The American League dominates in LF (remember, some folks you might think as OFers spent most of their time at DH).
We have a new defensive metric for outfielders: ARM, which is an estimate of the number of runs saved (or allowed) from their throwing arms.
#S Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
LAA
Kal Daniels
24
340/422/652
39 HR 106 RBI 111 R 55 SB
AL
BAL
Frank Robinson
22
308/394/674
48 HR 114 RBI 106 R
5 A
AL
NYY
Babe Ruth
25
280/412/744
73 HR 167 RBI 146 R 119 BB
I do feel sorry for Kal Daniels–that is a stupendous season right there, and he has no shot at being the best LF in the AL, not with Babe Ruth around. And Frank Robinson is the youngest of the trio, which speaks volumes for the future in Baltimore.
#A Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
MEM
Ted Williams
22
303/423/616
41 HR 109 RBI 125 R 109 BB
.975 fPct 1.49 RF -3.8 ARM
Seems strange to have only 1 name here, but there is clear separation between Robinson and Ted Williams (the only thing Williams does better is take walks), and when defense is factored in, this makes sense.
#B Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
—
MCG/ BBB
Ryan Braun
24
272/319/603
48 HR 102 RBI 24 SB
AL
DET
Oscar Gamble
32
249/396/533
35 HR
1.29 RF
AL
SFS
Rickey Henderson
22
256/385/454
103 R 107 BB 126 SB
12.2 ZR 1.117 dEff -3.6 ARM
NL
HOM
Rick Reichardt
24
284/355/586
39 HR 22 SB
NL
HOU
Jim Wynn
23
246/359/521
37 HR 116 R 38 SB
3.7 ARM
An interesting mix of useful players. Rickey Henderson is electric, for sure, but until he hits a bit more, he’s not elite and the other 4 are just dependable and solid, although it could be argued that Jim Wynn is a tier too high.
#C Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
CLE
Johnny Bates
27
282/349/470
55 SB
8.8 ZR
AL
DET
Juan Beníquez
35
313/379/509
.965 fPct 1.08 RF
NL
PHI
Sherry Magee
21
265/314/495
47 SB
.994 fPct
AL
MCG
Alejandro Oms
21
308/383/441
1.91 RF 1.121 dEff
NL
OTT
Tim Raines
23
251/353/442
119 R 115 SB
-6.8 ZR
NL
HOD
George Stone
30
286/359/478
29 SB
NL
BRK
Roy White
29
258/350/499
21 SB
6 A 10.3 ZR 1.068 dEff
These are all solid players with a question mark in their game, usually revolving around a lack of power. There’s nothing wrong with this group, but they are, at this point, complimentary pieces not cornerstones.
Note that Alejandro Oms, Sherry Magee, and Tim Raines are so young that being here really puts them on a great trajectory.
#D Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
NL
IND
Bob Bescher
26
253/355/440
80 SB
1.93 RF -4.8 ZR
—
LAA/ NYG
Don Buford
32
239/363/450
28 SB
.993 fPct
—
NYY/ HOU
Elliott Maddox
21
260/371/397
.972 fPct -5.8 ZR 2.7 ARM
NL
KCM
Ducky Medwick
29
261/290/467
1.94 RF -3.4 ARM
The only thing separating Bob Bescher from Raines is playing time, so perhaps he belongs up one Tier alongside The Rock? And this may be a bit unfair to Ducky Medwick, but the statistical metrics really ding him for not being willing to take a walk.
#F Tier
Lg
Tm
Name
Age
Slash
Other
Def
AL
POR
Kiki Cuyler
32
240/315/364
26 SB
—
POR/ PHI
Harry Hooper
24
203/312/382
31 SB
1.000 fPct 2.0 ARM
NL
BBB
Bob Nieman
30
209/301/413
There is some talent here, but nowhere near the offensive production to hold down a roster spot in the WBL.
#Rookies
Juan Beníquez (C Tier), Elliott Maddox (D Tier), and Kiki Cuyler (F Tier).
#Fielding Notes
We have our standard defensive stats here, with the leaders in bold and the worst performers in italics. Assists (A), more romantically referred to as Outfield Kills are runners eliminated on the bases. Range Factor (RF) measures the number of plays made per game–the higher the better. Zone Rating (ZR) attempts to credit players for plays other fielders missed and ding them for plays other fielders made–the higher the better, and it has the benefit of being comparative across the position. Defensive Efficiency (dEff) measures the rate at which an individual fielder contributes to outs being made on balls put into play, with any score over 1.000 being a net positive impact. Finally, Fielding Percentage (fPct) reflects the percentage of times a chance was handled without a mistake–if someone made no errors, their fPct would be 1.000.
Of these, Range Factor is the most susceptible to the impact of the pitching staff and the ballpark, although none of these defensive ratings are perfect.
JP Arencibia and Eddie Mathews each hit 2 out as Birmingham topped Indianapolis, 9-4. Lefty Gomez carried a no-hitter through 6 innings, and Hank Aaron and Jim Pagliaroni also went deep for the Black Barons.
Then, Adrián González and Albert Belle did the same, pounding 2 homers each in a 13-7 victory over Indianapolis. Belle drove in 6, giving him 99 on the year.
Aaron again hit 2 out, but the Black Barons fell to Houston in 10 innings, 7-6. There were some positives: Greg Maddux had a good start, something of which they’ll need more of if they want to slide into that final Wild Card slot.
#Houston Colt 45s
37 year old backstop Bob Boone announced his retirement, as well as a desire to go into coaching.
The Colt 45’s had one of their most dominant showings of the year in a 22-1 triumph over Ottawa. Roger Clemens improved to 17-9 with 8+ innings and 10 strikeouts, and the team rapped out 8 homeruns, including 2 from Jeff Bagwell. Bagwell drove in 8 on the day, eclipsing the century mark on the season. Paul Goldschmidt, Jim Wynn, Elliott Maddox, Will Smith, Craig Biggio, and Jackie Warner each also went deep for Houston, and the win extended the Colt 45’s lead in the Marvin Miller Division to 4 games.
