, despite being roughed up in his last start, has been solid for Miami. If he struggles early, look for Jim Whitney to try to give the team some innings on short rest. For Detroit, Pete Conway will take the mound, also on a pretty short leash.
Ty Cobb may be almost universally disliked, but his baseball talent cannot be denied: he launched a 3 run homer in the top of the first and a grand slam in the 2nd, helping Detroit to a 9-0 lead after 2 innings.
Conway, meanwhile, had allowed a single run on 3 hits through 5, and left after 6 with the score 13-2.
Miami scored 3 in the 9th, but fell well short, 14-5. In the end, a just result, as Detroit really feels like the better team. Still, the Cuban Giants went from being the worst team in the league to being this close to the playoffs: a good year for them.
Cobb finished with 2 homers and 7 RBIs, and Al Kaline, Charlie Gehringer, Ernie Lombardi, and Hank Greenberg each also went deep. There was some bad news on Greenberg, who will be out of action for a few days with a leg injury.
#NL
Indianapolis would turn to Doc White while Kansas City gave the start to young Matt Morris.
Kansas City took an early lead on Albert Pujols‘ second homerun of the game, pulling ahead 6-3 after 3 innings, with the ABC’s runs coming on longballs from George Foster and Chris Sabo.
Morris was OK–not great, but not bad–until Tommy Helms singled and scored on a double from Barry Larkin in the top of the 4th. A Bob Bescher walk put runners on the corner, and fetched Frank Castillo from the bullpen. The move backfired as Sabo and Oscar Charleston singled and, after a couple of outs, Johnny Bench brought home 2 with a single of his own, giving Indianapolis an 8-7 lead. Foster followed with his 2nd dinger of the game, extending the lead to 10-7 and chasing Castillo. His successor, Bob Shawkey, gave upa solo shot to Helms and when all of the dust settled, the ABC’s had scored 8 and were up 11-7.
The ABC’s coasted from there, riding additional homeruns by Ed Charles and Sabo to a 15-8 win, powering Indianapolis into the postseason. Sabo drove in 5 and Foster 4, with each of them notching 3 hits on the day.
Kansas City had ridden its pitching staff all year; here their arms betrayed them, surrendering 14 hits and 15 runs.
Dickie Thon began a rehab assignment, marking a return from a long term injury.
Two relievers, Jeff Montgomery and Dick Tidrow, announced their retirement. Tidrow amassed 70 somewhat mediocre appearances over his career with the House of David, the New York Black Yankees, and Indianapolis.
Ron Cey hit 2 out, but the Royal Giants were downed by a late inning bullpen collapse, falling to Homestead, 13-4.
#Homestead Grays
Gary Lucas and Nip Winters were recalled from AA champions Syracuse.
#New York Gothams
37 year old minor league 1B Dan Johnson unsurprisingly announced his retirement.
#Ottawa Mounties
Dave Gregg and Mike Dorgan began rehab assignments as they try to make it back to Ottawa before the end of the year.
P Kirk McCaskill retired.
Emerging superstar Roberto Alomar tied a league record with 5 steals in a 9-6 win over the New York Gothams. Alomar had 2 hits and 3 RBIs, giving him 99 on the year, in a game that saw Rusty Staub, Sam Thompson, Gary Carter, and Josh Donaldson all go deep for Ottawa.
#Philadelphia Stars
Minor league pitcher Shane Greene announced his retirement.
Aaron Judge went deep twice and the Stars topped Homestead, 8-3. Charles Rogan improved to 12-9 with 7 shutout innings.
We’re going to do this by position group, ignoring league differences (although we will have a Rookie Team for each league in the offseason).
