Baseball The Way It Never Was

Tag: Vito Tamulis

TWIWBL 103.1: Year 3, Week 6 – All About the Moundsmen

13 May, 2002

After the offensive explosion of 2001, the pendulum may have swung too far the other way, as the WBL saw 14 shutouts in 66 games this week. The incessant rain contributed, as a few were shortened games, but still.

Most impressively, Kansas City‘s Jock Menefee came within a single out of the first perfect game in WBL history. More detail on that, and the overall pitching dominance, below.

#Awards

Memphis‘s Ted Williams is the AL Player of the Week for the second time this season: 9-for-22 with 5 homeruns, 11 runs, 11 RBI and 7 walks in 6 games, slugging 1.091. He also pitched 2 innings. On the year he’s at 417/537/945 with 20 homeruns and 50 RBI, and is threatening to obliterate all sorts of records.

The NL Player of the Week is Birmingham‘s Eddie Mathews, who went 12-for-23 with 5 homeruns, 9 RBI and 8 runs, slugging 1.217. He came into the week hitting .188 and leaves it at .252, with 12 homeruns. Mathews has never hit for average–if he can maintain even something around .250, he’ll be among the best 3B in the league.

In the minors: Bill Doran (Los Angeles) took the award at AAA Las Vegas, going 13-for-25 with 2 homeruns and 10 RBI; Mike Tiernan (New York Gothams) won at AA Troy, going 7-for-10 with 3 doubles and 2 homeruns; and Kevin Young (Memphis) won at A-ball Pine Bluff, where the 31-year-old first baseman drove in 12 runs in 6 games.

Note that none of them are pitchers. So what’s the big deal on the mound?

#The Big Deal On the Mound

#One Out Away

Jock Menefee, Kansas City’s fifth starter, started against Houston and retired the first 26 batters, striking out 11 on the way and doing it so efficiently that he entered the 9th having thrown only 95 pitches. Carlos Correa grounded out weakly back to the mound and George Brett was Menefee’s 12th strikeout victim, bringing the 40,962 fans in attendance to their feet, holding their collective breath. Jim O’Rourke absolutely smoked the first pitch dealt to him, sending it back the other way at 115 mph and into the outfield for a clean single, releasing a collective moan from the crowd.

That brought Craig Biggio to the plate as the tying run, but he flew out to left to end it.

Menefee’s final line: 9 innings, 1 hit, no walks, 12 strikeouts, 111 pitches. Both Kansas City runs came in the 5th off Stephen Strasburg on a single by Boog Powell and a bases-loaded walk to Albert Pujols.

HOU 0 (Strasburg 3-1) @ KAN 2 (Menefee 2-2)
HRs: none.
Box Score

#The Next Day …

… Roger Clemens and Smokey Joe Wood would face off, and neither team could touch either ace. Clemens and Wood each survived a near-hour-long rain delay to throw 8 scoreless innings (Clemens 4 hits and 6 strikeouts, Wood 3 and 7), and the bullpens took over from there, keeping the game scoreless through the 15th, meaning Houston had now gone 24 innings without scoring against the Monarchs.

In the 16th, pinch-hitter Craig Biggio walked, Jeff Bagwell singled him to third, and Paul Goldschmidt singled him home. That was enough: Houston’s Sparky Lyle closed the game out for his 6th save of the year.

HOU 1 (Kern 1-0; Lyle 6 Sv) @ KAN 0 (Thatcher 0-1) [16 Innings]
HRs: none.
Box Score

#The Stars At Night

No, not more about Houston. Instead, we take a glance at the emergent juggernaut of the Philadelphia Stars‘ staff. The New York Gothams came into the week leading the WBL in scoring at 5.24 runs a game. They left Philadelphia managing only 13 hits over 3 games. And no–zero, nada, zilch–runs.

Philadelphia right now is a staff missing its ace due to Charles Rogan‘s injury. Steve Carlton has stepped right into a leading role, with 5 victories and a sub-3.00 ERA coming into the series.

The opener saw Ray Collins (7 innings, 3 hits) beat New York’s Christy Mathewson, who had been 6-0. Chase Utley‘s RBI triple in the 3rd and Harmon Killebrew‘s 2-run homer (his 12th) in the 6th were all Philadelphia needed, and Ryan Madson and Mark Melancon (his 5th save as he deputizes for the injured Bob Howry) finished the 3-0 win.

The next day Hardie Henderson went the distance: 5 hits, 2 walks, 9 strikeouts, 137 pitches, and no runs allowed in a 6-0 victory. Bill Dickey drove in 4, with a 2-run homer in the 2nd and a 2-run single in a 4-run 7th that Willie Davis capped with his first homerun of the year.

In the finale Carl Hubbell matched Carlton through 6 scoreless innings, but we’ve already revealed how it ends. Utley broke it open with a 2-run homer (his 3rd) in the 7th. Carlton went 8.1 innings (4 hits, no walks, 11 strikeouts, 130 pitches) and joined Mathewson atop the WBL with 6 wins.

NYG 0 (Mathewson 6-1) @ PHI 3 (Collins 2-2; Melancon 5 Sv)
HRs: NYG – none; PHI – Killebrew (12).
Box Score

NYG 0 (Sutton 2-3) @ PHI 6 (Henderson 2-3)
HRs: NYG – none; PHI – Dickey (4), Davis (1).
Box Score

NYG 0 (Raschi 1-2) @ PHI 3 (Carlton 6-1; Melancon 6 Sv)
HRs: NYG – none; PHI – Utley (3).
Box Score

Philadelphia has the best record in the NL, and leads the Effa Manley Division by 2.5 games.

#Performance

#Team Performance

Figured it was time to glance at how the stats were building up at the team level.