Indianapolis ABC’s
Luis Padrón remains superlative, improving to 22-3 with a 4 hit shutout of Philadelphia. Chris Sabo had 2 homers as the ABC’s triumphed, 8-0.
George Foster drove in a half-dozen runs as the ABC’s came from behind to beat Philadelphia 10-8. Foster and Ed Charles had 3 hits each and Foster, Charles, and Johnny Bench each went deep.
#Kansas City Monarchs
The Monarchs recalled Dale Murphy from a rehab assignment, sending utility speedster Rex Hudler back to AAA. More importantly, Smokey Joe Wood began his own rehab, with a goal of being back with the big club by the end of the week.
Wood was indeed recalled, with Dustin Hermanson being returned to AAA. Wood will start in the bullpen, but should re-enter the rotation next week.
#Wandering House of David
Jim Clinton began a rehab assignment, and then was recalled with Frank Sullivan heading to AAA.
We’re going to do this by position group, ignoring league differences (although we will have a Rookie Team for each league in the offseason).
Only 6 players are officially full time (that is, they qualify for the batting stats): IF Jimmie Foxx, OFs Turkey Stearnes, John Briggs, Adam Dunn, and Ichiro Suzuki, and everywhere playing Charles Rogan. That group probably forms the core of the shortlist for the final Rookie of the Year Award: if you’re able to hold down a fulltime starting spot as a rookie in the WBL …
#C
Perhaps unsurprisingly, there are no fulltime rookie catchers, although 2–Philadelphia’s Bill Dickey and the House of David’s Frank Chance–have seen more and more time as the season has worn on.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
JP Arencibia
30
BBB
NL
.769 / -0.3
166 PA, 15 HR, 29 RBI
Frank Chance
24
HOD
NL
.658 / -0.2
250 PA
Bill Dickey
23
PHI
NL
.772 / 0.4
159 PA, 23 RBI
Dick Dietz
29
NYG
NL
.937 / 0.7
94 PA
Tom Haller
33
BAL
AL
.839 / 0.7
127 PA
AJ Pierzynski
28
LAA
AL
.630 / -0.4
191 PA, 9 HR
Really, that’s it. Chance has played about 3/4 of the time behind the plate, so the playing time is pretty consistent. So … Tom Haller (who is likely to not have a very long career, although he’ll be retained as the backup in Baltimore next season for sure) in the AL and Dickey in the NL.
#1B/3B
The corner IF spots are a bit rough, given the high end talent in the AL and the lack of presence in the NL.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Jimmie Foxx
1B/3B
21
SFS
AL
.924 / 2.3
510 PA, 44 HR, 82 RBI
Joe Harris
1B
36
HOD/ KCM
NL
.899 / 1.1
429 PA
Eddie Murray
1B
22
BAL
AL
.857 / 0.2
79 PA
David Ortiz
1B
27
MEM
AL
1.039 / 2.0
293 PA, 30 HR, 62 RBI
Andy Pafko
3B
29
BBB/ MCG
NL/ AL
.851 / 0.6
260 PA
Chris Sabo
3B
29
IND
NL
.780 / 0.2
297 PA
Foxx’s being the only rookie infielder to qualify for the batting championship gives him the lead, despite Ortiz’ remarkable production. Foxx played a little more at 1B than 3B, but given the paucity of hot corner candidates, may get the recognition there, clearing the way for Ortiz.
Pafko played as much in RF as 3B, but we needed more 3B here. Harris is a nice feel-good story–nothing like a 36 year old rookie come good.
#2B/SS
2 of the best here–Cal Ripken, Jr. and Judy Johnson–played regularly elsewhere (including 3B), but logged the majority of their innings in the middle infield.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Royce Clayton
SS
22
SFS
AL
1.020 / 0/7
100 PA
Charlie Gehringer
2B
25
DET
AL
.798 / 0.3
418 PA, 14 HR, 48 RBI
Frank Grant
2B/SS
22
HOD/ SFS
NL/ AL
.754 / 1.1
283 PA
Judy Johnson
SS
18
HOM
NL
.809 / 1.2
240 PA
Dobie Moore
SS
20
MEM
AL
.779 / 1.1
378 PA
Cal Ripken, Jr.
SS
23
BAL
AL
.876 / 2.3
370 PA, 22 HR, 62 RBI
Joe Sewell
SS
23
CLE
AL
.852 / 0.9
133 PA
Interesting list, with Gehringer being the only truly full time player for the entire season, although both Moore and Ripken are close enough to count. The lack of talent at 2B and in the NL is striking.
#OF
Here we have the clear overall RoY from the field players, but there’s more to chew on here than Turkey. Sorry.
Name
Pos
Age
Tm
Lg
OPS / WAR
Other
Juan Beníquez
LF
35
DET
AL
.916 / 1.9
400 PA
John Briggs
CF
21
BRK
NL
.930 / 2.7
448 PA
Kiki Cuyler
LF
32
POR
AL
.675 / -0.5
305 PA
Adam Dunn
LF
22
IND
NL
.831 / 0.5
502 PA
George Foster
RF
22
IND
NL
.841 / 1.5
432 PA
Al Kaline
RF
21
DET
AL
.919 / 2.1
422 PA, 75 RBI
Elliott Maddox
OF
21
NYY/ HOU
AL/ NL
.766 / 0.2
406 PA
Rick Monday
CF
24
OTT
NL
1.019 / 1.6
307 PA
Julio Rodríguez
CF
20
MCG
AL
1.024 / 1.8
355 PA, 35 HR
Charles Rogan
CF
27
PHI
NL
.964 / 3.0
466 PA
Turkey Stearnes
CF
22
SFS
AL
1.134 / 6.0
512 PA, 47 HR, 115 RBI
Ichiro Suzuki
RF
28
LAA
AL
.698 / -0.5
513 PA
Sam Thompson
RF
27
OTT
NL
.820 / -0.2
362 PA
We’re not going to be too picky about positions here, going with Stearnes, Kaline, and J-Rod in the AL and Briggs, Rogan, and Foster in the NL; or perhaps Monday, if you want to recognize Rogan on the mound.
