We’re going to do this by position group, ignoring league differences (although we will have a Rookie Team for each league in the offseason).
Only 6 players are officially full time (that is, they qualify for the batting stats): IF Jimmie Foxx, OFs Turkey Stearnes, John Briggs, Adam Dunn, and Ichiro Suzuki, and everywhere playing Charles Rogan. That group probably forms the core of the shortlist for the final Rookie of the Year Award: if you’re able to hold down a fulltime starting spot as a rookie in the WBL …
#C
Perhaps unsurprisingly, there are no fulltime rookie catchers, although 2–Philadelphia’s Bill Dickey and the House of David’s Frank Chance–have seen more and more time as the season has worn on.
| Name | Age | Tm | Lg | OPS / WAR | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JP Arencibia | 30 | BBB | NL | .769 / -0.3 | 166 PA, 15 HR, 29 RBI |
| Frank Chance | 24 | HOD | NL | .658 / -0.2 | 250 PA |
| Bill Dickey | 23 | PHI | NL | .772 / 0.4 | 159 PA, 23 RBI |
| Dick Dietz | 29 | NYG | NL | .937 / 0.7 | 94 PA |
| Tom Haller | 33 | BAL | AL | .839 / 0.7 | 127 PA |
| AJ Pierzynski | 28 | LAA | AL | .630 / -0.4 | 191 PA, 9 HR |
Really, that’s it. Chance has played about 3/4 of the time behind the plate, so the playing time is pretty consistent. So … Tom Haller (who is likely to not have a very long career, although he’ll be retained as the backup in Baltimore next season for sure) in the AL and Dickey in the NL.
#1B/3B
The corner IF spots are a bit rough, given the high end talent in the AL and the lack of presence in the NL.
| Name | Pos | Age | Tm | Lg | OPS / WAR | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jimmie Foxx | 1B/3B | 21 | SFS | AL | .924 / 2.3 | 510 PA, 44 HR, 82 RBI |
| Joe Harris | 1B | 36 | HOD/ KCM | NL | .899 / 1.1 | 429 PA |
| Eddie Murray | 1B | 22 | BAL | AL | .857 / 0.2 | 79 PA |
| David Ortiz | 1B | 27 | MEM | AL | 1.039 / 2.0 | 293 PA, 30 HR, 62 RBI |
| Andy Pafko | 3B | 29 | BBB/ MCG | NL/ AL | .851 / 0.6 | 260 PA |
| Chris Sabo | 3B | 29 | IND | NL | .780 / 0.2 | 297 PA |
Foxx’s being the only rookie infielder to qualify for the batting championship gives him the lead, despite Ortiz’ remarkable production. Foxx played a little more at 1B than 3B, but given the paucity of hot corner candidates, may get the recognition there, clearing the way for Ortiz.
Pafko played as much in RF as 3B, but we needed more 3B here. Harris is a nice feel-good story–nothing like a 36 year old rookie come good.
#2B/SS
2 of the best here–Cal Ripken, Jr. and Judy Johnson–played regularly elsewhere (including 3B), but logged the majority of their innings in the middle infield.
| Name | Pos | Age | Tm | Lg | OPS / WAR | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Royce Clayton | SS | 22 | SFS | AL | 1.020 / 0/7 | 100 PA |
| Charlie Gehringer | 2B | 25 | DET | AL | .798 / 0.3 | 418 PA, 14 HR, 48 RBI |
| Frank Grant | 2B/SS | 22 | HOD/ SFS | NL/ AL | .754 / 1.1 | 283 PA |
| Judy Johnson | SS | 18 | HOM | NL | .809 / 1.2 | 240 PA |
| Dobie Moore | SS | 20 | MEM | AL | .779 / 1.1 | 378 PA |
| Cal Ripken, Jr. | SS | 23 | BAL | AL | .876 / 2.3 | 370 PA, 22 HR, 62 RBI |
| Joe Sewell | SS | 23 | CLE | AL | .852 / 0.9 | 133 PA |
Interesting list, with Gehringer being the only truly full time player for the entire season, although both Moore and Ripken are close enough to count. The lack of talent at 2B and in the NL is striking.