First, in a sentence nobody saw coming, Memphis has the best record in the WBL (25-13). They are not doing it with mirrors, sporting the best run differential (+68), leading the league in runs per game (5.71), and in OPS (.813). AND, they lead the league in overall ERA (3.22) and bullpen ERA (2.49). Dominance. Totally unexpected, and, if it holds, a significant message about just how thoroughly a team can be transformed in a single offseason.

On the mound, they are joined by Kansas City, who lead the league in WHIP (1.09) and in BA allowed (a minuscule .210), Houston (2nd-best ERA at 3.25, a full .40 in front of the #3 team) and, perhaps surprisingly, Ottawa (pedestrian-looking numbers, but the second-best FIP in the WBL, behind Kansas City).

Memphis is 2nd in the WBL in homers, trailing–who else–the New York Black Yankees, who have 68 to the Red Sox’s 62. The Big Apple’s 3 teams sit 2-4 in the league in OPS, with the Black Yankees, the Gothams, and the Brooklyn Royal Giants all between .779 and .789.

And then we have the other end of the lists.

Kansas City has hit only 25 homeruns on the year, with Houston and the Birmingham Black Barons the only other teams with under 40. Baltimore is pretty miserable offensively across the board, last in the league in BA (.206, .019 worse than Houston) and OPS (.628, .025 worse than, yes, Houston). Unlike Houston, Baltimore is just bad, last in the league in WHIP (1.45, with Detroit and Birmingham at 1.39 and 1.40), tied with the House of David for last in BA allowed (.264), and last in ERA at 5.42, with only Detroit joining them over 5.00.

#Player Performance

Six weeks in, qualifying is 3.1 plate appearances or 1 inning per team game: about 115 PA and 37 innings.

#Batters

Ted Williams leads the WBL in batting average, on-base, slugging, homeruns, runs, RBI, walks, hits and WAR. Doubles, triples and steals belong to others.

John Briggs (MEM). 238/315/462. 15 2B.
Dan Brouthers (BRK). 374/422/634.
Pete Browning (HOD). 369/420/553. 52 H, 11 SB.
Oscar Charleston (IND). 303/342/690. 16 HR, 38 RBI, 2.4 WAR.
Eric Davis (NYY). 262/373/438. 30 R, 12 SB.
Hank Greenberg (DET). 269/346/504. 4 3B.
Rickey Henderson (SFS). 226/331/339. 12 SB.
Grant Johnson (NYG). 348/381/674. 48 H, 10 HR, 15 2B.
Joe Morgan (IND). 252/426/411. 32 BB.
Jackie Robinson (BRK). 341/388/541. 16 2B.
Babe Ruth (NYY). 237/387/605. 12 HR, 26 BB.
Chino Smith (CAG). 290/331/718. 15 HR, 35 R, 37 RBI, 2.2 WAR.
Ted Williams (MEM). 417/537/945. 20 HR, 44 R, 50 RBI, 34 BB, 53 H, 3.5 WAR.

#Pitchers

#Starters

Christy Mathewson lost for the first time this year, and Steve Carlton joins him at 6 wins. Charles Radbourn‘s 1.43 ERA leads the league; Dwight Gooden leads in FIP and WAR, despite a 3.80 ERA.

Brett Anderson (HOD). 5-2, 2.49.
Ray Brown (HOM). 2-1, 2.15.
Steve Carlton (PHI). 6-1, 2.50. 61 K.
Dwight Gooden (LAA). 2-2, 3.80. 1.90 FIP, 2.0 WAR.
Lefty Grove (SFS). 5-1, 2.87. 76 K, 59 IP.
Walter Johnson (POR). 3-3, 2.55. 72 K, 0.91 WHIP.
Christy Mathewson (NYG). 6-1, 2.93. 70 K, 55 IP.
Jock Menefee (KAN). 2-2, 2.51. 0.81 WHIP, 2.22 FIP.
Charles Radbourn (OTT). 3-1, 1.43. 0.91 WHIP, 2.27 FIP, 1.7 WAR.
Toad Ramsey (HOU). 2-3, 3.33. 2.80 FIP, 1.6 WAR.
Tom Seaver (MEM). 3-1, 1.54.
Smokey Joe Wood (KAN). 3-1, 2.32. 54 IP, 0.77 WHIP.

#Relievers

Brian Wilson and Eric Gagné lead with 10 saves each. Detroit’s Mike Henneman has 8, with a 9.82 ERA. Several relievers, led by Memphis’ Tommy de la Cruz (4-0, 1.23), have 4 wins, but aren’t listed below.

Rate stats below require 10 IP, meaning Ottawa’s Billy Koch qualifies without allowing a run so far this year. Both Chicago‘s Joe Horlen (now in the rotation) and Birmingham’s Kerry Ligtenberg were touched for their first runs this past week, but both remain dominant so far.

Rod Beck (SFS). 1-2, 3.75. 8 Sv.
Jack Billingham (POR). 1-2, 3.46. 8 Sv.
Chad Bradford (DET). 3-2, 3.18. 6 Hld.
Jeurys Familia (LAA). 2-0, 2.45. 6 Hld.
Eric Gagné (BRK). 1-0, 0.64. 10 Sv, 45.5% K.
Mike Henneman (DET). 0-2, 9.82. 8 Sv.
Joe Horlen (CAG). 1-1, 0.34.
Billy Koch (OTT). 1-0, 0.00. 1 Sv, 2 Hld.
Kerry Ligtenberg (BBB). 1-0, 0.47. 1 Sv, 5 Hld.
Ryan Madson (PHI). 2-1, 1.02. 1.02 FIP.
Jeff Pfeffer (LAA). 0-1, 1.47. 8 Sv.
Johan Santana (POR). 1-1, 0.83. 31 K in 21.2 innings.
Vito Tamulis (NYG). 1-1, 5.40. 6 Hld.
Brian Wilson (NYG). 1-1, 1.46. 10 Sv.