The surprises here are probably Briggs (who had an army of doubters, but is 2nd here in WAR) and Monday, whose offense just kept demanding more and more playing time. And mention has to be made of Beníquez–35 years old and a dominant year. He played 1B and 3B as well, so may see recognition there.
#SP
A dozen rookies made 10 or more starts; of those, a half-dozen are worth taking a closer look at.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
W-L
ERA
IP
WHIP
FIP
WAR
A. Rube Foster
23
KCM
NL
10-6
3.21
185
0.99
3.72
5.1
Bump Hadley
23
SFS
AL
16-5
4.15
169
1.22
4.07
4.3
Charles Rogan
27
PHI
NL
11-9
4.41
169
1.23
4.81
3.1
Fernando Valenzuela
24
BRK
NL
13-5
3.60
148
1.02
4.32
3.1
Jim Whitney
24
BBB/ MCG
NL/ AL
8-6
3.79
176
1.08
4.39
4.2
Joe Williams
24
BRK
NL
12-11
3.87
188
1.24
3.69
6.0
Foster is the clear class of this group, but Smokey Joe is a very close 2nd. I would add Whitney and Valenzuela to the award list, giving Brooklyn 2 of the 4 slots.
#RP
There aren’t a ton of relievers who are impactful enough to really warrant discussion here, but there are some.
Name
Age
Tm
Lg
W-L
ERA
Sv
H
WHIP
Terry Forster
22
BRK
NL
1-2
3.56
2
14
1.12
Eddie Guardado
25
KCM
NL
2-2
2.20
1
9
1.00
Billy Hoeft
19
DET
AL
2-3
6.10
2
10
1.50
Brad Kilby
27
PHI
NL
3-3
6.20
2
14
1.24
Firpo Marberry
28
CLE
AL
7-0
4.72
3
11
1.34
Tug McGraw
27
HOU
NL
5-4
2.95
12
5
1.20
Andrew Miller
23
MEM
AL
6-8
4.41
3
11
1.33
Skel Roach
28
MEM
AL
2-1
4.31
3
12
1.49
Marberry, McGraw, Forster, and Guardado look pretty solid.
A run through of the trading deadline, in no particular order. Over 50 players and almost 20 draft picks changed hands in the frenzy.
Hoyt There it Is!
P Waite Hoyt, 5th round pick from NYY to CAG for P Hoyt Wilhelm, IF Jorge Orta, 4th round pick.
The New York Black Yankees address a bullpen need by acquiring Hoyt Wilhelm from the Chicago American Giants, in exchange for young starter Waite Hoyt. Chicago will also send young IF Jorge Orta to New York, and the 2 teams exchanged draft picks, with New York getting a 4th and Chicago a 5th rounder.
It’s an odd trade for New York, as it’s not clear that Hoyt (Wilhelm) adds more to their bottom line of wins more than Hoyt (Waite). Chicago probably wins this one, just on the SP > RP evaluation. Orta should have a WBL career, but is not enough to balance the deal.
Now & Later
IF Paul Konerko, P Akinori Otsuka, OF Lenny Dykstra, 3rd round pick from CAG to BBB for P Sam Streeter, IF Trea Turner, 5th round pick.
Chicago officially closed the door on their performance for this season, sending 1B Paul Konerko and his .988 OPS along with Akinori Otsuka and his 1.07 WHIP to Birmingham, receiving P Sam Streeter and prospect Trea Turner in return. Chicago will also send OF Lenny Dykstra and a 3rd round pick, with Birmingham surrendering a 5th rounder to make it all work.
Konerko and Otsuka being on the wrong side of 30 makes this acceptable, and Chicago probably got peak value for them in a long-term starter and the talent of Turner. Birmingham is thrilled, as this addresses two of their most pressing needs for a playoff push: 1B and bullpen help.
The Wolverines Commit
P Gene Conley, P Bill Drake, P Emil Yde, OF Hub Collins from DET to BAL for SS Bobby Wallace, P Connie Johnson.
Detroit addressed two needs in a deal with Baltimore, sending struggling P Gene Conley (who is in search of a reboot to their career after an amazing start last season), promising young Ps Bill Drake and Emil Yde along with OF Hub Collins to Baltimore in exchange for SS Bobby Wallace and P Connie Johnson.
I mean … Detroit loves this for the immediate future. The key here is whether Yde, and especially Drake, ever amount to anything. This does remove any question about the infield of the future for the Black Barons, with Eddie Murray, Miller Huggins, Cal Ripken, Jr. and Manny Machado all but assured of starting roles.
Stars and Sea Dogs move a lot of Bodies
SS Jim Fregosi, P Mark Melancon, OF Harry Hooper, IF Rafael Palmiero from POR to PHI for OF Bobby Abreau, P Dave Stieb, P Jaret Wright, P LaTroy Hawkins, SS Pat Meares, 2nd round pick.
Philadelphia, eyeing a potential playoff run, went shopping in Portland. They added a long-term solution at SS (Jim Fregosi), a much-needed bullpen arm (Mark Melancon), and some OF depth in the struggling Harry Hooper. That haul cost them 3 pitching prospects in Dave Stieb, Jaret Wright, and LaTroy Hawkins, as well as SS Pat Meares, and a 2nd round pick. The teams also swapped high-ceiling-but-blocked prospects, with Portland receiving Bobby Abreu and Philadelphia Rafael Palmiero.
