73 - 89, .451 pct.
5th in Bill James Division, 17 GB
Overall
With low expectations come … well … another poor season in Memphis.
There are some decent pieces to build around here, but there is some ways to go. There is also a bit of a surplus of talent, especially in the OF, so some trade possibilities to hang in the air. Like so many WBL teams, the Red Sox struggle on the mound–I mean, they struggle everywhere, but it’s much easier to see the pieces coming together offensively than, especially, in their rotation.
Everything in Memphis revolves around Ted Williams, and how to build the franchise around the infinitely talented 22 year old.
What Went Right
Ted Williams had what felt like might qualify as an off-year by the time his career is over and done with. That still meant slashing 303/423/616, revealing a rare mixture of power and strike zone control.
Manny Ramírez improved on a rough initial year, leading the team with 46 homeruns and 110 RBIs with an OPS of 1.024. At 26, Ramírez should be entering his true prime, and while his lack of defensive skill pushes him towards a full time DH role, if he can maintain that level of performance, he’s a rare talent. The only caution is that he only saw 450ish PAs this season.
David Ortiz saw even less time, but hit even better: a 1.047 OPS and 34 homeruns in 100 games, displacing Bill White at 1B.
And while we’re on the topic of great performances in limited appearances, mention must be made of Lefty O’Doul (1.059 OPS) and Hack Wilson (1.036), each of whom have a shot at making the team out of Spring Training.
Billy Bryan was one of the best offensive backup catchers in the league, slashing 257/327/621 in support of Gabby Hartnett, who was pretty solid himself, posting an .879 OPS with good power.
And then we get pretty thin offensively: Reggie Smith and Mookie Betts were good enough, with mid .800s OPS numbers, but one or both of them need to improve, especially with the performance of the late season call ups. Betts, especially, may have value on the trade market.
On the mound, both Stubby Overmire and Len Barker racked up enough innings to generate decent WAR numbers, but were honestly not that great. That may be a little cruel on Overmire, who is clearly the best the Red Sox have to offer.
Andrew Miller was solid in a WBL leading 74 games, so there is value just in being rubber armed with a live arm, even if his walk rate is too high for comfort.
Tommy de la Cruz and Jameson Taillon were relatively effective in limited work. Taillon blew out his elbow, and won’t be back for about a year, effectively missing all of next season.
And then there is Skel Roach. 44 strikeouts in 40 innings and only 19 hits allowed … but 40 walks. So that can’t survive very long.
ALL STARS
Ted Williams
MAJOR AWARDS
Andrew Miller, AL Team of the Year
RECOGNITIONS
Andrew Miller, AL All Rookie Team; AL 25 & Under Team; AL 23 & Under Team
Dobie Moore, AL All Rookie 2nd Team; AL 21 & Under Team
David Ortiz, AL All Rookie 2nd Team
Skel Roach, AL All Rookie 2nd Team
ORGANIZATIONAL AWARDS
Ted Williams, MVP
Andrew Miller, Pitcher of the Year
David Ortiz, Heart & Soul
Skel Roach, Fan Favorite
Pete Richert, Minor League Pitcher of the Year
Lefty O'Doul, Minor League Player of the Year
What Went Wrong
Dobie Moore struggled a bit in his rookie year, but at 20 he has a lot of room to improve. There’s really not a lot else that went wrong, just a range of players who were fine: Wade Boggs, Bill White, and DJ LeMahieu leap to mind.
Whereas on the mound … Jon Lester and David Bush were pretty bad as starters, especially Lester. And major free agent signing Shane Bieber made only 8 poor starts before a long-term injury. Bieber should be back early in the season.
The Red Sox keep giving Sadie McMahon, Eddie Cicotte, Nixey Callahan, and Derek Lowe opportunities. And they keep fumbling, combining for a 4-8 record and ERA’s well over 6.00.
Heath Bell stumbled badly over the season, ending with a 3-5 record and an ERA in the mid 6’s.
Transactions
March
OF Sammy Sosa for C Gabby Hartnett, P Rollie Fingers & 4th Round Pick.
A massive, massive win. Sosa struggled mightily in Memphis, went back to the House of David … and struggled mightily. On the other hand, Hartnett looks like the Red Sox catcher for the foreseeable future.
OF David Justice, IF Ozzie Albies, 2nd Round Pick to BBB for IF Bill Buckner & OF Joe Rudi.
Sure. I mean, we can’t evaluate this one for a few years.
July
The season was over for Memphis at this point, but there weren’t any real buyers, so there wasn’t much activity.
IF Vern Stephens to BRG for 4th Round Pick.
This seemed to make sense: Stephens was having a miserable season, and the Red Sox had already decided that Dobie Moore was their future SS.
August
P Jonathan Papelbon & 4th Round Pick to MCG for P Josh Beckett, OF Roy Thomas & 3rd Round Pick.
Makes sense. Papelbon was excellent, and netted a strong return from the Cuban Giants.
Positional Overview
C
Gabby Hartnett came over and seems to have seized the position, which is quite good news for Memphis. Look for Billy Bryan to back him up again, with Rick Wilkins pressing for time from below.
There are some options: Brian McCann and Jason Varitek have some talent, and Dobie Moore can even play here in a pinch.
1B
David Ortiz‘ explosion really leaves Bill White flapping in the wind, which is a shame: White has been a quality contributor, and really deserves better. Best bet is the Red Sox shop White, and Ortiz holds this down until either Bill Buckner or Joe Cunningham are ready.
There are a ton of other options as well, most notably George Scott, Travis Shaw, and even young phenom Carl Yastrzemski.
2B
It seems that DJ LeMahieu may have taken this role for his own–LeMahieu clearly outperformed Dustin Pedroia, and really his only competition is Dobie Moore, who is probably headed for shortstop.
SS
The problem with Dobie Moore is his youth and his glove. Everything else looks incredible.
If he falters, we’re likely to see Woody English or Francisco Lindor given a chance.
So, there is optimism, but you could also see this as a very large question mark.
3B
Wade Boggs was … mediocre this year, but he will still be the 3B at the end of the day.
It’s not clear what happens next here, although young Candy Jim Taylor certainly shows promise.
LF/RF
LF is Ted Williams, period.
RF is a little less settled, but is likely Mookie Betts, with occasional support from Manny Ramírez. The complications here are the youth, with Lefty O’Doul, Dwight Evans, Joe Kelley, and most importantly Carl Yastrzemski, all pushing for playing time.
CF
Reggie Smith is far better than he gets credit for. That may not be enough as Hack Wilson is breathing down his neck pushing for playing time.
DH
Manny Ramírez most of the time. But, again, there is the Lefty O’Doul issue.
SP
Stubby Overmire leads, and then … well … then it is mostly question marks, although Len Barker and Dean Chance are favored.
The scouts keep pushing Eddie Cicotte, Sadie McMahon, and Nixey Callahan, but the fans don’t appreciate their results to date. If the Red Sox decide to give youth a chance, Josh Beckett, Nathan Eovaldi, or Jim Kaat could get a look.
RP
More uncertainty.
Heath Bell, Armando Benitez, and the incomprehensible Skel Roach may get first opportunities, along with the impressive Tommy de la Cruz. Rollie Fingers may get a look in the Spring as well.
Draft Outlook
DRAFT PICKS
1st Round: 1
2nd Round: 0
3rd Round: 2
4th Round: 2
5th Round: 1
Pitching, pitching, pitching. Maybe a middle infielder. Then, more pitching.