#Hardest Shots

Three balls left the bat at 121 mph this week, all solo homeruns: Mike Schmidt (New York Black Yankees), Paul Molitor (Portland) and Hank Aaron (Birmingham).

The hardest out was Ted Williams‘ 121-mph ground ball to second.

#Longest Homeruns

Kansas City’s Doug Rader hit the second-longest homerun of the season, a 505-foot 2-run shot. Willie McCovey (Cleveland) hit one 485 feet, and Rico Carty‘s grand slam against Memphis went 484.

#Injuries

The Wandering House of David lost Jim Clinton (2.88 ERA over his first 4 starts) for about a year. The Gothams’ Mike Norris, 37 and the 2000 Reliever of the Year, is out 4-5 months. Birmingham lost two relievers for about 3 months each: setup man Akinori Otsuka, and Alejandro Peña, who tore a finger tendon on a rehab assignment.

See the team notes for details and related roster moves.

TWIWBL 102.1: Year 3, Week 5 – One Month In!

6 May, 2002

And we enter the second month of the season! Whoo Hoo!

Which means we have monthly awards for the first time, and we have our first review of the early standings.

#Awards

Miami‘s Robin Yount is the AL Player of the Week, hitting .450 with 2 homeruns, 6 runs and 5 RBI, and slugging an even 1.000. Yount is up to .283 with 6 homeruns and 12 doubles on the year.

The NL Player of the Week goes to Grant Johnson of the New York Gothams for the second week running: Johnson hit .409 with 3 homeruns, 3 doubles and 7 RBI while slugging .955. Overall, he’s hitting .379 with 9 homeruns and a league-leading 15 doubles.

In the minors: Freddie Lindstrom (Chicago American Giants) took the award at AAA Milwaukee, where the 21-year-old third baseman is hitting .306 with 7 homeruns, making his early demotion seem a bit of a mistake in judgement by the American Giants; Raúl Mondesi (Wandering House of David) won at AA Albuquerque, and Al López (Brooklyn) at A-ball Albany, where the 33-year-old catcher is hitting .426.

#April Awards

The first month is in the books, and one name on the list is no surprise at all.

Ted Williams (Memphis) is the AL Batter of the Month, having hit .437 with 14 homeruns, 30 runs and 34 RBI in April while slugging an even 1.000. Grant Johnson takes the NL award–not a surprise given the above.

Waite Hoyt (Chicago) is the AL Pitcher of the Month, going 4-1 with a 2.45 ERA and 40 strikeouts in 36.2 innings. For a team whose primary weakness was dependable starting pitching, the acquisition of Hoyt sure looks like good work for Chicago.

Over in the NL, the Pitcher of the Month goes to one of Johnson’s teammates on the Gothams, Christy Mathewson. Seemingly returning to his 2000 form, Matty has started the season perfectly, going 6-0 with a 2.27 ERA.

Whitey Ford (New York Black Yankees) went 3-2 with a 2.25 ERA in April, earning the AL Rookie of the Month Award, and in the NL, Philadelphia‘s Harmon Killebrew is the Rookie of the Month, despite only hitting .255. 9 homeruns in a calendar month will do that.

The minors have their own monthly awards too, of course.

At AAA, Roger Maris of the New York Black Yankees was the Batter of the Month, hitting .418 with 11 homeruns at Newark, and Mike Scott (Los Angeles) won the Pitcher of the Month, going 4-1 with a 1.98 ERA. Cody Bellinger (Wandering House of David) hit .404 at AA Albuquerque and Hugh Mulcahy (Homestead) went 3-0 with a 1.93 at AA Syracuse. At A-ball, John Bass (Philadelphia) hit 10 homeruns and Fred Gladding (Indianapolis) allowed only 2 earned runs in 15.1 innings, as they took home the monthly honors.

#Team Performance

I know it’s early. You know it’s early. Still, it is May. And that’s no longer April, right?

The best records in the WBL belong to two surprise teams: Memphis leads the Bill James Division and Philadelphia tops the Effa Manley, each with a 20-11 record–that’s a .645 clip.

Ottawa (a game behind Philadelphia) and Chicago (leading the Cum Posey Division) are the only other teams playing over .600 ball.

The Baltimore Black Sox sit at the other end of the scale, already 11.5 games out in the Bill James Division, sitting at 8-22. But they aren’t the only major disappointments: both Birmingham and Indianapolis are only winning at a .333 clip (10-20).

Full standings are at the top of each divisional page for the curious.

#Player Performance

Five weeks in, qualifying is 3.1 plate appearances or 1 inning per team game — about 96 PA and 31 innings.

Some early season streaks of note: The Gothams’ Grant Johnson has a 15 game hitting streak going and Memphis’ Ted Williams has reached base in 30 straight. On the mound, Chicago’s Joel Horlen hasn’t allowed a run in 23 innings and Kansas City’s Smokey Joe Wood in 14.

#Batters

Ted Williams is still the story, and it is getting harder to describe without sounding like an advertisement: he leads the WBL in batting average, on-base, slugging, homeruns, runs, RBI, walks and WAR, outright. That only leaves 2B, 3B, and SB for others.

This list should reduce a little over time, but it’s got some decent WBL storylines in it–the resurgence of a healthy Pete Browning, Rico Carty‘s deal with the devil to combat his age, Cool Papa Bell giving Rickey Henderson some competition for the SB crown, etc.

But it’s really all about The Splendid Splinter for now.