#OF
Here we have the clear overall RoY from the field players, but there’s more to chew on here than Turkey. Sorry.
| Name | Pos | Age | Tm | Lg | OPS / WAR | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Juan Beníquez | LF | 35 | DET | AL | .916 / 1.9 | 400 PA |
| John Briggs | CF | 21 | BRK | NL | .930 / 2.7 | 448 PA |
| Kiki Cuyler | LF | 32 | POR | AL | .675 / -0.5 | 305 PA |
| Adam Dunn | LF | 22 | IND | NL | .831 / 0.5 | 502 PA |
| George Foster | RF | 22 | IND | NL | .841 / 1.5 | 432 PA |
| Al Kaline | RF | 21 | DET | AL | .919 / 2.1 | 422 PA, 75 RBI |
| Elliott Maddox | OF | 21 | NYY/ HOU | AL/ NL | .766 / 0.2 | 406 PA |
| Rick Monday | CF | 24 | OTT | NL | 1.019 / 1.6 | 307 PA |
| Julio Rodríguez | CF | 20 | MCG | AL | 1.024 / 1.8 | 355 PA, 35 HR |
| Charles Rogan | CF | 27 | PHI | NL | .964 / 3.0 | 466 PA |
| Turkey Stearnes | CF | 22 | SFS | AL | 1.134 / 6.0 | 512 PA, 47 HR, 115 RBI |
| Ichiro Suzuki | RF | 28 | LAA | AL | .698 / -0.5 | 513 PA |
| Sam Thompson | RF | 27 | OTT | NL | .820 / -0.2 | 362 PA |
We’re not going to be too picky about positions here, going with Stearnes, Kaline, and J-Rod in the AL and Briggs, Rogan, and Foster in the NL; or perhaps Monday, if you want to recognize Rogan on the mound.
The surprises here are probably Briggs (who had an army of doubters, but is 2nd here in WAR) and Monday, whose offense just kept demanding more and more playing time. And mention has to be made of Beníquez–35 years old and a dominant year. He played 1B and 3B as well, so may see recognition there.
#SP
A dozen rookies made 10 or more starts; of those, a half-dozen are worth taking a closer look at.
| Name | Age | Tm | Lg | W-L | ERA | IP | WHIP | FIP | WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Rube Foster | 23 | KCM | NL | 10-6 | 3.21 | 185 | 0.99 | 3.72 | 5.1 |
| Bump Hadley | 23 | SFS | AL | 16-5 | 4.15 | 169 | 1.22 | 4.07 | 4.3 |
| Charles Rogan | 27 | PHI | NL | 11-9 | 4.41 | 169 | 1.23 | 4.81 | 3.1 |
| Fernando Valenzuela | 24 | BRK | NL | 13-5 | 3.60 | 148 | 1.02 | 4.32 | 3.1 |
| Jim Whitney | 24 | BBB/ MCG | NL/ AL | 8-6 | 3.79 | 176 | 1.08 | 4.39 | 4.2 |
| Joe Williams | 24 | BRK | NL | 12-11 | 3.87 | 188 | 1.24 | 3.69 | 6.0 |
Foster is the clear class of this group, but Smokey Joe is a very close 2nd. I would add Whitney and Valenzuela to the award list, giving Brooklyn 2 of the 4 slots.
#RP
There aren’t a ton of relievers who are impactful enough to really warrant discussion here, but there are some.
| Name | Age | Tm | Lg | W-L | ERA | Sv | H | WHIP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Terry Forster | 22 | BRK | NL | 1-2 | 3.56 | 2 | 14 | 1.12 |
| Eddie Guardado | 25 | KCM | NL | 2-2 | 2.20 | 1 | 9 | 1.00 |
| Billy Hoeft | 19 | DET | AL | 2-3 | 6.10 | 2 | 10 | 1.50 |
| Brad Kilby | 27 | PHI | NL | 3-3 | 6.20 | 2 | 14 | 1.24 |
| Firpo Marberry | 28 | CLE | AL | 7-0 | 4.72 | 3 | 11 | 1.34 |
| Tug McGraw | 27 | HOU | NL | 5-4 | 2.95 | 12 | 5 | 1.20 |
| Andrew Miller | 23 | MEM | AL | 6-8 | 4.41 | 3 | 11 | 1.33 |
| Skel Roach | 28 | MEM | AL | 2-1 | 4.31 | 3 | 12 | 1.49 |
Marberry, McGraw, Forster, and Guardado look pretty solid.