Abreau for Palmiero is a wash. Of the rest, it’s sort of a classic now/later proposition. Fregosi and Melancon step directly into key roles for the Stars, but Hawkins, and especially Stieb, do look like excellent long term prospects.
The American Giants Do Some (More) Things
OF Jake Stenzel from IND to CAG for P Joe Lake.
IF Freddie Lindstrom, 2nd round pick from HOM to CAG for P David Price.
Chicago believes they can solve their pitching woes from within, sending 2 members of their rotation packing. First, they received CF Jake Stenzel from Indianapolis for Joe Lake; then they sent David Price to Homestead for Freddie Lindstrom and a 2nd round pick.
Stenzel steps into a crowded outfield, but should get a lot of play the rest of the season while the American Giants’ commitment to the struggling teen Cristóbal Torriente is tested. This basically decimates the American Giants’ rotation, leaving them with Ed Walsh and a lot of questions, but Lake and Price (who himself only arrived via trade earlier last season) were questions themselves. Lindstrom may step into a WBL role behind Dick Allen at 3B.
A Closer for Some Future
P Jonathan Papelbon, 4th round pick from MEM to MCG for P Josh Beckett, OF Roy Thomas, 3rd round pick.
Memphis sent Jonathan Papelbon to Miami, receiving minor leaguers Josh Beckett and Roy Thomas in return. The team also exchange draft picks, with Memphis surrendering a 4th in exchange for Miami’s 3rd round selection.
Fair enough. Miami desperately needed a dependable arm to join Ricky Nolasco in their pen, and Beckett has a ton of upside.
The Black Barons Upgrade
IF Bobby Grich, 3rd round pick from LAA to BBB for P Vic Willis, C Gene Tenace, 1st round pick.
Birmingham came into this trade period looking for a SS; they left with a 2B (who can play SS). In a bit of a surprise move, they convinced LA to part with Bobby Grich, sending Vic Willis, Gene Tenace, and a 1st rounder to the Angels, who also sent a 3rd round pick back their way.
Grich is a huge pickup for the Black Barons–an all star caliber who can get on base and play both middle infield positions is exactly what the doctor ordered in Birmingham. They gave up a lot–Tenace is excellent, some think Willis will eventually be a number one starter, and of course, the #1 pick is a lot. But it seems Birmingham is convinced they have a shot in the playoffs this year, and you can’t fault the ambition.
First Round Picks On the Move, or Freeman at Last, Freeman at Last
P Joe Beggs, 2nd round pick from BAL to KCM for OF Earl Averill.
IF Freddie Freeman, IF Eddie Miller from SFS to LAA for P Joe Nathan, IF Wally Joyner, 1st round pick.
Baltimore found a potential CF for the future in Earl Averill, who came over from Kansas City for a Joe Beggs and a 2nd round pick.
One of the more promising talents in the WBL may have found a home, as Los Angeles sent a 1st Round Pick, closer Joe Nathan, and Wally Joyner to San Francisco for Freddie Freeman and minor league SS Eddie Miller.
Both of these make some sense, as both Freeman and Averill were totally blocked where they were (Freeman by Jimmie Foxx and others, Averill by Willie McGee and Cool Papa Bell). Freeman should immediately see playing time in LA, while Averill looks to be in the mix for next season.
Gothams Going Gone
P Juan Marichal, P Robb Nen from NYG to HOM for IF Davey Johnson, IF Howard Johnson, 3rd round pick.
P Steve Howe, P Troy Percival from NYG to DET for IF Robby Thompson, P Dellin Betances, 3rd round pick.
The Gothams moved a few pieces around, sending Juan Marichal and Robb Nen to Homestead for 2B Davey Johnson, Howard Johnson, and a 3rd round pick. Then, they moved Steve Howe and Troy Percival to Detroit for 2B Robby Thompson, P Dellin Betances, and a 3rd round pick.
The Gothams will need to totally redo their staff, but each move makes some sense. Between Johnson (Davey) and Thompson, they should now have a post-Larry Doyle plan at 2B.
The Black Yankees Find their SS of the Future?
P Sparky Lyle, IF Elliott Maddox, P Carlos Rodón, 2nd round pick, 4th round pick from NYY to HOU for IF Grant Johnson.
They hope so, sending Sparky Lyle, Elliott Maddox, pitching prospect Carlos Rodón, and a 2nd and a 4th round pick to Houston for Grant Johnson, who will rotate in with both Derek Jeter and Rogers Hornsby for now.
It’s a lot to give up, for sure. But Johnson is only 25, and an established WBL performer who will solve the Black Yankees’ long term needs at either 2B or SS. Lyle is solid, and fills a very strong need for Houston, but the rest of what they gave up was future potential, which is cheap for a team whose goal is to win now.
Other Deals
OF George Hendrick from PHI to BRK for 3rd round pick.
IF Joe Adcock from NYG to MCG for 5th round pick, cash.
Philadelphia sent OF George Hendrick to Brooklyn for a 3rd Round Pick.
Miami picked up Joe Adcock from the New York Gothams essentially for free: they sent the Gothams a 5th round pick, and the Gothams are covering Adcock’s salary for the rest of the year.
Each of these were essentially curtesy trades: having picked up Harry Hooper, Philadelphia had no place for Hendrick and Adcock, at 38, desperately wanted a chance to swing the bat for a contender in what may be his final season.
Summary
Minor Leaguers in italics.