Ernie Banks (HOD). .225/.299/.549. 9 HR, 27 RBI.
Cool Papa Bell (KAN). .204/.295/.280. 10 SB.
Dan Brouthers (BRK). .369/.416/.612. 11 2B.
Pete Browning (HOD). .331/.389/.508. 10 2B, 9 SB.
Rico Carty (PHI). .374/.442/.670.
Oscar Charleston (IND). .300/.341/.642. 12 HR, 29 RBI, 1.9 WAR.
Roberto Clemente (HOM). .372/.413/.698. 7 HR.
Ty Cobb (DET). .345/.390/.708. 10 HR, 2.0 WAR.
Eric Davis (NYY). .260/.353/.452. 8 SB.
Lou Gehrig (NYY). .288/.373/.635. 25 RBI.
Hank Greenberg (DET). .272/.348/.476. 4 3B.
Bobby Grich (BBB). .202/.362/.279. 22 BB.
Rickey Henderson (SFS). .229/.333/.365. 9 SB.
Grant Johnson (NYG). .379/.402/.741. 9 HR, 15 2B, 1.6 WAR.
Harmon Killebrew (PHI). .275/.325/.569. 10 HR.
Willie Mays (NYG). .289/.344/.588. 25 R.
Joe Morgan (IND). .253/.405/.374. 23 BB.
Jackie Robinson (BRK). .336/.381/.509. 14 2B.
Babe Ruth (NYY). .232/.387/.611. 11 HR, 21 BB.
Chino Smith (CAG). .292/.324/.736. 13 HR, 30 R, 32 RBI.
Mike Trout (LAA). .300/.349/.567. 12 2B.
Ted Williams (MEM). .419/.533/.914. 15 HR, 33 R, 39 RBI, 27 BB, 2.7 WAR.

#Pitchers

#Starters

There’s nowhere near the single person dominance on the mound–early days, of course, but it looks like we may have some good years on the mound coming.

Brett Anderson (HOD). 4-2, 2.84.
Steve Carlton (PHI). 4-1, 2.56. 41 K.
Don Drysdale (MEM). 2-1, 2.48. 49 K.
Bob Feller (CLE). 1-4, 4.58. 52 K.
Whitey Ford (NYY). 3-2, 3.19. 2.94 FIP.
Ned Garvin (BAL). 1-2, 4.10. 50 K, .208 BABIP.
Lefty Gomez (BBB). 2-4, 2.82. 2.30 FIP.
Dwight Gooden (LAA). 2-2, 4.30. 1.96 FIP, 1.7 WAR.
Lefty Grove (SFS). 3-1, 3.47. 62 K.
Waite Hoyt (CAG). 4-1, 2.52. 42 K, 2.60 FIP.
Walter Johnson (POR). 3-3, 2.76. 64 K, 2.66 FIP.
Christy Mathewson (NYG). 6-0, 2.74. 64 K, 49.1 IP.
José Méndez (MCG). 3-2, 2.57. 0.93 WHIP.
Joseíto Muñoz (POR). 2-0, 2.55. 46 K, 2.48 FIP.
David Price (HOM). 2-1, 2.90. 0.94 WHIP.
Charles Radbourn (OTT). 3-1, 1.57. 2.28 FIP, 1.5 WAR.
Toad Ramsey (HOU). 2-3, 3.24. 50 K, 2.53 FIP, 1.5 WAR.
Tom Seaver (MEM). 2-1, 1.59.
J.M. Ward (PHI). 4-2, 3.51. .213 BABIP.
Jim Whitney (MCG). 1-1, 3.40. 54 K, 0.86 WHIP.
Smokey Joe Wood (KAN). 3-0, 2.23. 47 K, 0.69 WHIP, 2.31 FIP.

#Relievers

Rate stats still want another week or two. The saves and holds:

Rod Beck (SFS). 1-2, 4.09. 7 Sv.
Dellin Betances (HOD). 2 Sv, 4 Hld.
Jack Billingham (POR). 3.60. 7 Sv.
Chad Bradford (DET). 2-2, 3.68. 5 Hld.
Jeurys Familia (LAA). 3.21. 5 Hld.
Eric Gagné (BRK). 0.75. 8 Sv.
Andrew Miller (MEM). 1.26. 6 Sv.
Jonathan Papelbon (MCG). 3.27. 7 Sv.
Eustaquio Pedroso (MCG). 4.87. 4 Hld.
Vito Tamulis (NYG). 3.38. 6 Hld.
Kent Tekulve (NYG). 2-0, 4.76. 5 Hld.
Brian Wilson (NYG). 1.74. 9 Sv.

Note that the Gothams may be back on track in their quest to rebuild their bullpen.

Two arms have yet to allow a run at all: Birmingham’s Kerry Ligtenberg over 16.1 innings, with 21 strikeouts and 4 hits allowed, and Chicago’s Joe Horlen over 20.2.

#Hardest Shots

Birmingham’s Eddie Mathews hit the hardest ball of the season so far, a 126 mph solo homerun. Mathews doesn’t hit many balls, but at least that one was a freaking rocket. Cleveland‘s Ed Bailey and Birmingham’s Bobby Grich also hit balls over 120 mph.

The hardest out belonged to a pitcher: Jim Whitney (Miami) flew out to center at 118 mph.

#Injuries

Houston‘s outfield took another hit–with Tony Gwynn already sidelined, the eternally underappreciated Jim Wynn will miss 2-3 weeks.

Frank Grant of the San Francisco Sea Lions is out a couple weeks and some other important names (Ottawa’s Gary Peters, Cleveland’s Louis Santop, Kansas City‘s Rube Foster, and Homestead’s Ricardo Rincón) will each miss about a week.

