So, a one game playoff in the Marvin Miller Division.
The question is … does either team want to go all out here? I would look for first-team offensive lineups. But both teams had been protecting the front of their rotations in expectations of a playoff series.
The two teams decide to split the difference, with Birmingham starting Vic Willis, 4-5 with a 3.57 ERA on the year and Portland countering with Dizzy Trout, 7-5 and 4.27.
If any player acquired in the middle of the season can claim to be their team’s MVP, Gavvy Cravath can make that argument, posting an OPS just shy of 1.200 in his time since being brought over from Philadelphia. With 2 outs in the bottom of the first and Joe Mauer on first, Cravath singled to right. A throwing error by Hank Aaron allowed Mauer to score for an early 1-0 lead for Portland.
The Black Barons would tie the game in the 4th, when Eddie Mathews led off with a double, moved to third on a single by Curtis Granderson, and scored on a wild pitch.
With the left-handed heart of Birmingham’s lineup due up, Trout was relieved by Mike Cuellar to start the 6th. It worked for 2 outs, but Adrián González took Cuellar deep to left, giving Birmingham a 2-1 edge.
It was short-lived: a double from Cravath and another from Rogers Hornsby each scored runs, and Portland reclaimed the lead, 3-2. That chased Willis from the game, but Portland was unable to increase their lead.
Mauer would add an insurance run in the bottom of the 7th, plating Greg Litton with a single to right. It was needed, as Mathews blasted his 27th homerun of the year in the top of the 8th. But Rafael Palmeiro–in the game as a defensive replacement–hit his first WBL moon shot in the 8th, restoring the 2 run lead.
It was bumpy, but Bob Porterfield prevailed, inducing a double play from Pie Traynor to end the game, and give the Sea Dogs the pennant.
BBB 3 (Willis 4-6) @ POR 5 (Cuellar 13-8, Porterfield 9 Sv; Hoffman 3 H)
HRs: BBB – González (11), Mathews (27); POR – Palmeiro (1).
Box Score
And with that, we have our playoff matchups set: Birmingham visits Detroit, Portland hosts Chicago, the New York Gothams head to Cleveland, and The House of David will visit Baltimore.