Team
Coming
Going
Baltimore Black Sox
Earl Averill Gene Conley Hub Collins Bill Drake Emil Yde 2nd Round Pick
Joe Beggs Connie Johnson Bobby Wallace 1st Round Pick 2nd Round Pick
Birmingham Black Barons
Lenny Dykstra Bobby Grich Paul Konerko Akinori Otsuko 3rd Round Pick 4th Round Pick
Something was clearly wrong with Mike Mussina all season. Turns out an elbow problem wen unnoticed until it forced him from the game in a 6-5 victory over Chicago. Mussina hit the DL and is expected to miss a few weeks, with the Black Sox finally, and excitedly, recalling Ned Garvin to take his place.
#Cleveland Spiders
Ron Blomberg went deep 3 times (including a 530 ft moon shot) and drove in 7 as the Spiders rolled over Baltimore, 8-4. Cy Young struggled a bit, but only allowed 1 earned run in 6 innings, improving to 3-1.
Lance Berkman matched Blomberg, going deep twice (including his own 550 ft. moon shot), but it wasn’t enough as the Spiders fell to Baltimore, 5-3.
Stan Coveleski hit the 10 day DL, with Hank Gastright being recalled from AAA.
The Spiders exploded for 16 runs and 21 hits in a 16-8 doubling of Detroit. Johnny Bates and Joe Sewell had 4 hits each, Bates and John Ellis drove in 4 runs, Bates scored 4 times and Bates and Ellis each went deep twice (with one of Bates’ shots being a nearly 540 ft. bomb). Gastright picked up the win in relief of a very ineffective Pat Malone, who couldn’t make it through 5 innings despite being staked to a 13-2 lead.
#Detroit Wolverines
Ty Cobb‘s 2 homeruns and 5 RBIs will grab the headlines, but the Wolverines don’t beat Portland 7-3 in 11 innings without Ed Bailey throwing out 6 runners trying to steal over the course of the ballgame. Mike Henneman threw 2 scoreless innings for the win, improving to 2-0 on the year.
#Memphis Red Sox
The Red Sox clubbed 6 homeruns, with both Billy Bryan and Bill White going yard twice, in a 15 to 8 romp over San Francisco. White drove in 4 and Ted Williams, White, and Dobie Moore had 4 hits each.
In what is likely a single-game maneuver, the Red Sox demoted Alex Johnson and recalled Carl Mays from AA for a start. Mays pitched well enough for the win, but not well enough to stick around, as the Red Sox beat the Sea Lions, 10-6 with Manny Ramírez going deep twice. David Ortiz and Wade Boggs had 3 hits each, and Williams also went deep in the victory.
Johnson was left at AAA, with Joe Rudi being recalled.
A 6-5 loss to the Black Yankees was especially costly, as both Skel Roach and Shane Bieber hit the DL. Roach is likely to be out a few weeks, while Bieber may miss only 1 or 2 starts at the most. Derek Lowe and Sadie McMahon were recalled from AAA New Orleans.
#New York Black Yankees
Babe Ruth hit 2 homeruns with the 2nd being a walkoff shot in the bottom of the 11th as the Black Yankees topped Chicago, 5-4. That gives New York 3 players tied for the league lead in homers with 11 in Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Mickey Mantle.
Mike Schmidt went deep twice as the Black Yankees built a lead, and then held on for a 9-5 win over the American Giants. Schmidt drove in 6 and Manny Sanguillén had 3 hits, while Ron Guidry improved to 3-1 with 11 strikeouts in just over 6 innings of work.
This team keeps hitting longballs: this time it was Mantle’s turn to go deep twice as the Black Yankees beat Memphis 6-3. Elliott Maddox had 3 hits and Jack Scott pitched a strong 8 innings in improving to 3-2.
Waite Hoyt was placed on the 10 day DL, with veteran AJ Burnett recalled from AAA.
Dennis Martínez spun a masterful 2-hit shutout and Baltimore sent 13 people to the plate in a 9 run 6th inning as they demolished Detroit 12-0. Martínez fanned 4 without giving up a walk in the complete game effort, evening his record to 1-1. Frank Robinson and Manny Machado had 3 hits each for Baltimore.
Curt Blefary went deep twice, including a long grand slam, as the Black Sox topped the Wolverines, 14-6. Blefary scored 4 times, drove in 5, and had 3 hits total.
#Cleveland Spiders
Lance Berkman went deep twice, driving in 4, and Evan Longoria delivered a walkoff blast as Cleveland beat Portland 8-7. Johnny Bates and Tris Speaker had 3 hits each for the Spiders.
Speaker drove in 4 and Berkman 3 as the Spiders took a 10-0 lead, and then held on for dear life in a 10-8 victory over Memphis. Berkman would continue his hot start the following day, driving in the winning run in the 10th in a 3-2 win for the Spiders.
#Detroit Wolverines
Ty Cobb had 4 hits–3 of which were doubles–leading the Wolverines to a 7-6 victory over Chicago. Mike Henneman continued his perfect start to the year, earning his 4th save.
Whitey Wilshere was sent to AAA temporarily as the Wolverines needed a starter. George Bechtel was recalled for the start, with an expectation that Wilshere would be recalled shortly after the game. Bechtel did fine and got the victory, but was returned to AAA that evening.
#Memphis Red Sox
Reggie Smith went deep twice, but those were the only runs Memphis could score in a 3-2 loss to Cleveland.
#New York Black Yankees
Babe Ruth and Mickey Mantle each had 2 homeruns as the Black Yankees outslugged Baltimore 14-11. Ruth drove in 6–his 2nd 6 RBI game of the young season–and Mantle and Manny Sanguillén had 3 hits each for New York.
Eric Davis went deep twice and Elliott Maddox had 3 hits as the Black Yankees beat up on San Francisco, 12-4. Waite Hoyt had a decent 8 innings, moving to 3-0 on the year and Lou Gehrig and Mantle each also had homeruns for New York.