TWIWBL 99.4: Year 3, Week 2 – Effa Manley Division

TeamW/LPctGB
Philadelphia Stars10-3.769—
New York Gothams7-5.5832.5
Homestead Grays7-6.5383
Ottawa Mounties6-6.5003.5
Brooklyn Royal Giants5-8.3855
Effa Manley Division | 15 April

Brooklyn Royal Giants

Some roster churn in Brooklyn: Trevor Hildenberger began MiL rehab assignment while Nap Rucker heads to the DL. Eustace “Doc” Newton was recalled from AAA.

New York Gothams

Grant “HR” Johnson has been mashing, hitting 3 doubles in a 16-12 win over Indianapolis.

Dave Righetti–brought over in the same deal that netted Johnson–combined with George Jeffcoat, Vito Tamulis, and Brian Wilson on a 3-hit shutout of the ABC’s the next day, with New York taking the game, 4-0.

Willie Mays hit 2 out against the ABC’s the next day, the only bright spot in a 19-5 drubbing of a loss–a game so bad that Johnson pitched the back end, giving up 7 runs in true mop up duty, but preserving some arms in the beleaguered Gothams’ pen.

The staff did it again later in the week, with Pete Donohue, Masahiro Tanaka, Kent Tekulve, and Wilson holding Kansas City to 3 hits over 10 innings, with the Gothams winning on a Jimmy Sheckard single in the 10th.

Tip O’Neill began a rehab assignment, which should become a more interesting story in about a week. O’Neill is a legitimate 2-way player, and a Rule V choice, so New York may have some decisions to make when he’s ready to be activated.

Ottawa Mounties

Gary Carter had 3 homeruns and 6 RBIs in an 11-2 drubbing of Brooklyn.

Philadelphia Stars

Andrew Payne was recalled to provide some late inning defense after Sherry Magee hit the DL. Payne stepped up to the first PA of his WBL career and launched a 481 foot moonshot off Sandy Koufax for the go-ahead run in a 3-2 win over Brooklyn. Sure, Koufax provided most of the velocity but still .. that ball might still be rolling.

Bullet Joe Rogan just keeps rolling on, as the 2-way star hit 2 homeruns against Brooklyn in a game Harmon Killebrew eventually won with a walkoff shot. Killebrew would add 2 more in a game later in the week, blasting a pair of solo shots in a 6-5 loss to Homestead.

Year III Season Preview: New York Gothams

▌ State of the Franchise

team logo

The Gothams are the 3rd team in their own city, behind a Brooklyn club that just won it all and the rich/arrogant Yankees up the road. 2001 was a wake-up call — after winning 87 games, they plummeted to 75-87 and last in the Effa Manley Division, 24 games back.

The top of the roster is not the problem. Willie Mays hit 49 home runs at 24 and was worth 4.4 wins. Buster Posey hit 39 from behind the plate and was worth 4.2. Will Clark put up a .952 OPS, Johnny Callison hit 39 more, and all 4 are 24 to 29 years old.

The problem is … well … everything else. Shortstop gave New York 442 plate appearances of 221/268/381. Third base needed 7 different men before Jim Ray Hart claimed it in the 2nd half, and it’s not like he set the world on fire. Left field was a hole until Don Buford was bought at the deadline, and Jimmy Sheckard, a 4-WAR outfielder in 2000, hit .172 in the WBL and finished the year at Triple-A.

And the rotation wasn’t much better — Christy Mathewson keeps giving both ace potential and thoroughly average performances, and the bullpen — the pride of the club in 2000 — was showing its age. So the Gothams tore it all down (which may mean, panicked uncontrollably, or may mean made a smart investment in their future).

Juan Marichal, Robb Nen, Troy Percival and Steve Howe all went out at the deadline; then, in January, the Gothams sent Gaylord Perry — its own 2001 WAR leader — up the road to the Yankees for HR Johnson, Dave Righetti, a 1st-round pick and a 3rd. Johnson is an infielder, and may offer some long-sought-after stability there.

▌ 2001 Revisited

We asked for a deep playoff run, much like last year, and added a note about the Gothams’ habit of trading away all their damn picks. They went 75-87.

The worst case we sketched was that the bullpen falters, and only Matty remains viable as a starter while everyone not named Mays and Posey struggles offensively. That was close, and still too kind. The bullpen didn’t falter so much as get sold for parts. Mays and Posey did carry the offense. And Mathewson was the one who faltered.

Which is where 2001 gets strange. Mathewson went 7-16 with a 5.61 ERA, and he was the best pitcher on the staff: 210 innings, 207 strikeouts, 4.0 WAR at 22, a figure that actually rose from the year he led the league in wins. Don Sutton went 17-8 with a 5.23 and was worth 1.9. Same rotation, same season, 2 records that just add to the lack of internal clarity.

The best case wanted Perry or Marichal to step forward and join Mathewson among the league’s elite. Perry did have a decent year — a 1.13 WHIP across 211 innings, but went packing when the Black Yankees came knocking. Benny Kauff, who the preview wondered how they’d find at-bats for, found them, made the All-NL 2nd Team, and was traded in March.

A lot of churn. But it’s not clear the Gothams are any better.

▌ Key Changes

In: Grant Johnson (NYY); Dale Murphy (KAN); Dave Righetti (NYY)

Out: Dellin Betances (FA); Benny Kauff (KAN); Tony Mullane (FA); Gaylord Perry (NYY); Robby Thompson (NYY)

Opening Day Rookies: Santiago Casilla; Dick Dietz; George Jeffcoat; Doggie Miller; Buck O’Brien; Vito Tamulis; Masahiro Tanaka

▌ Best Case for 2002

The middle fills in. HR Johnson, 26, takes second base and hits the way he did in Houston; Hart holds third; Brandon Crawford finds enough of a bat to go with the glove, or somebody takes the job from him. That alone is worth several wins, because the 4 men at the top are already producing at a playoff standard.