Only 6 players are officially full time (that is, they qualify for the batting stats): IF Jimmie Foxx, OFs Turkey Stearnes, John Briggs, Adam Dunn, and Ichiro Suzuki, and everywhere playing Charles Rogan. That group probably forms the core of the shortlist for the final Rookie of the Year Award: if you’re able to hold down a fulltime starting spot as a rookie in the WBL …
#C
Perhaps unsurprisingly, there are no fulltime rookie catchers, although 2–Philadelphia’s Bill Dickey and the House of David’s Frank Chance–have seen more and more time as the season has worn on.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
JP Arencibia
30
BBB
NL
.769 / -0.3
166 PA, 15 HR, 29 RBI
Frank Chance
24
HOD
NL
.658 / -0.2
250 PA
Bill Dickey
23
PHI
NL
.772 / 0.4
159 PA, 23 RBI
Dick Dietz
29
NYG
NL
.937 / 0.7
94 PA
Tom Haller
33
BAL
AL
.839 / 0.7
127 PA
AJ Pierzynski
28
LAA
AL
.630 / -0.4
191 PA, 9 HR
Really, that’s it. Chance has played about 3/4 of the time behind the plate, so the playing time is pretty consistent. So … Tom Haller (who is likely to not have a very long career, although he’ll be retained as the backup in Baltimore next season for sure) in the AL and Dickey in the NL.
#1B/3B
The corner IF spots are a bit rough, given the high end talent in the AL and the lack of presence in the NL.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Jimmie Foxx
1B/3B
21
SFS
AL
.924 / 2.3
510 PA, 44 HR, 82 RBI
Joe Harris
1B
36
HOD/ KCM
NL
.899 / 1.1
429 PA
Eddie Murray
1B
22
BAL
AL
.857 / 0.2
79 PA
David Ortiz
1B
27
MEM
AL
1.039 / 2.0
293 PA, 30 HR, 62 RBI
Andy Pafko
3B
29
BBB/ MCG
NL/ AL
.851 / 0.6
260 PA
Chris Sabo
3B
29
IND
NL
.780 / 0.2
297 PA
Foxx’s being the only rookie infielder to qualify for the batting championship gives him the lead, despite Ortiz’ remarkable production. Foxx played a little more at 1B than 3B, but given the paucity of hot corner candidates, may get the recognition there, clearing the way for Ortiz.
Pafko played as much in RF as 3B, but we needed more 3B here. Harris is a nice feel-good story–nothing like a 36 year old rookie come good.
#2B/SS
2 of the best here–Cal Ripken, Jr. and Judy Johnson–played regularly elsewhere (including 3B), but logged the majority of their innings in the middle infield.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Royce Clayton
SS
22
SFS
AL
1.020 / 0/7
100 PA
Charlie Gehringer
2B
25
DET
AL
.798 / 0.3
418 PA, 14 HR, 48 RBI
Frank Grant
2B/SS
22
HOD/ SFS
NL/ AL
.754 / 1.1
283 PA
Judy Johnson
SS
18
HOM
NL
.809 / 1.2
240 PA
Dobie Moore
SS
20
MEM
AL
.779 / 1.1
378 PA
Cal Ripken, Jr.
SS
23
BAL
AL
.876 / 2.3
370 PA, 22 HR, 62 RBI
Joe Sewell
SS
23
CLE
AL
.852 / 0.9
133 PA
Interesting list, with Gehringer being the only truly full time player for the entire season, although both Moore and Ripken are close enough to count. The lack of talent at 2B and in the NL is striking.
#OF
Here we have the clear overall RoY from the field players, but there’s more to chew on here than Turkey. Sorry.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Juan Beníquez
LF
35
DET
AL
.916 / 1.9
400 PA
John Briggs
CF
21
BRK
NL
.930 / 2.7
448 PA
Kiki Cuyler
LF
32
POR
AL
.675 / -0.5
305 PA
Adam Dunn
LF
22
IND
NL
.831 / 0.5
502 PA
George Foster
RF
22
IND
NL
.841 / 1.5
432 PA
Al Kaline
RF
21
DET
AL
.919 / 2.1
422 PA, 75 RBI
Elliott Maddox
OF
21
NYY/ HOU
AL/ NL
.766 / 0.2
406 PA
Rick Monday
CF
24
OTT
NL
1.019 / 1.6
307 PA
Julio Rodríguez
CF
20
MCG
AL
1.024 / 1.8
355 PA, 35 HR
Charles Rogan
CF
27
PHI
NL
.964 / 3.0
466 PA
Turkey Stearnes
CF
22
SFS
AL
1.134 / 6.0
512 PA, 47 HR, 115 RBI
Ichiro Suzuki
RF
28
LAA
AL
.698 / -0.5
513 PA
Sam Thompson
RF
27
OTT
NL
.820 / -0.2
362 PA
We’re not going to be too picky about positions here, going with Stearnes, Kaline, and J-Rod in the AL and Briggs, Rogan, and Foster in the NL; or perhaps Monday, if you want to recognize Rogan on the mound.