With opening day just around the corner, we thought it would be interesting to see how the draft worked out …
#Love ‘Em (Draft Picks Making Opening Day Rosters)
1st Round
Charles “Bullet Joe” Rogan, the overall #1 pick in the draft, makes Philadelphia’s opening day roster, expected to be their 4th OF and provide bullpen support. The Stars’ other first-rounder, Dave Stieb, made their opening day rotation.
Two outfielders were taken with the 7th and 8th picks, and both should be in their team’s opening day lineups, as San Francisco took CF Turkey Stearnes at 7 and Los Angeles RF Ichiro Suzuki at 8.
2nd Round
Miami took Julio Rodríguez with the 2nd pick in round 2 thinking the 19 year old would be a project for the future; instead he breaks camp as their starting CF.
Homestead’s Tim Lincecum makes the opening day roster in their bullpen, and Houston’s César Cedeño will start the season as their reserve OF (although this is expected to only last until George Brett‘s return from injury, but you never know).
Portland drafted 26 year old Walter Ball expecting him to be ready for the WBL, and he delivered, starting the season in their rotation.
Some mention should be made of Kansas City’s Matt Morris, who was expected to make their rotation before tearing his labrum.
3rd Round
Dobie Moore exploded on the scene for Memphis and should see essentially full time usage alternating between SS and 2B.
Philadelphia breaks camp with Bill Gatewood in the bullpen.
5th Round
The New York Black Yankees didn’t expect Noah Syndergaard to make the opening day roster, but he did.
Detroit is even more surprised at the performance and poise from 18 year old Billy Hoeft, who will start the season in their bullpen.
6th Round
Jess Barbour was a throw-in in the Albert Belle/Andy Pettitte trade, but his defensive flexibility and speed kept him around for Birmingham.
8th Round
Ottawa’s staff was essentially open going into Spring Training, so while Dupee Shaw making the team was a surprise, it wasn’t a shock.
The Black Yankees’ bench received a complete overhaul, with Elliot Maddox earning a spot out of the gate.
9th Round
Jack Billingham starts the season in Indianapolis’ bullpen.
12th Round
Indianapolis took Edward “The Only” Nolan with their final pick of the draft. Nolan starts the year on their staff as the WBL’s version if Mister Irrelevant.
#Leave ‘Em (Draft Picks No Longer With Original Organization)
Other than the inexplicable treatment of Chino Smith, this all looks fine. Topsy Hartsel should find a home somewhere, the rest may or may not.
1st Round: Vladimir Guerrero, OF (traded from MCG to POR)
2nd Round: Jon Matlack, P (traded from POR to MCG)
3rd Round: Topsy Hartsel, OF (BAL)
4th Round: Leo Cardenas, IF (IND); Bob Smith, P (BBB); Denard Span (traded from POR to OTT)
7th Round: Cass Michaels, IF (CAG)
8th Round: Ray Blades, OF (KCM); Chino Smith, IF (MEM, now with BAL); Lee Stange, P (POR, now with HOM)
9th Round: Justin Steel, P (HOD)
10th Round: Doug Bair, P (KCM); Greg Pryor, IF (BRK)
11th Round: Nick Allen, IF (SFS); Vern Kennedy, P (CAG); Eddie Solomon, P (BBB)
12th Round: Jeff Ballard, P (BBB); Craig Gentry, OF (CAG); Dave Lemanczyk, P (SFS); José Lopéz, 1B (MCG); Hal Mauck, P (HOD); Connor Seabold, P (MEM)
Same as it ever was: despite not making the playoffs last year, the Black Yankees will be expected to contend for the Whirled Championship. That’s what happens when you have Babe Ruth, and, if you had him, you wouldn’t want it any other way.
Best Case
Everything that was supposed to happen last year does: Ron Guidry establishes himself as an elite ace with Waite Hoyt and Jack Scott close behind; the bullpen’s revival, led by Aroldis Chapman, proves real; Lou Gehrig and/or Mike Schmidt move from good to excellent; and Ruth keeps doing Ruth things.
Worst Case
Not only does the pitching fail to come through, but Thurman Munson, Eric Davis, and Mickey Mantle all regress and nobody else truly steps up.
Key Questions
It’s all about the bullpen, according to the media.
There will be a lot of attention on last year’s ERA champion, Andy Pettitte–with some of that focused on what the loss of Albert Belle means for what was truly a fearsome bench last year.
Trade Bait
Sure. The most useful pieces would be OF Albert Belle, SS Derek Jeter, and 2B Tom Herr, any of whom could potentially move on.
You can’t accuse New York of not making moves: Belle is gone, along with some other good talent, in exchange for Andy Pettitte, further deepening what could be–could be–a great pitching staff.
Roster Evaluation
POS
Elite
Strong
Solid
Meh
Weak
Unknown
C
Munson
Sanguillén
1B
Gehrig Mattingly
Etten
2B
Herr
3B
Schmidt
López Maddox
SS
Jeter
LF/ RF
Ruth Mantle
CF
Davis
SP
Pettitte
Scott Guidry Hoyt
Ruffing
End
Chapman
Cormier
Gossage
RP
Lavelle
Lyle Righetti
Robertson
New Addition | Injured
That sure looks like a contending team, especially when you see the potential for some of the players to take steps leftward.
Talent Ratings
WBL
Minors
Raw Power
OF Babe Ruth
1B Fred Whitfield
Batting Eye
OF Babe Ruth
IF Jack Crooks
Contact
C Manny Sanguillén
OF Mickey Rivers
Running Speed
OF Eric Davis
IF Hal Chase
Base Stealing
OF Eric Davis
IF Hal Chase
IF Defense
3B Mike Schmidt
IF Aaron Hill
OF Defense
OF Babe Ruth
OF Bill Lange
Stuff
P Dave Righetti
P Dewey Adkins
Control
P Andy Pettitte
P Carlos Silva
Velocity
RP David Robertson
P AJ Burnett P Mike Fetters
Best In The Minors
Rank
Age
POS
Name
1 (26)
21
P
Noah Syndergaard
2 (37)
23
P
Jake Peavy
3 (66)
25
P
Whitey Ford
4 (98)
21
P
Carlos Rodón
5 (119)
21
P
Tony Brizzolara
6 (140)
22
OF
Clyde Milan
7 (168)
21
U
Elliott Maddox
Others: None.