Mathewson’s record catches up to his arm. Righetti, 24 and coming off a 2.5-WAR season in the Bronx, gives the rotation a 2nd real starter, and Pete Donohue — 22, a 3.61 across 120 innings at Triple-A and a NL 21 & Under Team pick — turns his September look into a rotation spot.

And the bullpen rebuilds itself from inside. Brian Wilson is still an elite closer when healthy, George Jeffcoat saved 32 games at Hartford, Santiago Casilla was untouchable there. So perhaps the identity returns.

▌ Worst Case for 2002

Johnson is the latest name on a long list. New York has spent 3 years betting on the undervalued bat — Pinky Higgins, John Kerins, Matt Williams, Pete Runnels, Carl Furillo, Wes Westrum — and the bets keep landing in the same unremarkable middle. If Johnson doesn’t hit, the club will have sold its best pitcher to the richest team in its own city for another meh return.

Mathewson doesn’t take the step, Sutton’s ERA finally catches his record, and the rotation behind them is a 26-year-old with a 5.75 and a set of Triple-A arms. Dale Murphy hit .193 in Kansas City last year and is the insurance in center. Crawford keeps the shortstop job by default. A 75-win team wins 75 games again.

▌ Key Questions

  • Does HR Johnson hit? He is 26, he plays the position New York has needed for 3 years, and he cost the club a pitcher who had just led it in WAR. Johnson produces and the trade is the cleverest thing the Gothams have done. Get him wrong and it is an all-too-familiar mistake.
  • Will the real Matty please stand up? He has now led the league in wins and, a year later, in losses, with his WAR going up in between. Read that again. At 22 with 207 strikeouts he has every ingredient of a front-line starter and a 5.61 to explain away. The org has never been sure whether it has an ace or a very good innings-eater. It would be nice to know.
  • Can the left side of the infield be fixed from inside? Shortstop and third combined for less production than most clubs get from a single player. Johnson will swing across these positions, but someone else needs to contribute here as well.

▌ Roster Evaluation

Tier = the player’s 2001 positional grade (S best → F worst; color coded S A B C D F). Bold names carry a substantive WBL track; italic names are pure projection — a hope, not a grade — with no qualifying track to anchor them.

PosPlayers
CPosey A · Dietz
1BClark B
2BJohnson · Doyle B
SSCrawford F
3BHart
LFBuford D · Sheckard
CFMays A · Murphy F
RFCallison C
DHDoyle B · Dietz
SPMathewson D · Sutton C · Hubbell F · Righetti · Donohue · Tanaka
RPWilson B (CL) · Norris B · Casilla · Tamulis · Tekulve · Jeffcoat

Dick Dietz was among the better backup bats in the league, which on most rosters is a luxury and on this one is a way to get a real hitter into a lineup that runs out of them by the 6th spot. And Mike Norris, 37 and the club’s Fan Favorite, is almost certainly taking his last lap — which may be cut off early, as age catches up with the 2000 Reliever of the Year in the WBL.

▌ Talent Ratings

WBLMinors
Raw Power2B HR JohnsonCF Dwayne Murphy
Batting EyeC Dick DietzCF Dwayne Murphy
ContactLF Tip O’NeillCF Fred M Lewis
Running SpeedCF Willie MaysCF George Van Haltren
Base StealingLF Jimmy Sheckard; 2B HR JohnsonSP Al Spalding; CF George Van Haltren
IF DefenseSS Brandon Crawford2B Whitey Wietelmann
OF DefenseCF Willie MaysRF Mike Tiernan
StuffRP Grant BalfourRP Henry Rodríguez
ControlSP Pete DonohueSP Al Spalding
VelocityRP Grant BalfourRP Derrick Turnbow

▌ Best In The Minors

RankAgePosName
1 (27)18SPAmos Rusie
2 (61)26CFDwayne Murphy
3 (76)23SPWilliam VanLandingham

Graduated to the active roster since the ranked list: Masahiro Tanaka (77).

Others: IF Carlos Baerga, IF Alvin Davis, IF Howard Johnson, OF Tully Hartsel.

3 names on the ranked list, and the Gothams know exactly how it got that way — last year’s preview asked them to stop trading away all their damn picks, and they spent 2001 trading more of them. Amos Rusie is the exception and a real one: 18 years old and 27th in all of baseball.

Underneath, the system is infielders the club is hoping into relevance. Carlos Baerga, 19, came from Kansas City in the Kauff deal; Howard Johnson and Davey Johnson arrived from Homestead for Marichal and Nen. At least the January trade brought back picks instead of spending them.

▌ Superlatives

MostLeast
AgeMike Norris, 37Amos Rusie, 18
HeightRon H Jackson, 6’7″Tully Hartsel, 5’5″
OPSWill Clark, .952Cliff Bolton, .534 (A)
HRWillie Mays, 49George Van Haltren, 0 (AA)
SBTim Shinnick, 72 (A)–
WAR (bat)Willie Mays, 4.4George Van Haltren, −1.2 (AA)
WDon Sutton, 17–
SVGeorge Jeffcoat, 32 (AAA)–
ERAWillie Banks, 3.37 (A)Tully Sparks, 6.10 (AAA)
WAR (pit)Pete Donohue, 4.5 (AAA)Wandy Rodríguez, 0.3 (A)

Stats across all levels, 2001 season. 200 PA / 75 IP minimum. Non-WBL levels tagged in parentheses.

WBL Year III Statistics

I needed a place to hold statistics that aren’t easily displayed in OOTP. Most of these are game-level performances.

For complete statistics, poke around on the WBL Stats Page.