The surprises here are probably Briggs (who had an army of doubters, but is 2nd here in WAR) and Monday, whose offense just kept demanding more and more playing time. And mention has to be made of Beníquez–35 years old and a dominant year. He played 1B and 3B as well, so may see recognition there.
#SP
A dozen rookies made 10 or more starts; of those, a half-dozen are worth taking a closer look at.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
FIP
WAR
A. Rube Foster
23
KCM
NL
10-6
3.21
185
0.99
3.72
5.1
Bump Hadley
23
SFS
AL
16-5
4.15
169
1.22
4.07
4.3
Charles Rogan
27
PHI
NL
11-9
4.41
169
1.23
4.81
3.1
Fernando Valenzuela
24
BRK
NL
13-5
3.60
148
1.02
4.32
3.1
Jim Whitney
24
BBB/ MCG
NL/ AL
8-6
3.79
176
1.08
4.39
4.2
Joe Williams
24
BRK
NL
12-11
3.87
188
1.24
3.69
6.0
Foster is the clear class of this group, but Smokey Joe is a very close 2nd. I would add Whitney and Valenzuela to the award list, giving Brooklyn 2 of the 4 slots.
#RP
There aren’t a ton of relievers who are impactful enough to really warrant discussion here, but there are some.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
W-L
ERA
Sv
H
WHIP
Terry Forster
22
BRK
NL
1-2
3.56
2
14
1.12
Eddie Guardado
25
KCM
NL
2-2
2.20
1
9
1.00
Billy Hoeft
19
DET
AL
2-3
6.10
2
10
1.50
Brad Kilby
27
PHI
NL
3-3
6.20
2
14
1.24
Firpo Marberry
28
CLE
AL
7-0
4.72
3
11
1.34
Tug McGraw
27
HOU
NL
5-4
2.95
12
5
1.20
Andrew Miller
23
MEM
AL
6-8
4.41
3
11
1.33
Skel Roach
28
MEM
AL
2-1
4.31
3
12
1.49
Marberry, McGraw, Forster, and Guardado look pretty solid.
This week we have more playoff updates, and a look at the best rookies so far this year.
#Awards
Freddie Freeman is immediately showing he belongs at this level for Los Angeles, with the recent acquisition earning the AL Player of the Week Award, hitting .579 for the week with 4 homeruns. Over in the NL, Brooklyn‘s Duke Snider took home the Player of the Week with a .600 (!) average and 5 homers.
So, barring some real drama, the only race here is between the Spiders and the Black Yankees for playoff seeding.
#NL
The Effa Manley is a bit of a mirror of the Cum Posey, with the Brooklyn Royal Giants playing out the string, riding a 15.5 game lead over second place Philadelphia, with the Stars currently the highest ranked Wild Card team as well.
And then it gets messy.
Houston has surged in front of the Kansas City Monarchs, with the Colt 45’s leading the Marvin Miller Division by 2.5 games now. However, 3 more teams (Indianapolis, Homestead, and the House of David) are within 2.5 games of the final Wild Card spot, with Birmingham and the New York Gothams only 4 games back. All of that means that only the Ottawa Mounties (5.5 games off the Wild Card, but having 5 teams in the way) have really given up on the season.
#Player Performance
#Batters
It’s late in the year, so there is less churn in these lists. Let’s focus on the races that are still up for grabs.