This is an old system (there isn’t a single teenager in it), and one that is lacking in talent beyond the top 3. But those top 3 are pretty strong, so perhaps that won’t matter. Maddox breaks camp with the Black Yankees.
Most
Least
Age
OF Ollie Pickering, 38
1B Anthony Volpe, 20
Height
P Jeff Nelson, 6’8″
C Eddie Fusselback, 5’6″
OPS
OF Babe Ruth, 1.091 (WBL)
OF Ron Pruitt, .487 (—)
HR
OF Babe Ruth, 48 (WBL)
OF Wally Rehg, 2 (—) IF Tom Herr, 2 (WBL) IF Jerry Freeman, 2 (AAA/AA) IF Harry Bauchman, 2 (AA)
SB
OF Eric Davis, 64 (WBL)
Many with 0
WAR
OF Babe Ruth, 8.1 (WBL)
IF Devon Travis, -3.4 (—)
W
AJ Burnett, 15 (WBL/AAA) Andy Pettitte, 15 (WBL)
Sean Newcomb, 1 (—)
SV
Aroldis Chapman, 32 (WBL)
ERA
Mike Fornieles, 2.72 (—)
Hooks Dauss, 6.70 (AAA/AA)
WAR
Ron Bryant, 4.9 (—)
Lady Baldwin, -0.5 (WBL/AAA)
Stats are across all levels. 200 PA / 75 IP min. Non WBL leagues indicated by —.
The pitching staff will be under great scrutiny, with 5th round pick Noah Syndergaard having an outside shot at the rotation.
Last season the Black Yankees were hampered by limited MI flexibility, which will be a concern they want to address.
First Cuts
Things on the mound went much as expected for New York, as Cal Eldred, Don Liddle, Paul Shuey, Frank Viola, Bill Monbouquette, and John Danks all moved on to the minor leagues. Dave Righetti remains in camp, but his control continues to be a concern. On the other side, Lefty Gomez, Noah Syndergaard, and Whitey Ford have all impressed out of the gate.
Darrin Fletcher and Benny Bengough were both reassigned, with the Black Yankees planning to take a look at Ron Pruitt behind the plate as a 4th option. Fred Whitfield and Nick Etten have impressed at 1B, with Ryan Garko being sent to the minors while at 3B Aaron Hill and Elliott Maddox have been stellar (and Héctor López quite good), while Josh Harrison and Red Rolfe were both moved to the minors.
The 2B/SS situation was quite convoluted but poor starts from Mark Grudzielanek, Jess Barbour, Charlie Irwin, and Alcides Escobar have helped clear some space as all four of those IFers were reassigned, with Willie Randolph barely hanging on to a spot in camp.
In the OF, despite there not being much room on the eventual roster, only Bill Lange was moved from the major league camp, although there are doubts as to how long Clyde Milan and Nick Swisher will stick around.
Second Cuts
Other than Jeff Nelson, the pitching has been excellent for the Black Yankees, with nobody else posting an ERA over 3.00. Nelson heads to the minors while New York tries to sort out the rest.
C Gary Alexander was recalled for some depth, and to see if his impressive power holds up against better pitching.
Nick Swisher, Willie Randolph, and Ron Pruitt were sent down as well.
Third Cuts
Lady Baldwin and Vic Raschi were sent down, clearing up the back end of the staff a bit. Whitey Ford and Sparky Lyle are next on the chopping block, depending on what they do over the next week or so.
Eric MacKenzie, Pee Wee Reese, Red Rolfe, and Roger Maris were all sent to AAA. MacKenzie’s demotion keeps Gary Alexander in camp for a while, as much for his defensive flexibility as anything else.
While the IF starters–Tom Herr, Derek Jeter, and Mike Schmidt–are pretty much set, it’s unclear how the reserves will sort out, with Aaron Hill, Héctor López, and Elliott Maddux all making cases for roster spots. Veteran Doug DeCinces looks like he may be done, but he’ll be given another week to turn it around.
Final Cuts
SS Alex Arias was the first to go, in a move that would seem to indicate that Aaron Hill will break camp as the backup infielder for the Black Yankees. That was followed by the demotion of P Dewey Adkins, always considered a long shot to make the opening day roster.
1B Fred Whitfield had a good Spring, but there’s just too much blocking him at 1B, moving him to AAA for the time being.
Gary Alexander was pulled into camp to take some of the load behind the plate. He showed some pop, but little else, and was moved back to AAA as was Hardy Richardson, who was outperformed throughout the Spring by several lesser regarded prospects.
Whitey Ford clearly has the arm to have a future in the WBL, but his time is yet to come as the young lefty will start the season at AAA. He’ll be joined by veteran AJ Burnett, who had a spectacular Spring but was edged out by rookie Noah Syndergaard for the last spot on New York’s staff.
Aaron Hill was sent to AAA, cementing roster spots for Héctor López and Elliott Maddox and, perhaps surprisingly, sending veteran 3B Doug DeCinces (who was adequate as Mike Schmidt‘s backup last season) down as well. Maddox and López were retained partially for their defensive flexibility, pushing both Clyde Milan and recent acquisition Mickey Rivers to the minors.
All of that meant that Spring surprise Nick Etten starts the season with the Black Yankees.
Oh yeah … Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig made the team …
81 - 73, .525 pct.
2nd in Effa Manley Division, 5 games behind.