Batting Statistics

2+ 3B Games

3+ 2B Games

3. Lou Gehrig (NYY); Grant Johnson (NYG); Al Kaline (DET); JD Martinez (DET); Jackie Robinson (BRK); Robin Yount (MCG).

3+ HBP Games

3. Melky Cabrera (BBB).

3+ HR Games

3. Gary Carter (OTT); Oscar Charleston (IND); Lou Gehrig (NYY); Rogers Hornsby (NYY); Babe Ruth (NYY).

3+ OF Assists

4+ BB Games

4+ CS Games

4+ Run Games

4. Johnny Bates (CLE); Oscar Charleston (IND); Eddie Collins (CAG); Babe Ruth (NYY); Andy Van Slyke (HOM); Roy White (BRK); Ted Williams x3 (MEM).

4+ SB Games

5+ Hit Games

6. Rogers Hornsby (NYY).
5. Dan Brouthers (BRK); Joe Morgan (IND); Charles Rogan (PHI); Andy Van Slyke (HOM).

5+ SO Games

5. Lou Gehrig (NYY); Evan Longoria (CLE); Rick Monday (OTT); Ron Santo (HOD).

6+ RBI Games

8. Lou Gehrig (NYY); Rogers Hornsby (NYY).
6. Gary Carter (OTT); Lou Gehrig (NYY); Elrod Hendricks (HOD); Grant Johnson (NYG); Arky Vaughan (CLE).

Cycles

Ty Cobb (DET).

Longest HRs

{ OOTP has, for a long time had a problem with surreally long HR distances. So we threw math at it–these distances are modified based on the game’s projected exit velocity, which puts a cap on how far the ball could actually travel. Far more realistic, although these are probably still running a tad high. }

510. Chuck Klein (POR).
505. Doug Rader (KAN).
497. Willie Mays (NYG).
495. Josh Gibson (HOM).
495. Duke Snider (BRK); Willie Stargell (HOM).
490. Rogers Hornsby (NYY).
485. Willie Mays (NYG); Willie McCovey (CLE); Buster Posey (NYG); Anthony Rizzo (HOD); Ted Williams (MEM).

Pitching Statistics

80+ Game Scores

97. Jock Menefee (KAN).
94. Joseíto Muñoz (POR).
90. Whitey Ford (NYY); Smokey Joe Williams (BRK).
89. Waite Hoyt (CAG); Mickey Welch (KAN).
88. Christy Mathewson (NYG).
87. Old Hoss Radbourn (OTT).
86. Steve Carlton (PHI).
85. Dupee Shaw (OTT); Smokey Joe Wood (KAN).
84. Steve Carlton (PHI); Hardie Henderson (PHI); José Méndez (MCG); Bill Steen (CLE).
83. Walter Johnson (POR).
82. Walter Johnson (POR); JM Ward (PHI).
81. Bill Byrd (BBB); Smokey Joe Wood (KAN); Kerry Wood (HOD).
80. Watty Clark (SFS).

10+ Strikeout Games

17. Smokey Joe Williams (BRK).
16. Sid Fernandez (DET).
13. Bob Feller (CLE); Lefty Grove (SFS); Walter Johnson (POR); Christy Mathewson (NYG); Hal Newhouser (DET); Jim Whitney (MCG).
12. Lefty Gomez (BBB); Lefty Grove (SFS); Ron Guidry (NYY); Waite Hoyt (CAG); Pat Malone (CLE); José Méndez (MCG); Jock Menefee (KAN); Joseíto Muñoz (POR); Dick Redding (BRK); Jim Whitney (MCG); Smokey Joe Williams (BRK).
11. Steve Carlton x2 (PHI); Bob Feller (CLE); Ned Garvin (BAL); Bump Hadley (SFS); Hardie Henderson (PHI); Walter Johnson (POR); Christy Mathewson (NYG); Joseíto Muñoz (POR); Luis Padrón (IND); Charlie Root (DET); Red Ruffing (MEM); Tom Seaver (MEM); Bob Shawkey (KAN); Bill Steen (CLE); Smokey Joe Williams (BRK).
10. Don Drysdale x2 (MEM); Ned Garvin (BAL); Dwight Gooden (LAA); Cole Hamels (MCG); Connie Johnson (DET); Walter Johnson x2 (POR); Pat Malone (CLE); Christy Mathewson x2 (NYG); Luis Padrón (IND); Camilo Pascual (MCG); Toad Ramsey (HOU); José Rijo (LAA); Charlie Root (DET); Sam Streeter x2 (CAG); Fernando Valenzuela (BRK); Justin Verlander (DET); Jim Whitney x2 (MCG); Smokey Joe Wood x2 (KAN); Cy Young x2 (CLE).

8+ Walk Games

8. Hardie Henderson (PHI).

Shutouts

1 Hit. Mark Buehrle (CAG, 6 IP); Whitey Ford (NYY); Jock Menefee (KAN).
2 Hits. Lefty Grove (SFS, 6 IP); Joseíto Muñoz (POR); Old Hoss Radbourn (OTT); Mickey Welch (KAN).
3 Hits. Smokey Joe Williams (BRK, 5 IP)
4 Hits. Dupee Shaw (OTT).
5 Hits. Hardie Henderson (PHI).