Ty Cobb‘s lead in most categories is significant, but his 15 triples is only ahead of Houston’s Pete Hill by 1, with Bullet Joe Rogan and Turkey Stearns staying close with 13 each.
Miami’s José Canseco is holding onto the homerun lead with 62. He’s trailed by 2 Black Yankees: Babe Ruth with 59 and Lou Gehrig with 56.
Rickey Henderson is ahead of Ottawa’s Tim Raines by 3 in the stolen base race, 108 to 105.
Top 2 in most categories.
Ron Blomberg (CLE). 279/346/639. 129 RBI. José Canseco (MCG). 251/357/717. 62 HR. Ty Cobb (DET). 382/436/827. 195 H, 59 2B, 15 3B, 135 R, 8.6 WAR. Josh Gibson (HOM). 395/493/791. 9.7 WAR. Rickey Henderson (SFS). 248/376/431. 95 BB, 108 SB. Joe Jackson (CAG). 354/407/611. 64 2B. Babe Ruth (NYY). 269/402/694. 59 HR, 139 RBI, 125 R, 104 BB.
In the less glorious stats, sitting on 197, the Black Yankees’ Mickey Mantle is guaranteed to top 200 strikeouts on the season.
#Pitchers
Luis Padrón continues to totally dominate, winning his 20th and 21st game over the past week. Sitting at 21-3, Padrón has been the best starter in the league for most of the season. With only a few weeks left, it’s possible nobody else reaches 20 victories, but we’ve listed all 5 of the other hurlers with at least 16 wins.
A couple active streaks of note: José Rijo, Padrón’s teammate on the Indianapolis ABC’s, hasn’t allowed a run in 21 innings, and Brooklyn’s Sandy Koufax is riding a streak of 10 innings without giving up a hit.
#Starters
On the one hand, this list could be 3 names long: A. Rube Foster, Padrón, and Toad Ramsey.
Top 2 in most categories.
Roger Clemens (HOU). 16-9, 3.61. A. Rube Foster (KCM). 10-6, 3.21. .187 BA, .211 BABIP, 0.99 WHIP. Ron Guidry (NYY). 9-7, 4.29. 232 K. Bump Hadley (SFS). 16-5, 4.15. Orel Hershiser (BRK). 17-5, 3.87. José Méndez (MCG). 12-5, 4.37. 206 IP. Luis Padrón (IND). 21-3, 3.34. 205 IP, 6.2 WAR. Andy Pettitte (NYY). 17-8, 4.19. Eddie Plank (SFS). 17-7, 4.55. Toad Ramsey (HOU). 15-9, 3.18. 248 K, .181 BA, 0.97 WHIP, 3.33 FIP, 7.4 WAR. Fernando Valenzuela (BRK). 13-5, 3.60. 1 Sv, 4 H, .220 BABIP. Smokey Joe Williams (BRK). 12-11, 3.87. 3.69 FIP.
#Relievers
Top 2 in most stats, top 3 in saves and holds. 30 Min IP for rate stats, which allows the debut of the amazing start to Bartolo Colón‘s career for Homestead.
Rod Beck (SFS). 4-4, 4.93. 36 Sv, 1 H. Bartolo Colón (HOM). 1-0, 0.87. 1 H, 0.84 WHIP. Rheal Cormier (NYY). 0-3, 5.40. 16 H. Eric Gagne (BRK). 2-3, 2.60. 33 Sv. Eddie Guardado (KCM). 2-2, 2.20. 1 Sv, 9 H. Michael Jackson (HOM). 1-7, 5.14. 1 Sv, 20 H. Josh Lindblom (HOM). 8-4, 3.48. 32 Sv. BJ Ryan (OTT). 2-3, 4.64. 1 Sv, 16 H. Lee Smith (KCM). 4-2, 2.79. 6 Sv, 12 H, 0.77 WHIP.
#Injuries
A huge one: Chicago‘s Frank Thomas is out for 8-9 months with a knee injury. The Big Hurt is expected to make a full recovery, but this really will impact the American Giants’ offseason plans, as they will need a 1B for the first half of next season.