Overall
From pre season championship favorite to missing the playoffs: it was a massively disappointing year in the Bronx, and while most of the blame has been focused on the bullpen, there are other concenrs.
Long term, this is an old franchise; but it is also built to win now, so it has conflicting incentives in terms of getting WBL level help immediately and building depth throughout the organization.
Also, Babe Ruth.
What Went Right
Babe Ruth did Babe Ruth things.
Perhaps no other team offers as dangerous a series of 7 hitters as the Black Yankees, with Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Lou Gehrig, Albert Belle, Thurman Munson, Eric Davis, and Don Mattingly. It is very hard to work more than 6 of them into the lineup at the same time, but still.
Waite Hoyt, Jack Scott, and Red Ruffing were all excellent (Ruffing will miss much of next season through injury, however).
After being blasted for much of the season, the bullpen finally turned the corner with the acquisition of Aroldis Chapman. Once Chapman arrived, he, Rheal Cormier, and Goose Gossage began to consistently close out games.
The stats wonks insist that Ron Guidry was a top 5 starter this year, so he has that going for him.
ALL STARS
OF Eric Davis; 1B Lou Gehrig; SS Derek Jeter; OF Mickey Mantle; C Thurman Munson; P Red Ruffing; OF Babe Ruth.
What Went Wrong
The Black Yankees came out of the break with all-stars at both 2B (Tom Herr, acquired from Birmingham) and SS (Derek Jeter). Both struggled the rest of the season. Nothing worked in the middle infield all year: Willie Randolph was replaced by Herr, neither Hardy Richardson nor Red Rolfe did anything of note, and New York even turned to Pee Wee Reese, released earlier by Brooklyn. 2B/SS remains several notches below the level of the rest of the team.
So much ink has been spilled about their bullpen struggles, but it has to be mentioned. Suffice to say that Sparky Lyle and Dave Righetti pitched themselves right down to AAA, Ralph Citarella was pretty poor all season, and Gossage struggled until Chapman’s arrival.
The naked eye would insist that Guidry–their #1 starter going into the season–struggled. Plenty of strikeouts, but an 8-12 record and a 4.35 ERA are not what was expected.
Transactions
March
C Bill Dickey, OF Aaron Judge & 1B Prince Fielder to Philadelphia for 3B Mike Schmdit & P Cole Hamels
Right now, looks like a steal for New York, but the jury is still very much out.
June
IF Reddy Mack, OF Bill Buckner, P Heathcliff Slocumb, OF Charlie Keller, 1B Moose Skowron & 10th Round Pick to Birmingham for 2B Tom Herr
Birmingham got as much as they could from the deal and, given Herr’s struggles in New York, probably got the best of it.
IF Dick Bartell, OF Sam Thompson & 4th Round Pick to Ottawa for P Gary Lavelle and P Jamie Moyer
Meh. Given that both Lavelle and Moyer are in the twilights of their careers, you have to give Ottawa the edge here if any of the players turn into anything.
July
C Smoky Burgess & P Cole Hamels to Miami for P Aroldis Chapman & 3rd Round Pick {Brett Gardner}
A win for New York, even if Hamels develops as expected.
P Jim Clinton, 3B Chris Brown & 2nd Round Pick to House of David for P Dick Tidrow & 8th Round Pick {Elliott Maddox}
Tidrow was wildly inconsistent, so who knows.
P LaTroy Hawkins, P Fritz Coumbe, IF Mike Bordick & 3rd Round Pick to Philadelphia for P Rheal Cormier & 4th Round Pick {Mark Grudzielanek}
Meh. All of these deals were made to win now, and since that didn’t happen, have to be judged somewhat harshly.
Looking Forward
SP
Should be strong. Ron Guidry, Waite Hoyt, Whitey Ford, and Lefty Gomez will be supported by Vic Raschi, Frank Viola, and Dave Righetti long term. That’s a solid bunch.
RP
There is depth here, but not a lot of confidence. For now, Aroldis Chapman and Goose Gossage will close out games, but Sparky Lyle and David Robertson are both available as reinforcements.
C
Thurman Munson had a magnificent season.
1B
Lou Gehrig and Don Mattingly should have this–and DH–locked down for quite some time.
2B
The Black Yankees still hope that Willie Randolph comes around. But there’s a decent chance they are in the market for a 2B.
3B
Mike Schmidt should have a lot of good years left, although there is very little talent behind him.
SS
There is a lot of optimism about Derek Jeter, but so far it seems to have been misplaced.
LF
Ruth forever, some Albert Belle sprinkled in for now.
CF
A mixture of Mickey Mantle and Eric Davis.
RF
Ruth, Mantle, and Belle–essentially the Black Yankees have 4 starting OFers to go along with their 2 starting 1Bs.
The Rookie Draft
Rounds 1-4
What the Black Yankees need most–immediate help in the bullpen and depth at the big league level–won’t come through the rookie draft. As such, they are guided here by a desire to grab the best, youngest talent available. In the first round, that meant 19 year old David Cone, who has the advantage of being a franchise player as well.
With the 2nd pick of the 3rd round, they added another franchise selection in CF Brett Gardner and with the first choice of the 4th round, tried to fill in some MI depth with Mark Grudzielanek.
Rounds 5-8
The Black Yankees took a high risk/high reward flyer on P Noah Syndergaard, who could contribute in the next year or so, but also looks unlikely to stay healthy for very long, and then picked U player Jess Barbour in the 6th. Carlos Rodón is a bit of a project, but he becomes the final exception for the Black Yankees in round 7.
From here on out, it’s best talent with a slight preference for young position players, as their A level is pretty empty. That starts with young SS Anthony Volpe followed by IF/OF Elliott Maddox.
Rounds 9-12
OF Aaron Hicks; P Scott Kamieniecki; IF Charlie Irwin.
They were unable to come to terms with their first round pick, P David Cone.