Shutouts (Combined)

1 Hit. Old Hoss Radbourn / Kevin Gross / Ryan Dempster / Billy Koch (OTT).
3 Hits. David Price / Babe Adams (HOM, 7 IP); Charlie Root / Dick Donovan / Jason Frasor / Troy Percival (DET); Dave Righetti / George Jeffcoat / Vito Tamulis / Brian Wilson (NYG); Whitey Ford / Hoyt Wilhelm / Goose Gossage (NYY); Jock Menefee / Jeff Reardon / Lee Smith (KAN); Pete Donohue / Masahiro Tanaka / Kent Tekulve / Brian Wilson (NYG; 10 IP); Bump Hadley / Charlie Ferguson (SFS); Watty Clark / Joe Nathan (SFS); Waite Hoyt / AJ Minter (CAG); Bert Blyleven / Johan Santana / Jack Billingham (POR); Red Ruffing / Jon Lester / Bucky Walters (MEM); Brett Anderson / Scott Downs / Dellin Betances (HOD); Al Javery / Kerry Ligtenberg / Harley Young (BBB); David Price / Ricardo Rincón / Robb Nen / Josh Lindblom (HOM).
4 Hits. Mel Harder / Whit Wyatt / Ron Reed / Aroldis Chapman / Terry Adams (CLE); Brett Anderson / Jimmy Key / Dellin Betances / Karl Spooner / Ed Bauta (HOD); Toad Ramsey / Jim Kern / Billy Wagner / Tug McGraw (HOU); Smokey Joe Wood / Lee Smith (KAN); Randy Johnson / Kevin Gross / BJ Ryan (OTT); Tony Brizzolara / Tony Mullane / Rheal Cormier / Goose Gossage (NYY); Roy Oswalt / Andrew Chafin / Sparky Lyle (HOU); Ray Collins / Ryan Madson / Mark Melancon (PHI); Steve Carlton / Mark Melancon (PHI); Ed Walsh / Mark Buehrle / Raisel Iglesias / Victor Cruz (CAG).
5 Hits. Cy Young / Ron Reed / Cory Gearrin (CLE); Greg Maddux / Kerry Ligtenberg / Bruce Chen / Akinori Otsuka / Harley Young (BBB); Waite Hoyt / Wilbur Wood / Will Smith (CAG); Joseíto Muñoz / John Wetteland (POR); Gaylord Perry / Hoyt Wilhelm (NYY); Lefty Grove / Ken Howell / Mark Davis / Steve Ontiveros (SFS); Luis Padrón / Willie Mitchell / Luke Gregerson / Rob Dibble (IND); Kerry Wood / Karl Spooner / Dellin Betances (HOD); Charlie Root / Jack Wilson / Mike Henneman / Chad Bradford (DET); Tom Seaver / Jon Lester / Rollie Fingers / Andrew Miller (MEM).

TWIWBL 14.0: May 17th Indy League Update – High Indy

{ On the 17th of each month, we’ll take a look at the Independent Leagues, a three-tier system with promotion and relegation. Transactions are allowed between the Independent Leagues and the WBL teams. }

The Low and Mid Indy Leagues have barely started their seasons, but the High Indy League is about 40 games in. The High Indy is a 16 team league, where the bottom 4 teams are relegated each year.

The standings are a remarkable mess, with a very clear cause: the Durham Bulls are 2-38 on the season.

Two wins. And thirty-eight losses.

That allows four teams to have either 26 or 27 wins, with the Tampa Bay Tarpons, at 27-13, the best of the lot.

Durham has struggled through with a highly compromised pitching staff, including two hurlers–Dustin Hermanson and Euel Moore–who have been thrown out almost every day, and allowed to rack up ERA’s over 25. Hermanson is 1-12, Moore 0-9. Clearly, the league needs to intervene with the management here.

The team has had some decent offensive performers, especially in the OF from Mike A. Marshall and Whitey Witt, but also from the two-way wonder that is Kevin Seitzer. Seitzer is slashing 294/328/514 as a 3B, and is also 0-1 with a save (remember, they have 2 wins all year) as the Bulls’ closer.

Durham’s woes may be addressed, as the WBL’s New York Gothams have sent them five players–four pitchers and SS Davy Force–in exchange for young Freddie Fitzsimmons. As part of the resulting roster juggling, the Gotham’s waived Ken Boyer.

#Top Performers

Curt Motton of the Minneapolis Millers has been far and away the best player in the High Indy League, slashing along at 379/485/793 with 16 homeruns. Motton has created 2.9 WAR, better than the next-best batters by 0.7. In fact, only 3 other players–Al Oliver, Jim Landis, and Heinie Wagner–are over 2.0 WAR.

Oliver, only 23 years old, is attracting some interest from WBL teams with his 356/409/671 line, as is 22 year old 1B Freddie Freeman (351/471/623).

An all league team might look something like this:

C: Darrin Fletcher (Tampa Bay). 374/429/661.
1B: Freddie Freeman (Calgary). 351/471/623.
2B: Heinie Wagner (Lexington). 370/424/580.
3B: Matt Williams (Venice). 342/390/639.
SS: Kristopher Negron (Toledo). 303/357/620.
LF: Curt Motton (Minneapolis). 379/485/793.
CF: Al Oliver (Dallas). 356/409/671.
RF: Gene Woodling (Denver). 368/472/618.

SP: Jack Powell (Tampa Bay). 5-1, 2.04; Vito Tamulis (Venice) 2-1, 2.30; Jerry Reuss (Jacksonville) 6-1, 2.32; Jack Harshman (Denver) 6-2, 3.15.
RP: Bruce Dal Canton (Toledo) 0-1, 11 Sv, 2.08; Mike Harkey (Dallas) 0-1, 2 Sv, 1.53; Bobby Seay (Oakland) 0-1, 1 Sv, 1.77 ERA.

If limited to true prospects for WBL teams–say, players 25 and under–it would look like this (age in parens):

C: Fletcher (22).
1B: Freeman (22).
2B: Bill Doran (Boston, 24). 353/421/520.
3B: Williams (25).
SS: Don Buddin (24, Lexington). 233/350/451.
LF: Dick Wakefield (22, Calgaray). 313/386/607.
CF: Oliver (23).
RF: Nelson Cruz (24, Tampa Bay). 288/393/568.

#Boomer Report

George Scott is 4-for-8 with 3 homeruns since being traded to the Boston Pilgrims.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén